#publisher The Economist * Log in * Register * Subscribe * Digital & mobile * Events * Topics A-Z * Newsletters * Jobs * RSS feed * Facebook * Twitter * More social links * Google plus * Linked in * Tumblr Offline reading Search this site: _______________ Search * World politics + United States + Britain + Europe + China + Asia + Americas + Middle East & Africa * Business & finance + All Business & finance + Which MBA? + Business Books Quarterly * Economics + All Economics + Economics by invitation + Economics A-Z + Markets & data * Science & technology + All Science & technology + Technology Quarterly * Culture + All Culture + More Intelligent Life + Style guide + The Economist Quiz + Book reviews * Blogs + Latest blog posts + Feast and famine + Analects + Free exchange + Americas view + Game theory + Babbage + Graphic detail + Banyan + Gulliver + Baobab + Johnson + Blighty + Lexington's notebook + Buttonwood's notebook + Newsbook + Cassandra + Pomegranate + Charlemagne + Prospero + Democracy in America + Schumpeter + Eastern approaches * Debate + Economist debates + What the world thinks + Economics by invitation + Letters to the editor * The World in 2013 * Multimedia + World + Business & economics + Science & technology + Culture + Events + The Economist in audio * Print edition + Current issue + Previous issues + Special reports + Politics this week + Business this week + Leaders + KAL's cartoon + Obituaries This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details Snooping on new media Spies, lies and the internet Plans to extend surveillance and secrecy are causing alarm within the coalition and outside it Apr 7th 2012 |From the print edition * * Tweet FOR a government allegedly keen on constraining the state and advocating greater transparency, the coalition has some big ideas about electronic surveillance—and an appetite for what critics are calling “secret justice” in court cases. On two fronts, it has become embroiled in clashes about the balance between liberty and security. First, it plans in early May to set out proposed measures giving the authorities access in real time to more data on public communications, including not only mobile phones and e-mail—which they can track now with a bit of effort—but also Skype, Facebook and online games. Theresa May, the home secretary, said this week that extending surveillance was crucial to keeping the public safe against terrorists and criminals in a high-tech age. In this section * Spies, lies and the internet * The year of many votes * Dressing up * Tall storeys * Back to the future * Small change * Riding the data wave * David Cameron is not too posh Reprints Related topics * Liberal Democrats (Britain) * United Kingdom * David Cameron * Theresa May * Labour Party (Britain) At the same time, a rift has emerged between David Cameron, the Conservative prime minister, and Nick Clegg, his Liberal Democrat deputy, over how courts should deal with sensitive evidence in cases of suspected terrorism. Mr Clegg has broken ranks over a previously announced plan to extend the system of “closed material procedures” in which evidence is heard privately, without the defendant present. He opposes the idea that ministers, rather than judges, should decide whether civil proceedings are held in private, and objects to extending secret hearings to coroner's court cases. Mr Cameron's government has been coming under pressure from America over the amount of detail that can be revealed publicly in tricky proceedings. There are fears that intelligence-sharing could be restricted. Attempts to extend the reach of the secret state caused headaches for the previous Labour government, which lost its battle for a longer detention period for terrorist suspects and failed in its attempt to introduce compulsory identity cards. Now the coalition, which promised a lighter touch on civil liberties, is in similar straits, especially over plans to curtail privacy on the internet. The government insists it will not seek access to the content of communications, but says it can gain valuable intelligence by simply monitoring who is talking to whom, and where and when. Getting such traffic figures does not require a judicial warrant now, so the new plans are about modernising surveillance techniques, not expanding their scope. Critics, such as Shami Chakrabarti of Liberty, a civil-rights group, disagree. Scanning the sites people access and identifying their contacts is akin to building up an intimate picture of them, she says; doing so faster and more thoroughly “increases the amount of surveillance without adding safeguards”. The Office of the Information Commissioner is equally unconvinced. [EMBED] Practically, the idea also raises thorny questions. CCTV has been widely introduced in Britain over the past two decades to help prevent crime. Yet it often emerges when crimes occur that cameras were either not monitored or the images produced were not accurate enough to yield useful evidence. Whitehall sources say such flaws are less likely in proposed internet trawls, since the intelligence services focus on existing suspects, rather than random tracking of internet use. It does mean, however, that sophisticated offenders may take to using anonymous re-mailer and proxy servers based outside Britain, just driving the cat-and-mouse game to a deeper level. Many countries are struggling to keep abreast of the security implications of new communication technology. In 2008 the Labour government proposed a similar extension of internet surveillance, only to be shouted down by, among others, Tories and Liberal Democrats. Americans discovered in 2005 that their spooks were hoovering up vast quantities of internet traffic and scanning it for anything suspicious, a practice that has continued despite doubts about its legality. In Germany the constitutional court ruled in February that the content of e-mails should be made available only in cases where lives or state property were in danger. Politically, this territory is fraught for Mr Cameron: not only does it exacerbate coalition tensions with the Lib Dems; it also annoys many civil libertarians on his own side. Some compromise looks inevitable. The internet proposals, slated for inclusion in the Queen's Speech laying out the government's firm legislative agenda, have been downgraded to a mere draft for consultation. Mr Clegg is also insisting that he wants the government to row back on closed hearings. One way and another, extending the secret state does not look like a political winner. From the print edition: Britain * Recommend 30 * * Tweet * Submit to reddit * * View all comments (10) Related items TOPIC: Liberal Democrats (Britain) » * Liberal Democrats: Cleggxistential crisis * The politics of press regulation: Pressing ahead * Coalition and the grassroots: Worm’s eye view TOPIC: United Kingdom » * American growth vs. the world: At the top of an underperforming class * Gun control: The gun control that works: no guns * Demography: The convergence of the twain TOPIC: David Cameron » * Britain's future: Goodbye Europe * Britain's unruly press: Beware the slippery slope * Saudi women: Sacred texts TOPIC: Theresa May » * National security: Shadowlands * Gary McKinnon: No place like home * Family migration: Sons and lovers More related topics: * Labour Party (Britain) * Nick Clegg Want more? Subscribe to The Economist and get the week's most relevant news and analysis. * Print edition X Apr 7th 2012 Mar 31st 2012 Mar 24th 2012 Mar 17th 2012 * Next in The world this week X Politics this week * Next in The world this week X Business this week * Next in The world this week X KAL's cartoon * Next in Leaders X Asia's balance of power China’s military rise There are ways to reduce the threat to stability that an emerging superpower poses * Next in Leaders X The risk in clearing-houses All clear? Clearing-houses are meant to solve problems in derivatives markets. They create them, too * Next in Leaders X New light in Myanmar The Yangon spring Despite remarkable progress, dark forces still dominate in a dirt-poor country * Next in Leaders X Emerging markets Message to Ankara Why Turkey is an economy to worry about * Next in Leaders X The devaluation of everything The perils of panflation A virulent monster is dangerously out of control. Let us slay it together * Next in Letters X Letters On India, American Jews, taxes, Scotland, Lithuania, Turkey's AK party, an April fool, beards * Next in Briefing X China’s military rise The dragon’s new teeth A rare look inside the world’s biggest military expansion * Next in United States X American Indians Gambling on nation-building Tribes are at last becoming sovereign in more than theory, with mixed results * Next in United States X Newt Gingrich’s campaign Deflating the zeppelin The former House Speaker’s campaign reaches the limits of plausibility * Next in United States X Health disparities Beyond the mandate Improving America’s health will take more than universal insurance * Next in United States X Detroit Stalled in Motor City A desperate tussle over whether the state of Michigan should take over Detroit * Next in United States X Lexington The scarcer sex Republican callousness is not helped by women’s reluctance to enter politics * Next in United States X Correction: California water * Next in The Americas X Colombian politics Santos v Uribe Álvaro Uribe (pictured right) has fallen out with his chosen successor, Juan Manuel Santos (left).... * Next in The Americas X Prostitution in Brazil The wrong signal A court decides some children are less equal than others * Next in The Americas X Education in Peru Error message A disappointing return from an investment in computing * Next in Asia X By-elections in Myanmar The Lady of all landslides Aung San Suu Kyi’s win is a humiliation for the army. Will it now turn nasty? * Next in Asia X Politics in South Korea Snooping dogs Lee Chalk up one more scandal, but not only for the ruling party * Next in Asia X Witchcraft in Assam Toil and trouble In a corner of north-eastern India, old superstitions die hard * Next in Asia X Balochistan “We only receive back the bodies” Murder and mayhem in an ugly but little-known Pakistani conflict * Next in Asia X Banyan A rather flimsy firewall Remaking the global financial architecture in Asia’s image proves easier said than done * Next in China X Uncertain politics Reimposing order The authorities clamp down on rumours of political turbulence * Next in China X The politics of corruption Dirty tricks A transition year gives plenty of opportunity for foul play * Next in China X Private health care The good midwife of Sichuan Although there are more private health providers, they won’t make a killing * Next in Middle East and Africa X African energy Eastern El Dorado? At long last east Africa is beginning to realise its energy potential * Next in Middle East and Africa X Senegal’s election Lucky Macky Senegal retains its title as Africa’s oldest democracy * Next in Middle East and Africa X Syria’s stalemate No easy fix A meeting of Syria’s friends produces kind words but not much else * Next in Middle East and Africa X Tunisian Islamists in power Doing well on parole Tunisia’s Islamists have survived a shaky first 100 days in power * Next in Middle East and Africa X Egypt’s presidential race Battle of the beards Islamists dominate Egypt’s increasingly heated presidential contest * Next in Europe X Russia Politics begins at home A new political landscape is emerging: local, energetic and mistrustful * Next in Europe X Greece and Russia An orthodox friendship Russian tourists are pouring into Greece. Investors may follow * Next in Europe X The French election Climbing mount improbable Nicolas Sarkozy promises voters he can change * Next in Europe X Poland’s progress Tusk take two Donald Tusk’s government, once polished, is looking a little ragged * Next in Europe X Hungarian politics Schmitt quits The Hungarian president resigns after a damaging row over plagiarism * Next in Europe X Charlemagne Currency disunion Why Europe’s leaders should think the unthinkable * Next in Britain X Labour and local elections The year of many votes Councils, mayors, commissioners: Ed Miliband and the electoral tests ahead * Next in Britain X Clothing sizes Dressing up Central banks cannot control all types of inflation * Next in Britain X UK only High-rise living Tall storeys Residential skyscrapers come of age in Britain * Next in Britain X UK only Architectural salvage Back to the future Entrepreneurs find new treasures in doomed post-war buildings * Next in Britain X UK only Local museums Small change Fighting to save local history as budget cuts bite * Next in Britain X UK only The state and statistics Riding the data wave The swell of freely available official information, and its consequences * Next in Britain X Bagehot David Cameron is not too posh The real lesson of a bad week for the Conservatives: voters are losing faith in politics * Next in International X The incorporation business They sell sea shells The companies that form companies are a shadowy world and (see article) a thriving industry * Next in International X Company formation Shells and shelves Making money by making companies: another industry that is globalising, consolidating and shifting... * Next in Business X HTC The brand from nowhere After a swift rise from anonymity to omnipresence, the Taiwanese mobile-phone firm has stumbled.... * Next in Business X Geothermal energy in Japan Storm in a hot tub Clean bodies versus clean energy * Next in Business X The French election and business The terror The 75% tax and other alarming campaign promises * Next in Business X Coty’s bid for Avon Makeover or takeover? Perfume clashes with lipstick * Next in Business X Express Scripts and Medco Bigger means cheaper A new drugs manager may change the way Americans pop their pills * Next in Business X Corporate governance in America Heating up Shareholders are ever more willing to vote against management * Next in Business X Ad space for equity Air for shares Could an unusual venture-capital model be taking off? * Next in Business X Schumpeter A guardian and a guide Chief legal officers have more power than ever before * Next in Finance and economics X Turkey’s economy Istanbuls and bears Turkey has one of the world’s zippiest economies, but it is too reliant on hot money * Next in Finance and economics X Centrally cleared derivatives Clear and present danger Clearing-houses may add danger as well as efficiency * Next in Finance and economics X Podium values All that glisters How much is an Olympic gold medal worth? * Next in Finance and economics X Shadow banking in China The Wenzhou experiment China unveils a pilot programme to legitimise informal lending * Next in Finance and economics X Government accounting Book-cooking guide The public sector has too much freedom to dress up the accounts * Next in Finance and economics X Regulating European insurers From Brussels, with shove “Solvency 2” will transform not just insurance but capital markets, too * Next in Finance and economics X Free exchange Historysis Can conquests centuries ago explain the democratic deficit in the Arab world today? * Next in Finance and economics X Marjorie Deane internships * Next in Science and technology X Cancer and epigenetics Cancer’s epicentre New understanding of how cancers work is yielding new treatments * Next in Science and technology X Animal testing Be nice to mice… …and they may return the favour * Next in Science and technology X Cosmic-ray tomography Musing on muons How to detect smuggled uranium and plutonium using muons * Next in Science and technology X Age and wisdom Older and wiser? Americans get wiser with age. Japanese are wise from the start * Next in Books and arts X Occupy Wall Street and the media Talking about a revolution A fascinating and unwieldy movement in search of a narrative * Next in Books and arts X New York City Life after Bloomberg A city in need of fearless leadership * Next in Books and arts X Football and murder in Mexico Direct shot A season in Ciudad Juárez * Next in Books and arts X New fiction A swan’s song Peter Carey’s delightful double story * Next in Business books quarterly X Social habits and marketing Getting to know you The importance of learning about people’s habits * Next in Business books quarterly X The benefits of the system Why finance is good for us A new call to arms * Next in Business books quarterly X Career management Becoming a social worker What finding jobs and founding businesses have in common * Next in Business books quarterly X Salesmanship Ice to the Eskimos Can the dubious art of selling become more scientific? * Next in Obituary X Jocky Wilson Braveheart of darts Jocky Wilson, darts player, died on March 24th, aged 62 * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Output, prices and jobs * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Trade, exchange rates, budget balances and interest rates * Next in Economic and financial indicators X The Economist commodity-price index * Next in Economic and financial indicators X The Economist poll of forecasters, April averages * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Markets * Print edition X Apr 7th 2012 Apr 14th 2012 Apr 21st 2012 Apr 28th 2012 From the print edition Apr 7th 2012 * Comment (10) * Print * E-mail * Reprints & permissions * Advertisement Latest blog posts - All times are GMT [_0013_free-exchange.png] Recommended economics writing: Link exchange Free exchange 26 mins ago [_0018_sport-theory.png] African football: Nigerian heroes Game theory 2 hrs 45 mins ago [_0015_prospero.png] Kraftwerk at Tate Modern: A blast from the futuristic past Prospero February 11th, 18:43 [_0017_baobab.png] African football: Nigerian heroes Baobab February 11th, 18:24 [_0013_free-exchange.png] Mobility: There is nothing inevitable about low rates of economic mobility Free exchange February 11th, 18:02 [_0001_newsbook.png] Pope Benedict XVI’s resignation: Vatican ragged Newsbook February 11th, 17:48 [_0000_schumpeter.png] Mail-free Saturdays in America: No magazine today—and, perhaps, tomorrow Schumpeter February 11th, 17:29 More from our blogs » Most popular * Recommended * Commented Recommended * A tale of two Davoses 1The World Economic ForumA tale of two Davoses * 2The Nordic countries: The next supermodel * 3Spain’s government: Another blow * 4Northern lights * 5The World Economic Forum in Davos: Leaders without followers Commented * Locked on 1China and JapanLocked on * 2Italian politics: Gaffe or provocation? * 3John Brennan: The debate over drones * 4Israeli and Palestinian textbooks: Teaching children to hate each other * 5Battle of the EU budget: Cameron's budget blinder Sponsored by Advertisement Products & events Stay informed today and every day Get e-mail newsletters Subscribe to The Economist's free e-mail newsletters and alerts. Follow The Economist on Twitter Subscribe to The Economist's latest article postings on Twitter Follow The Economist on Facebook See a selection of The Economist's articles, events, topical videos and debates on Facebook. Advertisement Classified ads IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 552270;pos=button1;sz=125x125;tile=18;ord=470798531? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 552270;pos=button2;sz=125x125;tile=19;ord=470798531? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 552270;pos=button3;sz=125x125;tile=20;ord=470798531? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 552270;pos=button4;sz=125x125;tile=21;ord=470798531? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 552270;pos=button5;sz=125x125;tile=22;ord=470798531? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 552270;pos=button6;sz=125x125;tile=23;ord=470798531? * About The Economist * Media directory * Advertising info * Staff books * Career opportunities * Subscribe * Contact us * Site index * [+] Site Feedback * Copyright © The Economist Newspaper Limited 2013. All rights reserved. * Accessibility * Privacy policy * Cookies info * Terms of use * Help Quantcast