#publisher The Economist * Log in * Register * Subscribe * Digital & mobile * Events * Topics A-Z * Newsletters * Jobs * RSS feed * Facebook * Twitter * More social links * Google plus * Linked in * Tumblr Offline reading Search this site: _______________ Search * World politics + United States + Britain + Europe + China + Asia + Americas + Middle East & Africa * Business & finance + All Business & finance + Which MBA? + Business Books Quarterly * Economics + All Economics + Economics by invitation + Economics A-Z + Markets & data * Science & technology + All Science & technology + Technology Quarterly * Culture + All Culture + More Intelligent Life + Style guide + The Economist Quiz + Book reviews * Blogs + Latest blog posts + Feast and famine + Analects + Free exchange + Americas view + Game theory + Babbage + Graphic detail + Banyan + Gulliver + Baobab + Johnson + Blighty + Lexington's notebook + Buttonwood's notebook + Newsbook + Cassandra + Pomegranate + Charlemagne + Prospero + Democracy in America + Schumpeter + Eastern approaches * Debate + Economist debates + What the world thinks + Economics by invitation + Letters to the editor * The World in 2013 * Multimedia + World + Business & economics + Science & technology + Culture + Events + The Economist in audio * Print edition + Current issue + Previous issues + Special reports + Politics this week + Business this week + Leaders + KAL's cartoon + Obituaries This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details Internet regulation Wires crossed Politicians seek to tighten regulation of the web Jul 7th 2012 |From the print edition * * Tweet FANS of smutty websites may resist giving personal information to porn barons. But they should feel safe entrusting it to their government. On June 29th the Department for Education temporarily suspended a public consultation on proposals to make internet pornography harder to access. It had found that its website was leaking respondents' confidential answers and e-mail addresses on the net. The cock-up is an unfortunate start to a fraught discussion on what role government should play in protecting children from the web's wilder provinces—not just pornography but also sites that promote gambling, anorexia or self-harming. In March a committee led by Claire Perry, a Conservative MP, recommended that all British internet users be blocked by default from accessing adult sites—unless the bill payer requests otherwise. It is more likely that service providers will end up giving customers a choice whether to opt in or out of content blocking when their internet connection is first installed. In this section * Testing the limits * New model army * From Britain with Love * Wires crossed * A 10% better BBC * Acts of the apostles * Shipshape? * Simple pleasures Reprints Related topics * Britain's Parliament * United Kingdom The campaign against porn, which is supported by the Daily Mail, Britain's fiercest newspaper, is one of several new proposals to regulate the web. Last month the government promised to make it easier for citizens to pursue web users who libel them anonymously. It will offer legal immunity to publishers that cough up identifying information about people accused of spreading lies on their sites. Publishers have advocated this, but free-speech campaigners worry that poorly drafted rules could make platforms too eager to hand over user data. Ian Brown, at the Oxford Cyber Security Centre, warns the move could encourage sites to collect more personal information from their users. More controversial still are proposals contained in the draft Communications Data bill published on June 14th, which grants intelligence agencies the right to intercept and store information about almost any correspondence. This would let authorities piece together an individual's internet search history, see which sites they visit or track activity on webmail and social networks. Paul Bernal at the University of East Anglia law school says the draft bill is so broadly written it could even be used to monitor carrier pigeons. “It makes surveillance the default and privacy the exception,” he says. The legislation is likely to lose some of its sharp edges as it goes through Parliament. But Britain nonetheless looks out of step with its neighbours. No other European government has seriously considered the mass blocking of legal adult content, says Joe McNamee of European Digital Rights, a coalition of civil-liberties groups. Nor can he think of any democratic country that submits to surveillance as sweeping as that proposed in Britain. On the contrary, Ireland has asked the European Court of Justice to investigate an existing European directive that requires its internet service providers to retain a little data on users. Britain's coalition government enthusiastically champions digital growth. It is doggedly dragging government services online, releases oodles of useful data to businesses and the public, and coddles web entrepreneurs in the London district it has named “Tech City”. Its occasional spells of illiberalism, brought on by security worries and campaigning newspapers, are often at odds with these efforts. Only last summer the prime minister hinted he would consider blocking access to social networks during riots (the comment was quickly withdrawn). One tech-industry figure calls government web policies “schizophrenic”. Mr Bernal labels them “a real mess”. From the print edition: Britain * Recommend 16 * * Tweet * Submit to reddit * * View all comments (6) Related items TOPIC: Britain's Parliament » * Gay marriage: Ties that divide * The politics of press regulation: Pressing ahead * Politics this week TOPIC: United Kingdom » * American growth vs. the world: At the top of an underperforming class * Gun control: The gun control that works: no guns * Demography: The convergence of the twain Want more? Subscribe to The Economist and get the week's most relevant news and analysis. * Print edition X Jul 7th 2012 Jun 30th 2012 Jun 23rd 2012 Jun 16th 2012 * Next in The world this week X Politics this week * Next in The world this week X Business this week * Next in The world this week X KAL's cartoon * Next in Leaders X The LIBOR affair Banksters How Britain’s rate-fixing scandal might spread—and what to do about it * Next in Leaders X The Higgs boson Science’s great leap forward After decades of searching, physicists have solved one of the mysteries of the universe * Next in Leaders X Education A 20-year lesson Evidence from America and Britain shows that independence for schools works * Next in Leaders X The euro crisis Inching towards integration The latest European summit made more progress than usual—but still not enough * Next in Leaders X Australia’s new taxes Underland revenue The right place to look for fiscal resources * Next in Letters X Letters On the Arctic, corruption, Egypt, Marco Rubio, France, renting, slavery, bees, terminology * Next in Briefing X The LIBOR scandal The rotten heart of finance A scandal over key interest rates is about to go global * Next in Briefing X The turmoil at Barclays First-mover disadvantage Bob Diamond, Barclays and regulators are all battling to save their reputations * Next in United States X Education Charting a better course Charter schools raise educational standards for vulnerable children * Next in United States X The future of Medicaid Run for cover The Supreme Court’s ruling has grave implications for the poor * Next in United States X Washington’s power cuts Taken by trees The powerful without power * Next in United States X Fear of sequestration Collateral damage The Pentagon has become a hostage in the war over the deficit * Next in United States X Catholicism in America A contentious flock America’s Catholics are becoming more polarised and diverse * Next in United States X Infrastructure spending A patch on the road The transport bill averts calamity, but not by much and not for long * Next in United States X Silicon Valley chic Back to the garage Innovation in the old style * Next in United States X Lexington What’s eating Appalachia? Many Democrats in the region seem to hate their president * Next in United States X Correction: Simon Anholt * Next in The Americas X Mexico’s election The PRI’s qualified comeback The former ruling party triumphs, but without the majority it had hoped for * Next in The Americas X Television in Mexico Channelling public anger The president-elect must show that he is not a stooge of Televisa * Next in The Americas X Venezuela’s presidential campaign Tilting the pitch The opposition faces some extraordinary obstacles * Next in The Americas X Canadian politics Time to flip The voters may be starting to tire of the prime minister’s bullying * Next in Asia X The South China Sea Roiling the waters Tensions rise between China and Vietnam in the South China Sea * Next in Asia X Biometrics in Afghanistan The eyes have it Biometric data and the Afghan war * Next in Asia X Pakistan and America Making up, a bit Pakistan once again agrees to accept supplies bound for Afghanistan * Next in Asia X Australia’s fiscal reform Tithes of discontent The political dangers of taxing carbon and mining * Next in Asia X Banyan The idea of Myanmar Aung San Suu Kyi’s ethnic-minority problem * Next in Asia X Correction: Timor-Leste * Next in China X Hong Kong and China A city apart A huge protest in Hong Kong challenges new leaders in the city, as well as those preparing to take... * Next in China X Shanghai Film Festival History is never just history A new historical drama, mirroring today’s power struggles, is censored * Next in China X Fake degrees A quick study Bogus degrees from non-existent colleges cause headaches for employers * Next in Middle East and Africa X The crisis in Syria The tide begins to turn Diplomacy is being overtaken by the armed struggle. But on both scores, Syria’s embattled... * Next in Middle East and Africa X Syrian graffiti Mocking him to death The protesters go to war with wit * Next in Middle East and Africa X The Sahel Hungry again There must be better ways of preparing to meet the repeated threat of famine * Next in Middle East and Africa X A cultural assault in Mali The jihadists’ frightening new front Extreme Islamists are threatening the region—and an ancient African heritage * Next in Middle East and Africa X Congo and Rwanda Stop messing each other up The latest rebellion in eastern Congo does no one any good * Next in Middle East and Africa X Religion in Africa Celebrity priests Not everyone is pleased about Africa’s new breed of clergyman * Next in Europe X France’s public finances François Hollande’s fiscal puzzle The new Socialist government tackles its budget deficit—but with more taxes than spending cuts * Next in Europe X Turkey and its neighbours Delicate balance Turks fret about Syria, but few of them really want a fight * Next in Europe X Denmark’s prime minister Helle unfriended A leader falls abruptly from grace * Next in Europe X Bulgaria’s economy In a rough region Once Bulgaria hoped to be like Greece; now it just hopes to survive * Next in Europe X Circumcision in Germany Incisive arguments A row over a ruling that circumcision for non-medical reasons is a crime * Next in Europe X Russian politics Gudkovs, bad cops How two prominent opponents of Vladimir Putin are being harassed * Next in Europe X Charlemagne A Greece or a Norway? Cyprus takes the helm at a time of crisis for the European Union and itself * Next in Britain X Education reform Testing the limits Plans to reform British exams are less drastic than had been rumoured, but will still mean an... * Next in Britain X Military reform New model army The army is to be trimmed and reshaped, with a larger reserve * Next in Britain X James Bond From Britain with Love The global brand of 007 still shakes and stirs * Next in Britain X UK only The new director-general A 10% better BBC George Entwistle needs to redefine the case for the licence fee * Next in Britain X UK only The Conservatives and Tony Blair Acts of the apostles What the former prime minister’s Tory admirers have failed to learn * Next in Britain X UK only Bristol and elected mayors Shipshape? The mayoral campaign is renewing debate over what makes cities succeed * Next in Britain X Bagehot Simple pleasures Both parties have an interest in banker-bashing. That is unfortunate * Next in International X The Vatican’s woes God’s bankers A beleaguered papacy is embroiled in intrigue. Some scent a succession struggle * Next in International X Short-wave radio Tuning out A cold-war stalwart goes out of fashion * Next in International X Holiday hell-holes Danger zones Nasty places can be fun to visit * Next in Business X Volkswagen VW conquers the world Germany’s biggest carmaker is leaving rivals in the dust * Next in Business X Advertising on mobile phones Attack of the covert commercials Digital ads are popping up in irritating places * Next in Business X Mis-selling drugs The settlers American prosecutors wring $3 billion from GlaxoSmithKline * Next in Business X Women managers in Asia Untapped talent Sexism is rife in Asia. That creates an opportunity for non-chauvinist firms * Next in Business X British law firms Taking the magic abroad London’s big law firms are expanding their global footprints * Next in Business X Airbus Coming to America Europe’s big aircraft-maker is to open a factory in Alabama * Next in Business X Football Equity 1, debt 0 Manchester United’s unattractive initial public offering * Next in Business X Schumpeter No rush In praise of procrastination * Next in Finance and economics X The world economy Powering down More months of uncertainty about the euro area will weigh on the global economy * Next in Finance and economics X China’s capital controls The more special economic zone The landscape of capital-account liberalisation * Next in Finance and economics X Oil prices Rollercoaster Another leap. Where next? * Next in Finance and economics X Buttonwood Duncan dough notes A thought-provoking analysis of the debt crisis * Next in Finance and economics X Seth Klarman The Oracle of Boston A hedge-fund manager with a low profile and a big following * Next in Finance and economics X Free exchange Move over Falling labour mobility in America may reflect a more efficient market * Next in Science and technology X The Higgs boson Gotcha! The hunt for physics’s most elusive quarry is over * Next in Science and technology X Dark matter Material answers The universe is stitched together by invisible threads * Next in Science and technology X Hunting asteroids Rock on A charitable foundation is to launch the first private, scientific space mission * Next in Science and technology X The cheating side * Next in Books and arts X Segregation in cities Living in black and white How different races inhabit cities * Next in Books and arts X Latin American fiction A tragic hero’s tale * Next in Books and arts X The future of Italy Long life How to slay its demons * Next in Books and arts X Jeff Koons’s new sculptures Sexy contemporary antiquities Goddesses, hulks and cartoons inspire Jeff Koons * Next in Business books quarterly X The success of hedge funds Masterclass Two books analyse what makes hedge-fund managers great—and reach very different conclusions * Next in Business books quarterly X Eli Broad Uncommonly unreasonable * Next in Business books quarterly X Terry Leahy’s management One to ten * Next in Business books quarterly X Benjamin Graham Figuring it out * Next in Obituary X Nora Ephron and Lonesome George When Nora met George Nora Ephron, observer of sexual behaviour, died on June 26th, aged 71. Lonesome George, habitual... * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Output, prices and jobs * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Trade, exchange rates, budget balances and interest rates * Next in Economic and financial indicators X The Economist commodity-price index * Next in Economic and financial indicators X The Economist poll of forecasters, July averages * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Markets * Print edition X Jul 7th 2012 Jul 14th 2012 Jul 21st 2012 Jul 28th 2012 From the print edition Jul 7th 2012 * Comment (6) * Print * E-mail * Reprints & permissions * Advertisement Latest blog posts - All times are GMT [_0013_free-exchange.png] Recommended economics writing: Link exchange Free exchange 26 mins ago [_0018_sport-theory.png] African football: Nigerian heroes Game theory 2 hrs 45 mins ago [_0015_prospero.png] Kraftwerk at Tate Modern: A blast from the futuristic past Prospero February 11th, 18:43 [_0017_baobab.png] African football: Nigerian heroes Baobab February 11th, 18:24 [_0013_free-exchange.png] Mobility: There is nothing inevitable about low rates of economic mobility Free exchange February 11th, 18:02 [_0001_newsbook.png] Pope Benedict XVI’s resignation: Vatican ragged Newsbook February 11th, 17:48 [_0000_schumpeter.png] Mail-free Saturdays in America: No magazine today—and, perhaps, tomorrow Schumpeter February 11th, 17:29 More from our blogs » Most popular * Recommended * Commented Recommended * A tale of two Davoses 1The World Economic ForumA tale of two Davoses * 2The Nordic countries: The next supermodel * 3Spain’s government: Another blow * 4Northern lights * 5The World Economic Forum in Davos: Leaders without followers Commented * Locked on 1China and JapanLocked on * 2Italian politics: Gaffe or provocation? * 3John Brennan: The debate over drones * 4Israeli and Palestinian textbooks: Teaching children to hate each other * 5Battle of the EU budget: Cameron's budget blinder Sponsored by Advertisement Products & events Stay informed today and every day Get e-mail newsletters Subscribe to The Economist's free e-mail newsletters and alerts. Follow The Economist on Twitter Subscribe to The Economist's latest article postings on Twitter Follow The Economist on Facebook See a selection of The Economist's articles, events, topical videos and debates on Facebook. Advertisement Classified ads IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 558293;pos=button1;sz=125x125;tile=18;ord=508153581? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 558293;pos=button2;sz=125x125;tile=19;ord=508153581? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 558293;pos=button3;sz=125x125;tile=20;ord=508153581? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 558293;pos=button4;sz=125x125;tile=21;ord=508153581? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 558293;pos=button5;sz=125x125;tile=22;ord=508153581? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.tdqk/skwo/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 558293;pos=button6;sz=125x125;tile=23;ord=508153581? * About The Economist * Media directory * Advertising info * Staff books * Career opportunities * Subscribe * Contact us * Site index * [+] Site Feedback * Copyright © The Economist Newspaper Limited 2013. All rights reserved. * Accessibility * Privacy policy * Cookies info * Terms of use * Help Quantcast