#RSS Feed for Economics articles - Telegraph.co.uk < img alt="dcsimg" id="dcsimg" width="1" height="1" src="//webtrends.telegraph.co.uk/dcsshgbi400000gscd62rrg43_4o2o/njs.gif ?MLC=&Channel=&Genre=&Category=&Content_Type=&Level=&source=&dcsuri=/no javascript&WT.js=No&WT.tv=10.2.10&dcssip=www.telegraph.co.uk"/> [p?c1=2&c2=6035736&cv=2.0&cj=1] Accessibility links * Skip to article * Skip to navigation [telegraph_print_190.gif] Advertisement Telegraph.co.uk ___________________ Submit Wednesday 23 January 2013 * * News * World * Sport * Finance * Comment * Blogs * Culture * Travel * Life * Fashion * Tech * Dating * Offers * Jobs * Companies * Comment * Personal Finance * Economics * Markets * Festival of Business * Your Business * Business Club * Money Deals 1. Home» 2. Finance» 3. Economics Bank of England needs to prevent group think, former deputy governor warns The Bank of England needs to encourage a new culture that allows staff to “challenge” senior figures to prevent potentially damaging “house views” developing, a former deputy governor has urged. Picture inside the cuppolla at the side of the Bank of England. The Bank needs to allow more challenge from junior staff Photo: Julian Simmonds Philiip Aldrick By Philip Aldrick, Economics Editor 12:32PM GMT 02 Nov 2012 IFRAME: http://platform.twitter.com/widgets/follow_button.html?show_screen_name =false&show_count=true&screen_name=philaldrick Comments Comments Sir John Gieve said the failure of economic policy before the crisis at the Bank and other institutions across the world was largely the result of “group think” that needs to be stamped out. His comments at Fathom Consulting’s Monetary Policy Forum echoed those made in three reviews into the Bank’s recent performance released today. They found that “there appears to be some tendency for [staff] to filter recommendations in such a way as to maximise the likelihood that senior staff will find the recommendation palatable” and that the Bank needed to cultivate “a more assertive and experienced staff” who would “seriously challenge” policymakers. Sir John, who was deputy governor for financial stability until 2009, said: “The biggest errors of economic policy were before the crisis in allowing the boom to develop. They were the result of a remarkable degree of group think – not just in the UK. “That was a problem in the Bank, as it was in the US Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank. We need to redouble efforts to challenge orthodoxy in these institutions.” Related Articles * BoE admits its forecasts are worse than peers 02 Nov 2012 * BoE's 'hierarchical' culture attacked 02 Nov 2012 His words amounted to a call to arms for the Chancellor to ensure the right governance structures are put in place before the next Governor of the Bank takes over in June. Andrew Tyrie, chairman of the Treasury Select Committee, has called governance at the Bank “defective”. To stamp out group think, Sir John said the Bank should adopt the reviews’ proposal that it publish more detail on its economic forecasts. “How do you bring challenge into a hierarchical institution? One way of doing that is to publish more detail on the forecasts. Transparency on how they see the economy developing would be helpful in freeing up the discussion on what’s going right and what’s going wrong in its forecasts,” he said. “I think the reviews are right to suggest the Bank build in challenge to avoid house views developing.” One of the three reviews criticised the Bank’s error-ridden forecast record and suggested it publish the details of its outlook, such as the household savings rate and the output gap, to allow economists to challenge its assumptions. Eric Britton, a director at Fathom, said: “That should be out there and discussed – the way they are thinking about the world.” Sir John welcomed the reviews’ suggestion that matters could be brought up with the Court of the Bank, a group of independent directors who oversee the institution. He the Court should play “a stewardship role ... and assess whether blinkers are coming down ... and whether the architecture is working right”. However, Charles Goodhart, a former member of the Bank’s rate setting committee, told Fathom’s event that group think in the Bank has been no worse than other central banks and criticised the media’s mistaken tendency to focus on the person at the top. “If you think the Governor of the Bank was a Sun King, what do you make of [former US Federal Reserve chairman] Alan Greenspan. He would be a Sun King to the power of three,” Mr Goodhart said. “[Governor Sir] Mervyn King has been outvoted several times [on rates and money printing decisions]. You – in the media – focus so much on the man at the top. You don’t perceive how the person is influenced by those around him.” Economics * Finance » * Philip Aldrick » In Finance » George Osborne argued that Geoffrey Howe 'did not give up, but pressed on and overcame’, while Anthony Barber 'buckled and gave up’. Now the Chancellor is in Barber’s camp - Autumn Statement: The day the Chancellor reneged on his promise Autumn Statement: family tax bombshell over new black hole Top 10 coolest offices in the UK Related Partners * Save money on overseas transfers In Economics Debt crisis: live Global economy recession Britain to drop out of world's top ten economies Stock Trader Clutching His Head in Front of a Screen Showing a Stock Market Crash What's the most dangerous financial product? Aerial night view of Liverpool Street on August 6, 2007 in London UK financial sector at risk if country left EU Bail-outs 'a terrible deal' for taxpayers Advertisement telegraphuk Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. blog comments powered by Disqus Advertisement Advertisement Finance Most Viewed * TODAY * PAST WEEK * PAST MONTH 1. Britain becomes Germany's biggest trade partner as Berlin-London pact deepens 2. Revolutionary Japan is suddenly the centre of world affairs 3. UK public borrowing rises in December threatening AAA rating 4. Sir Stuart Rose named as new Ocado chairman 5. Tax rises by 19pc for UK firms despite corporation rate cut 1. Revolutionary Japan is suddenly the centre of world affairs 2. A new Gold Standard is being born 3. Blockbuster calls in administrators 4. Bundesbank to pull gold from New York and Paris in watershed moment 5. Britain becomes Germany's biggest trade partner as Berlin-London pact deepens 1. Stocks to soar as world money catches fire, Calvinst Europe left behind 2. Revolutionary Japan is suddenly the centre of world affairs 3. China blazes trail for 'clean' nuclear power from thorium 4. Waitrose boss: Britons should brace themselves for 'massive' food price hikes 5. HMRC publishes pictures of Britain's top tax cheats Advertisement MBA Courses Loading MORE FROM TELEGRAPH.CO.UK Telegraph Cottage Holidays Valentines cottage breaks from £170, book before Jan 31, 2013 for a chance to win a Kindle View Energy Switching Money-saving checklist Don't put up with high energy bills this winter. Switch to a cheaper deal in minutes View Vistaprint Vistaprint, Business Cards, Business stationary, Business, business owner Telegraph offers: free mugs, business cards, t-shirts and more View Telegraph Travel Hand-picked Seven-nights B&B at a luxury hotel in Malta View Back to top * HOME * Finance * Financial Crisis * Debt Crisis Live * Markets * Banks and Finance * City Diary * Economics * Transport * Media and Telecoms * Energy * Retail News * Consumer Tips * Insurance * Personal Finance * Your Business * Investing * Savings * Student Finance * Jobs * Job Search * Companies * China business * Money Deals * Money Transfers * Comment * Alex * Fund Game * Contact Us * Privacy and Cookies * Advertising * Fantasy Football * Tickets * Announcements * Reader Prints * * Follow Us * Apps * Epaper * Expat * Promotions * Subscriber * Syndication © Copyright of Telegraph Media Group Limited 2013 Terms and Conditions Today's News Archive Style Book Weather Forecast