#HuffPost Search The Full Feed Latest News The Blog Featured Posts Natasha Kuilak Mellersh: Bogeymen and Blanket Surveillance Natasha Kuilak Mellersh: Bogeymen and Blanket Surveillance HuffPost's QuickRead... Loading... HuffPost's QuickRead... Loading... * Facebook * Space * Google More Log in Create Account * Notifications * + Profile + Settings + Logout 11 February 2013 uk-tech UK Edition: UK * CA Canada * FR France * IT Italia * ES Espana * US United States * UK United Kingdom Search The Huffingto Submit * FRONT PAGE * Politics + Independent Scotland Must Negotiate International Status, Lawyers Advise494 + Vince Cable: Britain Needs Rich Chinese People288 + Romanian And Bulgarian 'Surge' Must Be Stopped, Say MPs169 + 'Scotland Is Better Off In Britain'1k + Hague Accuses Argentina Of 'Bullying' Behaviour Over Falklands437 + Go to Politics More in Politics + Boris Johnson + Conservatives + Labour + Lib Dems + Westminster + Mehdi's Morning Memo * World + LOOK: Incredibly Rare Color Photos Of Paris In 1900235 + 5 Dead, 3 Injured In Spanish Cruise Ship Accident281 + Syrian Rebels And Troops Battle For Key Damascus Highway130 + LOOK: Carnaval 2.070 + Stampede Kills At Least 10 During Religious Festival348 + Go to World More in World + Foreign Affairs + World Elections + Arab Uprising + Afghanistan War + Syria Crisis + Drug War + Protecting Journalists + Iranathon + World Videos * Sport + England Beat Ireland To Keep Six Nations Grand Slam Hopes Alive (PICTURES) + Paul Gascoigne In Intensive Care205 + 'If This Doesn't, I Don't Know What Does' + 12 Clear, 12 To Go + 'I Scrapped The Changes I Planned To Make' + Go to Sport More in Sport + Premier League + Football + Racism In Football + England Football Team + England Cricket Team + Champions League + Liverpool + Man Utd You might also like + US Sports * Entertainment + BAFTAs 2013: Skyfall Is Best British Film, All The Winners Here.. 38 + BAFTAS 2013: Eddie Redmayne's Nightmare Night + GRAMMYS 2013: Adele Does It Again13 + BAFTAS 2013: On Ben Affleck's Big Night, He Reflects On 'Second Act'15 + Pasquale Leaves DOI: 'It's Been All Highs' + Go to Entertainment More in Entertainment + BAFTA Awards + The Grammys + The Oscars + TV News + TV Reviews + Film News + Film Reviews + Film Trailers + Music News * Celebrity + Grammys 2013: Katy's Got Some Front70 + Grammys 2013: Adele In 'Doesn't Wear Black' Shocker!21 + Baftas 2013: After Party + BAFTAs: Hollywood's Finest Bring The Glamour + BAFTAs: Battle Of The Red Carpet Hosts + Go to Celebrity More in Celebrity + One Direction + Harry Styles + Cheryl Cole + Tulisa + TOWIE + Rihanna + Celeb Review Of The Year + Celebrity Pictures * Comedy + Twitter's Funniest Pope Jokes + WATCH: 'Harlem Shake' Is The New 'Gangnam Style' 14 + LOOK: Cat Loves Watching Hockey On TV + WATCH: This Dog LOVES The Snow + PICTURES: Pretty Girls Pulling Ugly Faces + Go to Comedy More in Comedy + Weird News + Comedy Gossip + Viral Videos + Comedy Clips + AnimaLOL + Pics & Giggles + TopicaLOL * Culture * Lifestyle + Could Your Shortsightedness Be Genetic? 21 + 17 Quirky Valentine's Day Gift Ideas For Him And Her + And Relax...The 10 Most Scenic Drives In The UK + 8 Apps That Make Life A Little Less Complicated + Organic Food: A Waste of Money77 + Go to Lifestyle More in Lifestyle + Simplicity + Relationships + Women + Health News + Fitness + Travel + Work Life Balance + Diet + GPS For The Soul + Inspiration * Tech + WATCH: UFO Hoaxer Explains How He Faked Incredible Alien Footage15 + Asteroid 'Capable Of Flattening London' To Skim Earth78 + PICS: 'Flying V' Galactic Collision Pictured In Deep Space By Hubble + Could A Nasa Spy Satellite Reveal The Hidden 'Mini Moons' Orbiting Earth? + William Shatner Voices Dismay At Reddit's Dark Side27 + Go to Tech More in Tech + CES 2013 + Android + Apple + Google + Facebook + Space + Gaming + Gadgets + Tech 2013 You might also like + TechCrunch * Students + 32 Ridiculous Names Of People You Went To School With + 'We Spent The Weekend Ripping Up 11 Argos Catalogues' + Inanimate Carbon Rod Runs For NUS Presidency + Go to Students More in Students + Young Talent + Student News + Student Jobs + Student Living + International Students + Tuition Fees + GCSEs + Freshers' Week * MyDaily + BAFTAs 2013: Best And Worst Dressed12 + Spellbinding! Rihanna Works Her Magic In Red Gown At The Grammys24 + Fashion Overkill? Miley Cyrus Does Sheer Dress, Side Boob, AND Over Knee Boots27 + Grammys 2013: Best And Worst Dressed Nominees + BAFTAs 2013 Beauty: Helen Mirren Has Pink Hair!11 + Go to MyDaily More in MyDaily + Fashion + Beauty You might also like + Style * BLOGS + Vivi Friedgut Vivi Friedgut :The Global Trend You Don't Yet Know About! View all featured blog posts * TechCrunch * Engadget * Apple Blog Tech * CES 2013 * Android * Apple * Google * Facebook * Space * Gaming * Gadgets * Invention * Tech 2013 [blog_banner_logo.png] Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors Hot on the Blog Cherie BlairPaul McCartneyCarrie ArmstrongStella Creasy HuffPost Social Reading [loader.gif] Some error occurred * Login with Facebook to see what your friends are reading * Enable Social Reading * i [loader.gif] * * * * Settings + Read Share Settings + Share everything I read + Share only things safe for work + Dont share what I'm reading + Read Share History + Learn More Natasha Kuilak Mellersh Natasha Kuilak Mellersh Author of tashalaw, a weekly legal blog GET UPDATES FROM Natasha Kuilak Mellersh Like [DEL: :DEL] 3 Bogeymen and Blanket Surveillance Posted: 19/06/2012 00:00 React [follow-arrow.png] Amazing Inspiring Funny Scary Hot Crazy Important Weird Read more [follow-arrow.png] David Davis , Julian Huppert , Theresa May , Black Boxes , Blanket Surveillance , Breach Of Privacy , Ccdp , Communications-Capabilities-Development-Programme , Freedom , Human Rights , Internet Law , Parliament , Privacy , Security Industry , Surveillance , UK Tech News share this story Submit this story digg reddit stumble Despite warnings from digital rights groups, privacy advocates and experts in the tech world, the government has gone ahead with their plans for blanket surveillance measures on the internet, including controversial practices such as deep packet inspection (DPI). The draft Communications Capabilities Development Programme (CCDP) bill published last week proposes that individuals' data is stored using so called 'black boxes' tracking their detailed internet use i.e. every website they visit, Google search terms, emails etc. A vast amount of data can be stored in these devices and using specialist software this data can be analysed using search functions and selection methods. Currently Government Central Head Quarters (GCHQ) can access a large amount of data and conduct surveillance of specific suspects, the difference in the CCDP bill is that this data would be accessible in relation to any member of the public. The idea behind this seems to be that by conducting blanket surveillance" the authorities could catch criminals who are not yet suspects. Throwing such a wide net however would also consequently entangle innocent people and breach their privacy, while most likely only finding those criminals who lack basic internet skills. The issue here is rather who the authorities actually wish to target and where they plan to concentrate their resources, than assuming everyone is a suspected criminal. Apart from a terrifying intrusion into people's private information this would be an arduous task for police, who currently are lacking the resources to analyse comparatively low levels of data already. This brings me on to the next issue - costs. The proposed cost for the implementation of the bill is over a billion pounds. Judging by experience on spending for the Olympics this figure is likely to rise by quite a lot. At a time when there are cuts to essential services in the NHS, legal aid and right across the public sector, where will the government manage to drum up the money for implementing a misguided and ludicrous piece of legislation - which looks to only benefit the security industry itself. While the security industry may prove lucrative for the government, the harm that this bill will cause to the public greatly overrides any government-business relations. Such an outright invasion of individuals' privacy and the breach of personal freedoms and basic human rights cannot be justified by the government in any way whether it is business-motivated or not. Analysing internet use can paint a very intimate picture of someone's private life such as their health, financial situation and their personal relationships. It is not only an extreme breach of a person's privacy but it is also completely unnecessary. Most of those affected will be innocent members of the public who may be unaware of the full extent of the bill and who do not know how to encrypt websites. Furthermore, the criminals that the government is referring to, can easily bypass the surveillance measures, thus making them even more difficult to catch. While the government insists it will not read the data, it claims that it must have access to it for the purpose of catching criminals. Charles Farr - the head of the Home Office's of security and counter-terrorism office, was extremely defensive when questioned about the bill and merely stated "trust us, we know". On the contrary, it appears that any sensible person with expertise in the field of internet security would know that the proposals in the bill make very little practical or financial sense. Therefore trusting the government to "know what it's doing" seems more and more naive on this issue. It appears that this is just one of several bills the government is putting forward which seeks to take away fundamental personal freedoms and infringe basic human rights. Only on Sunday, Theresa May criticised judges for "not qualifying" Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and being too lenient on criminals who use Art.8 to remain in the UK (even though only 2% of foreign nationals facing deportation after criminal proceedings successfully apply Art.8 to remain in the UK). These recent policies proposed by the government are particularly worrying as they may have severe consequences for basic human rights in the UK. The government has taken the line that this is an effective way of catching the usual bogeymen - terrorists and paedophiles. What they are still failing to consider, is that the system is relatively easy to bypass and simply requires the use of encrypted pages - in simple terms this means that websites using "https" rather than "http" cannot be tracked. Follow Natasha Kuilak Mellersh on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@tashalaws FOLLOW UK TECH Like [DEL: :DEL] 4k Enter email for UK T Get Alerts * Human Rights * Theresa May * privacy Related News On Huffington Post: Facebook, Twitter And Email Accounts Could Be Tracked Under New Home Office Legislation Queen's Speech Announces Increased Internet Surveillance Plans Liberals take blame for Vikileaks attacks on Public Safety Minister Toews Online Privacy Facebook, Twitter And Email Accounts Could Be Tracked Under New Home Office Legislation The police and security services are to be given new powers to track suspects through their use of emails, Facebook accounts and Twitter profiles, in... Internet Surveillance Queen's Speech Announces Increased Internet Surveillance Plans The Queen has formally announced plans to greatly increase surveillance of the internet by intelligence agencies and the police, in plans that are being labelled... Liberals take blame for Vikileaks attacks on Public Safety Minister Toews OTTAWA - A Liberal party researcher has resigned for tweeting salacious information about Public Safety Minister Vic Toews to protest the government's online surveillance bill.Interim... Around the Web: [favicon.ico] UK Govt. Seeks Massive Communications Surveillance Powers [favicon.ico] V 1912.04 Electronic Surveillance Policy [favicon.ico] Web surveillance More in UK Tech... [trans.gif] 2012 DA14 Asteroid 'Capable Of Flattening London'... [trans.gif] Hoax Artist Behind 'UFO Over Santa Clara'... [trans.gif] William Shatner Voices Dismay At Reddit's Dark... [trans.gif] Nasa Could Use Spy Satellite To Visit... [display_comments_title.gif] * Comments * 1 * Pending Comments * 0 * View FAQ Comments are closed for this entry Community Notice: We've made some changes to our badge program, including the addition of our newest badge: Community Curator. View All Favorites Recency | Popularity photo Ciaran Goggins 20 Fans 15:42 on 19/06/2012 Good article, and timely given that the new generation of cctv/spy cameras have mikes built in to listen, no more outdoor private chats. As you say, the new measures are draconian and I warrant unneeded. Ciaran_Goggins: Good article, and timely given that the new generation of http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/social/Ciaran_Goggins/bogeymen-and-blan ket-survelliance_b_1601162_162278181.html History | Permalink | Share it This comment has been down-ranked into oblivion. View comment You have not right to carry out this operation or Error this operation. spinner Loading comments... new comment(s) on this entry -- Click to refresh spinner Loading comments... FOLLOW US * Facebook * Twitter * Apple * Android * gplus * Email * Rss Connect with your friends Check out stories you might like, and see what your friends are sharing! [facebook_promo_connect.png?3] Most Popular YdI14RcNLlpqgECiBeqiagG6RqMO0IbFTGHcCV5fgfJtdxCG8Hp%2Bet%2FI8MtjKjm8pgv b80tdUvS7%2Bo0VWfwSwXbWqoDxlYeJ t%2BBp%2FOpqObnT5L0L9jiBQLbu6xjUtq%2FfLoSR6WPEwzzgntyABdvLh75UbAsVHhBx7 qLmrXRcVAM%3D 1 of 2 Katy Perry Grammys 2013: Katy's Got Some Front Like [DEL: :DEL] 16 Prince William And Kate Middleton Papped Again: Bikini-Clad Kate And The Royal Baby Bump Like [DEL: :DEL] 5 Harlem Shake WATCH: 'Harlem Shake' Is The New 'Gangnam Style' Like [DEL: :DEL] 148 Bafta BAFTAs 2013: Skyfall Is Best British Film, All The Winners Here.. Like [DEL: :DEL] 89 Pope Resigns Pope Benedict XVI To Resign 'For Health Reasons' Like [DEL: :DEL] 2k Grammys GRAMMYS 2013: Adele Does It Again Like [DEL: :DEL] 78 Adele Grammys Grammys 2013: Adele In 'Doesn't Wear Black' Shocker! Like [DEL: :DEL] 178 Pope Twitter Twitter's Funniest Pope Jokes Like [DEL: :DEL] 166 Taylor Swift WATCH: Taylor's Not-So-Subtle Message To Ex, Harry Styles Like [DEL: :DEL] 14 Don't Miss UK Bloggers 1 of 2 Cherie Blair Cherie Blair Make a Change Through Mentoring Paul McCartney Paul McCartney My Life as a Vegetarian - Supporting Linda's Legacy Carrie Armstrong Carrie Armstrong Alcoholism Is Ugly Stella Creasy Stella Creasy Be Part of One Billion Rising, Be Part of Saying Enough Is Enough MOST DISCUSSED RIGHT NOW 2RgnQXLokElFimSGDV8i8a43pip0bdKP iJKomeBLqmM3QvAVQ0trgKQA9zRBn5c9 1 of 2 [s-SHATNER-mini.jpg] William Shatner Voices Dismay At Reddit's Dark Side [s-UFO-YOUTUBE-mini.jpg] WATCH: UFO Hoaxer Explains How He Faked Incredible Alien Footage HOT ON FACEBOOK 2RgnQXLokElFimSGDV8i8TKPvBq8xPkmgYINREC4w8w%3D iJKomeBLqmM3QvAVQ0trgPTAYkCdRanfpr%2BnvSQA9QM%3D jpeKJKgSs0bJPlRX0pV4Fss35VaaM%2Fhsd5ArrOAf1yA%3D gMVUpgWa%2Fb8rmwkD%2B%2Fb%2FjQ%3D%3D 1 of 3 [s-8441458081_9F48BAAB8B_O-mini.jpg] Mars Rover Spots Metallic 'Robot Arm' Sticking Out Of A Rock [s-90S-mini.jpg] Microsoft's New Advert Will Make You Cry (If You Grew Up In The 90s) HUFFPOST'S BIG NEWS PAGES Bang With Friends: Facebook Sex App Helps You Get Closer To Your Mates (NSFW) Facebook Asteroid 2012 DA14 To Narrowly Miss Striking Earth With The Destructive Power Of A Nuclear Bomb On February 15 Space North Korea Comes To Google Maps, Showing Prison Camps Google more big news pages >> Search The Huffington Post_____ Search * Advertise | * * Make HuffPost your Home Page | * RSS | * Careers | * FAQ * User Agreement | * Privacy | * Cookie Policy | * Comment Policy | * About Us | * About Our Ads | * Contact Us * "The Huffington Post UK" is provided by AOL (UK) Limited. (c) 2013 AOL (UK) Limited its affiliates and licensors * Part of HuffPost Tech Quantcast HuffPost Lightbox