* * * Print Subscription * Conversations * Today's Paper * Going Out Guide * Jobs * Cars * Real Estate * Rentals * Classifieds * Home * Politics + Campaign 2012 + Congress + Courts & Law + The Fed Page + Health Care + Polling + White House + Blogs & Columns + Issues: Energy Top Blogs + Election 2012 | Felicia Sonmez + The Fix | Chris Cillizza + Federal Eye | Ed OâKeefe + Fact Checker | Glenn Kessler * Opinions + All Opinions + PostPartisan + Left-Leaning + Right-Leaning + Toles Cartoons + Telnaes Animations + Local + Columnist Index * Local + DC: Politics | News + MD: Politics | Communities + VA: Politics | Communities + Crime + Education + On Faith/Local + Obituaries + Traffic & Commuting + Weather + Blogs & Columns + The Root DC Top Blogs + Post Now + The Buzz + Capital Weather Gang + Dr. Gridlock * Sports + Redskins/NFL + Capitals/NHL + Wizards/NBA + Nationals/MLB + DC United/Soccer + Colleges + AllMetSports + Other Sports + Blogs & Columns Top Blogs + The Insider| Mike Jones + Capitals Insider| Katie Carrera + Wizards Insider | Michael Lee + Nationals Journal| Adam Kilgore * National + Corrections + Energy & Environment + Health & Science + Higher Education + National Security + On Faith + On Leadership + Innovations + On Giving + Blogs & Columns Top Blogs + Ideas@Innovations + Post Leadership + Under God + Checkpoint Washington * World + Africa + The Americas + Asia & Pacific + Europe + Middle East + National Security + War Zones + Special Reports + Checkpoint Washington * Business + Economy + Industries + Local Business + Markets + Policy & Regulation + Technology + World Business + Blogs & Columns + Innovations + On Small Business Top Blogs + Wonkblog | Ezra Klein + Post Tech | Cecilia Kang + Faster Forward + Where We Live * Investigations * Lifestyle + Advice + Carolyn Hax + Food + Home & Garden + Style + Travel + Weddings + Wellness + Magazine + KidsPost Top Blogs + The Style Blog + All We Can Eat + Reliable Source | Roxanne Roberts & Amy Argetsinger + On Parenting | Janice DâArcy * Entertainment + Books + Celebrities + Comics + Going Out Guide + Horoscopes + Movies + Museums + Puzzles + Theater & Dance + TV Top Blogs + TV Column | Lisa de Moraes + Celebritology | Jen Chaney + Click Track | Chris Richards & David Malitz + Comic Riffs | Michael Cavna * Multimedia + Innovations + Photos + Videos * The Washington Post The Washington Post [spacer.gif] Do Nevadaâs caucuses matter? [spacer.gif] January jobs report is win for Obama [spacer.gif] The GOP delegate race â in one chart [spacer.gif] Romney: âNot concerned about the very poorâ [spacer.gif] Poll: Romney strong in Nevada [spacer.gif] The best Nevada political tweeps * White House + A message for Obama in Komen decision? + GOP: âWe can do betterâ + Obama as most polarizing president: A rebuttal + Obama: The most polarizing president + President Obamaâs State of the Unions â in one chart View all Tag Posts * Campaign 2012 + Gingrich says he hasnât seen jobs numbers + The best Nevada music: A Fix playlist + Do Nevadaâs caucuses matter? + A message for Obama in Komen decision? + The GOP delegate race â in one chart View all Tag Posts * Senate + 4th quarter fundraising winners and losers + Scott Brown vs. Elizabeth Warren : The most expensive Senate race ever? + Kent Conrad will serve out term, denies interest in OMB job + Bob Kerrey spars with Karl Rove + Warren raised $5.7 million in 4th quarter View all Tag Posts * House + A message for Obama in Komen decision? + GOP: âWe can do betterâ + Rep. Heath Shuler to retire + 4th quarter fundraising winners and losers + Democrat Suzanne Bonamici wins Oregon special election View all Tag Posts * Governors + Scott Walker leads in Wisconsin recall poll + Kathleen Falk first candidate in Wisconsin recall race + The best 2012 governors races + Afternoon Fix: Maloney to run against Tomblin again + Can anyone stop Ovide Lamontagne? View all Tag Posts * Authors + Chris Cillizza + Aaron Blake + Rachel Weiner * Full Archive * Follow: * * * * Search The Washingto Submit ???initialComments:true! pubdate:10/17/2011 15:45 EDT! commentPeriod:3! commentEndDate:10/20/11 3:45 EDT! currentDate:2/4/12 4:0 EST! allowComments:false! displayComments:true! 44 Comments White House What John Edwards can teach Barack Obama Posted by Chris Cillizza at 03:45 PM ET, 10/17/2011 * Smaller Text Larger Text Text Size * Print * E-mail * Reprints * Share: * * * More > + Facebook + Twitter + LinkedIn + Reddit + StumbleUpon + Digg + Delicious + Google +1 John Edwards is persona non grata in the Democratic Party these days. And for good reason. [Edwards_Investigation_0c365.jpg?uuid=TwQhjvjlEeCAMtfdh-994g] FILE - In this July 14, 2011 file photo, former presidential candidate John Edwards leaves federal court following an appearance in Greensboro, N.C. (AP Photo/Gerry Broome, File)The former North Carolina senator, two-time presidential candidate and 2004 vice presidential nominee wrote his own political obituary with his marital infidelities and an ongoing investigation into campaign finance irregularities during his 2008 campaign. But, as we’ve written before, Edwards has had considerable influence on the current positioning of his party on the national political scene. Perhaps Edwards’ largest lasting legacy is his “Two Americas” speech, an address that perhaps best encapsulates the frustrations and anger coursing through the American electorate at the moment — and one that President Obama would do well to read and adapt for his own 2012 re-election campaign. (The term “Two Americas” was actually created by longtime Edwards aide Christina Reynolds.) Although Edwards had been giving some version of his “Two Americas” speech since late 2003, he drew national attention to it when he delivered it at the 2004 Democratic National Convention. It was so well received that he subsequently turned it into the centerpiece of his 2008 presidential bid. (You can read the full speech here.) Joe Trippi, the lead strategist for Edwards’ 2008 campaign, said that as that campaign wore on the other candidates in the field did everything they could to embrace the rhetorical power of “Two Americas”. “Coming down the stretch in Iowa in 2008 many of us in the Edwards campaign became worried because Obama was moving closer and closer to the ‘Two Americas’ message,” said Trippi. “Americans responded to that message in 2004. And they responded to that message in 2008. It’s even more relevant in 2012.” At its heart, “Two Americas” was an economic populist paean — driving home the sense that the distance between the haves and the have-nots was not only widening, but also that the system was somehow rigged to favor those with money and power. “We have much work to do because the truth is we still live in a country where there are two different Americas,” Edwards said in the speech. “One for all of those people who have lived the American dream and don’t have to worry and another for most Americans, everybody else who struggles to make ends meet every single day. It doesn’t have to be that way.” Edwards went on to offer a series of examples of the “Two Americas” from the health care industry to public education to jobs and the economy. “You know what happens if something goes wrong, if you have a child that gets sick, a financial problem, a layoff in the family — you go right off the cliff,” he said. “And when that happens what’s the first thing that goes? Your dreams. It doesn’t have to be that way.” Those sentiments are perhaps mor relevant today than when Edwards first uttered them nearly seven years ago. The decline in the American economy has stretched much of the country thin and contributed to an increasing sense that the game is rigged. That appears to be the central animating principle of the “Occupy Wall Street” movement and the other gatherings it has spawned across the country and across the world. The “We are the 99 percent” slogan is, really, just another way of expressing the “Two Americas” message that Edwards put into common parlance in 2004. And it’s that sentiment that the White House is hoping to tap into as President Obama tries to find a way to re-energize the Democratic base in advance of 2012. Senior White House adviser David Plouffe openly acknowledged as much to the Post’s Peter Wallsten over the weekend. “We intend to make it one of the central elements of the campaign next year,” Plouffe said of the efforts to harness the “Occupy” energy. “One of the main elements of the contrast will be that the president passed Wall Street reform and our opponent and the other party want to repeal it.” That is, of course, easier said than done. Edwards was a natural populist, the latest in a long line of (primarily southern) politicians who drew on their humble upbringings to make the case that they were the voice of the common man. (See Clinton, Bill.) (Edwards began his “Two Americas” speech by noting that his father had worked in a mill his entire life; “I still remember vividly the men and women who worked in that mill with him. I can see them. Some of them had lint in their hair; some of them had grease on their faces,” he said.) Obama is gifted at many things as a politician but populism is not one of them. He’s not terribly comfortable as a “people versus the powerful” messenger and isn’t good at faking it. His rhetoric has taken on a more populist edge of late, however, as he seeks to cast Republicans as the friend of Wall Street while painting himself as the voice of the every man. “If [Republicans] vote against these [jobs] proposals again, if they vote against taking steps now to put Americans back to work right now then they’re not going to have to answer to me, they’re going to have to answer to you,” Obama told an audience today in North Carolina. The question for many Democratic strategists, however, is whether Obama will keep up that sort of rhetoric and whether he can convince voters that he really gets their heartaches and hopes. “He is not the natural voice of the message, but because he feels the anger, and the gap has become so severe he can get there,” predicted one senior party operative. “I think Obama can do it, but needs to remind people that he passed Wall Street reform, that Wall Street is now trying to water [it] down, that he is fighting for jobs [and] that the GOP is resisting to protect the top 2 percent.” Edwards’ political career is over, done in by his own self-destructive behavior. But, the power of his “Two Americas” message can — and almost certainly would — resonate if President Obama can find a way to (in the immortal words of American Idol’s Randy Jackson) “make it his own.” More on PostPolitics Fact Checker: Axelrod’s spin gets ahead of the facts Cain: Some will pay more under 9-9-9 * Email * Tumblr * Reddit * Stumbleupon * Digg * Delicious * Tags 2012 Campaign, President Obama, John Edwards Older > Gingrich suggests Romney âclearly against the American idealâ Discussion Policy | FAQ | About Discussions Loading... Comments Add your comment Read about the changes to comment thread appearance, moderation. Read what others are saying About Badges SuperFan Badge SuperFan badge holders consistently post smart, timely comments about Washington area sports and teams. More about badges | Request a badge Culture Connoisseur Badge Culture Connoisseurs consistently offer thought-provoking, timely comments on the arts, lifestyle and entertainment. More about badges | Request a badge Fact Checker Badge Fact Checkers contribute questions, information and facts to The Fact Checker. More about badges | Request a badge Washingtologist Badge Washingtologists consistently post thought-provoking, timely comments on events, communities, and trends in the Washington area. More about badges | Request a badge Post Writer Badge This commenter is a Washington Post editor, reporter or producer. Post Forum Badge Post Forum members consistently offer thought-provoking, timely comments on politics, national and international affairs. More about badges | Request a badge Weather Watcher Badge Weather Watchers consistently offer thought-provoking, timely comments on climates and forecasts. More about badges | Request a badge World Watcher Badge World Watchers consistently offer thought-provoking, timely comments on international affairs. More about badges | Request a badge Post Recommended Washington Post reporters or editors recommend this comment or reader post. You must be logged in to report a comment. Sign in here You must be logged in to recommend a comment. Sign in here Comments our editors find particularly useful or relevant are displayed in Top Comments, as are comments by users with these badges: . Replies to those posts appear here, as well as posts by staff writers. All comments are posted in the All Comments tab. More about badges Get a badge To pause and restart automatic updates, click "Live" or "Paused". If paused, you'll be notified of the number of additional comments that have come in. Comments our editors find particularly useful or relevant are displayed in Top Comments, as are comments by users with these badges: . Replies to those posts appear here, as well as posts by staff writers. * + SHARE THIS DEBATE Latest Tweets TheFix Brett O'Donnell out as debate coach for Romney. Sign of STRICT message discipline Romney team demands. http://t.co/mTd4zN3Q — TheFix FixRachel RT @ArthurDelaneyHP: People who don't think the Huffington Post should tell the world what time the superbowl starts should go to hell. — FixRachel FixAaron Kudos to everyone tweeting Nevada-themed songs that aren't necessarily Vegas-themed! #fixplaylist — FixAaron View More Tweets Post Newsletters & Alerts Sign-up for e-mail newsletters and alerts and get the news you need delivered directly to your inbox. * [ ] Behind the Government Showdown * [ ] Afternoon Fix * [ ] Ezra Klein's Wonkbook * [ ] Federal Insider * [ ] Morning Fix * [ ] Politics News & Analysis * [ ] Politics News Alerts Enter your e-mail ad Subscribe See all Washington Post Newsletters Post Most: Politics * Most Popular 1. If recovery strengthens, Romney's pitch could be undercut 2. Obama ruling requires Catholic institutions to violate church teaching 3. For Paul and Romney, a strategic alliance between outsider and establishment 4. The Republican delegate race explained â in one chart 5. Unity eludes Nevada tea party in GOP presidential race * Top Videos 1. Obama to Congress: 'Don't muck it up' (2:00) 2. Stephen Colbert: New attack ad targeting Romney 3. Santorum on voters who think Obama is Muslim (0:41) 4. Sen. Boxer on Komen, Planned Parenthood (4:03) 5. Mitt Romney sings 'America the Beautiful' (00:56) * Top Galleries 1. The GOP presidential contenders: January 2. Mitt Romney's second run 3. Newt Gingrich's 2012 run 4. Witness Campaign: Through the eyes of the American voter 5. The things they carry WP Social Reader Hide this * Friends' Activity * Most Popular in politics * Most Popular in politics Most Popular Right Now Your Friends’ Most Recent Activity View More Activity Powered by [trove.gif] Featured Advertiser Links * L U N G C A N C E R ? Call us. L U N G C A N C E R ? Call us.>> * * HIP REPLACEMENT -- did you get one after '03? HIP REPLACEMENT -- did you get one after '03?>> * * Help Barack stand up for working Americans. Join our campaign now.>>The only candidate fighting for the middle class: Pres. Obama. Join us.>>Sign up for email updates from President Obama's 2012 campaign.>>Sign up for official email updates from Barack Obama's campaign.>> * * Looking to buy a home? Visit TWP Real Estate section for the latest open houses.>> * * Make Your Vanguard Investing More Profitable - Free Research Report Reveals Best & Worst Funds>> * Top politics Stories * People Also Read * Most Popular Videos * * * * * [spacer.gif] If U.S. economy strengthens, Mitt Romneyâs pitch could be undercut Philip Rucker [spacer.gif] Obama ruling requires Catholic institutions to violate church teaching Melinda Henneberger [spacer.gif] For Romney and Paul, a strategic alliance between establishment and outsider Amy Gardner [spacer.gif] The Republican delegate race explained â in one chart Aaron Blake [spacer.gif] Unity eludes Nevada tea party in GOP presidential race Amy Gardner; David Fahrenthold [spacer.gif] Voter frustration makes for tumultuous GOP primary Ann Gerhart [spacer.gif] For Romney campaign, race unfolding almost precisely as predicted Dan Balz [spacer.gif] Many House GOP freshmen still undecided about a presidential nominee Paul Kane [spacer.gif] January jobs report is good news for Obama Rachel Weiner [spacer.gif] Do Nevadaâs caucuses matter? Aaron Blake [spacer.gif] A message for Obama in Komen decision? Rachel Weiner National Prayer Breakfast: President Obamaâs speech transcript ::unspecified:: [spacer.gif] Romney, citing safety net, says heâs ânot concerned about the very poorâ Rachel Weiner [spacer.gif] Defiant Gingrich campaigns in Nevada against long odds David A. Fahrenthold Gingrich suggests Romney âclearly against the American idealâ Rachel Weiner [spacer.gif] Paul pursued strategy of publishing controversial newsletters, associates say Jerry Markon; Alice Crites [spacer.gif] President Obamaâs claim that some wanted to let the auto industry die Glenn Kessler Obama to announce Veterans Job Corps Steve Vogel [spacer.gif] Mitt Romneyâs Mormon advantage Aaron Blake Commerce agencyâs system infected by virus, may be victim of cyber attack Lisa Rein Ways you can get us * Mobile * Apps * Newsletter & alerts * RSS * Post Store * Facebook * Photo Store * Twitter * Washington Post Live The Washington Post * Work for us * Community Relations * PostPoints * Corrections/Suggestions * Archive * Contact the Ombudsman * Report a problem Web site * Make us your homepage * Digital Guidelines * Ask The Post Newspaper * Subscribe * Home delivery service * e-Replica Advertise * In the newspaper * On the web site * Mobile * Events The Washington Post Company * Post Company web sites Partners * Slate * Express Night Out * Captial Business * El Tiempo Latino * The Root * Foreign Policy * Trove * Post Tickets * Capitol Deal * Service Alley * Post Master Class * WP Live * Student Advisor College Reviews * © 1996- The Washington Post * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Reprints and Permissions * RSS Terms of Service * Help * Contact Us * Ad Choices [p?c1=2&c2=3005617&cv=2.0&cj=1]