Say 'no' to a Senate, the Americanisation of the UK has gone far enough, an OK competition | openDemocracy Home About Team Our Supporters Forum Donate Submit an article Contact Login | Signup × close “I will say it now: beware of my partisanship, my mistakes of fact, and the distortion inevitably caused by my having seen only one corner of events.” - George Orwell, Homage to Catalonia , 1938 View What links here Say 'no' to a Senate, the Americanisation of the UK has gone far enough, an OK competition Anthony Barnett 2 December 2010 Subjects: Ideas Democracy and government UK An all-party proposal to replace the House of Lords is about to appear. The word is that they will call for an elected chamber to be called...' The Senate'. How unoriginal can you be? An all-party proposal to replace the House of Lords is about to appear. It is being led by Nick Clegg and the guiding spirit is Jack Straw. The word is that they will call for an (eventually) elected chamber to be called ' The Senate'. How unoriginal can you be? In a pre-emptive strike against the report, Timothy Garton Ash in today's Guardian has a fine time puncturing the utterly corrupt and contemptible crony chamber we have today. He then goes on to reject the idea of its capture by the political parties as a step backwards. He is right, of course. He then comes up with his own solution. Ah, Tim, there have been so many! (Including my own modest one.) But he misses the critical point, the one which the machine that runs Westminster is well aware of. All reforms and replacements and in between schemes for the second chamber will be powerless before the executive leviathan unless and until they are set out as one entire half of parliament which has to be redefined as a whole. Leave it as it and you can fiddle (or burn) the upper half and... you are leaving the whole as it is. Peter Carty and I tried to make this obvious point in our book The Athenian Option . No, we actually did make it, more than once. Established thinking, however, prevents it from being registered. And Tim goes along with this received failure of wisdom. For example, you have to empower the Commons to be the legislative chamber, so that the second one can scrutinise it. But today, we have two legislative chambers. Retain this structure and it follows that the upper house has to be controlled by party whips. If it is taken in isolation from the Commons, there can be no democratic reform of the House of Lords Calling it a 'Senate' is a classic, spin doctors way of evading this. New Labour always wanted Britain to become like America without having to have a constitutional revolution. What could be 'more radical' than 'replacing' the Lords with a Senate? But what a betrayal of the English tradition - that we have to reach across the Atlantic to bring back a term consciously modeled on Rome so that no one mistook the new republic as looking to Greece and democracy? Surely, whatever it is, we can call it something that is rooted in our own traditions? OurKingdom will award a copy of Steve Pincus's 1688 The First Modern Revolution to the reader who suggests the best new name for a second chamber however it is organised. PS: My approach to a new upper house would include this proposal by The Earl of Clancarty from an 11 October debate (starts 3.14 pm) in the Lords: a modern reformed House of Lords should recognise that, rather than being a lesser other place, it could be celebration of public involvement in government. Rather than narrowing down politics to tighter control by professional politicians, should we not be opening up our second House to the British people? If we retain an appointments system to introduce expertise and life experience into the Lords, should it not be decoupled from party-political involvement, perhaps by bringing ordinary citizens into government of their peers through a jury system View the discussion thread. About the author Anthony Barnett ( @AnthonyBarnett ) is the founder of openDemocracy and a Co-Editor of its UK section, OurKingdom . This article is published under a Creative Commons licence. If you have any queries about republishing please contact us . Please check individual images for licensing details. Twitter Facebook Follow OurKingdom Daily email alerts: Weekly email alert: Latest events ‘What was the true Legacy of the Olympics?’: join in the debate online OurKingdom More OurKingdom comments Powered by Disqus Book Reviews Book Reviews Cruel Britannia: a secret history of torture Nicholas Mercer Dial M for Murdoch: the book to sink an empire? Bruce Page Tommy Sheridan and the myth of Scotland’s compassionate society Gerry Hassan Fight Back! - read it here OurKingdom is reading Context is everything – European Court of Human Rights struck out 99% of UK cases in 2012 Serco managers tell out-of-hours GP staff to cut 999 calls to meet targets PDF—Transparency International Report on UK police corruption warns of outsourcing risks Obama inauguration sponsors spent $160 million on political lobbying since 2009 Switzerland moves to ban mercenary companies more Privacy Licensing & Syndication Advertise Media Inquiries Vacancies RSS Feed openDemocracy Ltd, The Print House, 18 Ashwin Street, London, E8 3DL. Tel: +44 (0) 207 193 0676 openDemocracy openDemocracy X openDemocracy publishes high quality news analysis, debates and blogs about the world and the way we govern ourselves. More... Notes from the Editor-in-Chief Become a member | Week in 400 words | About the new site | Submit an article | Contact us Editor's Pick: The new Egyptian constitution: an initial assessment of its merits and flaws Zaid Al Ali Austerity, corporate tax evasion and human rights: why the anti-austerity movement needs some Lagarde lists of our own Peter Rossman Is Greece a racist state? Iannis Carras Best of the rest: Arab Awakening | Can Europe Make it? | Drug and Criminal Justice Policy Forum | OurBeeb OurKingdom OurKingdom X About us OurKingdom works to investigate and illuminate the crisis of democracy in Britain and analyse how its failings can be redressed. We encourage original debate untrammelled by party political loyalties. We ask how we as citizens can secure liberty, human rights, self-government and real democracy. ...more on OurKingdom Links Team | Contact | Submit an Article Debates OurBeeb | G4S: Securing whose world? | Uneconomics | Pick of the debates: Democratic Wealth: building a citizens' economy , edited by Stuart White , uses republican theory to explore ideas around how to democratise the economy. Co-hosted with Politics in Spires , a blog sponsored by the universities of Oxford and Cambridge. oD Russia oD Russia X openDemocracy Russia is a thoughtful platform for all those concerned about the future of the post-Soviet world. We publish indepth analysis, comment and reportage on the region — from politics and economics through to ecology and culture Partners Polit.Ru | Openspace.ru | Levada Center | Ukraine Analysis | Valdai Discussion Club Topics & debates Conflict | Culture | Euro2012 | Elections | Environment | Foreign | History | Human rights | Justice | Media | Politics | ProjectID | Religion | Regions | Russian rights at the crossroads | Stories you weren't meant to hear | USSR 20 Countries Armenia | Azerbaijan | Belarus | Georgia | Kazakhstan | Kyrgyzstan | Moldova | Russia | Tajikistan | Turkmenistan | Ukraine | Uzbekistan Latest articles on oDRussia Russia and China: aligned after all? Thomas Koenig The fable of the eagle, the dragon and the bear Pavel Salin Life on the Chinese border: Russia's Far East Olesya Gerasimenko The rise and fall of China-watching in Russia Alexander Gabuyev Russia-China relations: fantasies and reality Ben Judah 50.50 50.50 X Recent articles on 50.50 Gender wars: women redefining customs as crimes Ruth Rosen Of rights and risks: are women’s human rights in jeopardy? Maxine Molyneux A French debate on prostitution Valeria Costa-Kostritsky Fear and fury: women and post-revolutionary violence Deniz Kandiyoti 50.50 Dialogues About 50.50 50.50 is openDemocracy's section dedicated to exploring issues of gender equality and social justice at the global level. We are committed to promoting human rights and inclusive democracy through dialogue and debate. But a global debate without the female half of humanity is neither global nor democratic. With this in mind, 50.50 publishes women's analysis, insight and views on current affairs. openIndia openIndia X Plans for a new South Asia Section openIndia is no longer actively edited, however openDemocracy is developing plans for a South Asian section with the aim of building the views, arguments, energy, originality and democratic spirit of the region across the whole of openDemocracy. If you're interested in supporting this initiative through funding or editorial activities please email info@opendemocracy.net openIndia authors Articles by Rajeev Bhargava Articles by Tani Bhargava Articles by N Jayaram Articles by Kanishk Tharoor South Asian coverage on openDemocracy Bangladesh | Bhutan | Sri Lanka | Maldives | Nepal | Pakistan Latest stories from openIndia Beyond the politics of representation: the political economy of indigenous art in postcolonial India Rashmi Varma Yes to ending violence against women, but no to the ‘zero tolerance’ route Vijay Nagaraj At the root of rape is language Angshukanta Chakraborty More Spread the word Spread the word X Spread the word is a brand new section of openDemocracy's not-for-profit web platform. This space is for other not-for-profit organisations of all kinds to publicise your activities and spread the exchange of ideas. You will be able to link to all your publications, and events anywhere in the world. You will have your own openDemocracy page and all new announcements will be ticker-taped to our front page. This organisation subscription is available for a modest annual fee, dependent on the size of your organisation. Please contact Jonathan Bowles at supporters@opendemocracy.net if you are interested in joining. If you're interested in developing editorial projects on openDemocracy, please see our Editorial partnerships page We are grateful to the following organisations for their support in developing this initiative: Norwegian Peacebuilding Resource Centre Rockefeller Brothers Fund openSecurity openSecurity X Editors' pick The EU's Nobel Peace Prize DAN SMITH Neoliberalism in the American military and its impact on civilians JENNIFER MITTELSTADT The collapse of Transitional Justice MLADEN OSTOJIC openSecurity Debates Peacebuilding: southern perspectives | Beyond enemy images | Security sector reform openSecurity provides a point of interaction between the relatively closed group of people who can be said to have influence on the course of security policy, and the people in whose name they act. openSecurity on Twitter Sign up for a weekly email roundup from oS openEconomy openEconomy X openDemocracy brings you open-minded economics with a democratic perspective We're reading: Litquake » James Warner: An excess of joie de vivre Oct. 06, 2012 Silverman spreads an addiction ... A numerical habit that’s hard to kick - FT.com Oct. 04, 2012 EUobserver.com / Political Affairs / Back the EU or risk isolation, Poland warns UK Oct. 02, 2012 Excellent @gideonrachman on democracy and € crisis ... surely soltn is EU-level democracy Sep. 11, 2012 David Blanchflower: Osborne's support has drained away - David Blanchflower - Business Comment - The Independent Sep. 10, 2012 Latest stories from openEconomy Should we worry about global quasi-constitutionalization? Grahame Thompson Norman Tebbit exchange with John Mills - how to fix Britain's industry John Mills More Arab Awakening Arab Awakening X In the months following the start of the Arab Revolutions, articles and analysis poured into openDemocracy from contributors across the Middle East and Europe. Gradually, the impact of Tahrir Square began to extend well beyond the Middle East as democratic inspiration travelled from east to west. Arab Awakening tries to capture that inspiration and use it to help us read a rapidly changing world. "As students of politics is it is vital to study the power of imagination." -Professor Charles Tripp, SOAS Debates Columnists | This week's window on the Middle East Categories: | Revolution | Violent transitions | Constitutional reform | Spring of the 'others' | Geopolitics Countries: | Algeria | Bahrain | Egypt | Iraq | Israel | Jordan | Kuwait | Lebanon | Libya | Mauritania | Morocco | Oman | Palestine | Qatar | Saudi Arabia | Sudan | Syria | Tunisia | UAE | Yemen OurBeeb OurBeeb X Running May-October 2012 as an independent section of openDemocracy, OurBeeb is a digital challenge to the old order, seeking to make the BBC's next Director General truly accountable to the public, and debate the future of our BBC. This is a critical time for public service broadcasting, and the challenges of massive cuts and rapid technological change must be addressed head on. Follow OurBeeb OurBeeb weekly newsletter @our_Beeb Funded by 95% of British homes via the licence fee, the BBC belongs to the people, not the government. ourBeeb is independent, non-partisan, and aims to return the discussion about Britain's most important cultural institution to the people. AddThis