[p?c1=2&c2=13080930&cv=2.0&cj=1] The Washington Times * News + Politics + National + World + Security + Economy + D.C. Local + Newsmakers + Inside the Beltway + Inside the Ring + Pruden on Politics + Embassy Row + Weather BLOGS: + Inside Politics + Technology * Opinion + Editorials + Commentary + Letters + Water Cooler + Books + Kuhner + Nugent + Cartoons BLOGS: + Guns + Water Cooler * Video + Staff Exclusives + Politics + Newsmaker Interviews + Water Cooler + Entertainment + Strange and Weird + National News * Sports + Football + Baseball + Basketball + NCAA + Olympics + Tennis + Golf + Hockey + Soccer + Horse Racing + Video BLOGS: + Capitals Watch + From the Sports Editors + Nationals Watch + Redskins Watch + Screen Play + United Watch + Wizards Watch * Life + Entertainment + Home and Lifestyle + Travel + Health + The List + Technology + Books + Video * Media + Radio: Andy Parks + Photo Galleries + Video * Specials + Presidential Inauguration 2013 + A Guide to the 113th Congress + Benghazi Attack Under Microscope + Superstorm Sandy + Health Care Reform * Communities * Trending: * Mumford & Sons * Kelly Clarkson * Twitter * Taylor Swift * Congress ____________________ Search Editors' Picks: * Sen. Dick Durbin says embattled Sen. Robert Menendez shouldn’t resign yet * Pentagon to extend some benefits to gay partners * Egypt on high alert as protesters mark anniversary of Hosni Mubarak’s ouster * Israeli police detain comic Sarah Silverman’s sister * MILLER: Chicago’s deadly gun control lessons * Paterno family issues report, challenges Freeh’s findings * EDITORIAL: Bring up right to work * Chechnya leader orders crackdown on sorcerers, psychics * KNIGHT: A life on the front lines of the culture war * Background checks represent ground for compromise on gun control * CONNECT: * Facebook * Twitter * RSS * Home * Opinion * Editorials * Radio * Account + Edit My Profile + Email Alerts + Edit Password + Logout * Log In * E-Mail Alerts * Subscribe * Classifieds * E-Edition EDITORIAL: Exposing Uncle Sam’s Internet snooping Judge finds freedom of information essential to privacy protection Comment(s) Size: + / - Print By THE WASHINGTON TIMES - The Washington Times Tuesday, January 15, 2013 * Illustration: The Internet Enlarge Photo Illustration: The Internet more > Story Topics * Gladys Kessler * National Security Agency * U.S. District Court * Barack Obama * United States Department Of Defense Follow Us On facebook Facebook Follow @washtimes Question of the Day Do you think Sen. Marco Rubio will become the new face of the Republican Party? valid_email_________ ____________________ (*) Yes ( ) No ( ) Undecided ( ) Other Vote View results Uncle Sam is looking for ways to sharpen his watchful gaze. In the name of fighting terrorism, federal agencies can have a hard time distinguishing the line between legitimate surveillance and unlawful spying. Fortunately, a court ruling on the public’s right to know may brighten that line. Loss of hard-won liberty ought not be the price for keeping Americans safe. On Jan. 8, Judge Gladys Kessler of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia denied the Obama administration’s request to exempt documents related to the government’s Internet surveillance from Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) compliance. The judge also chastised administration officials for delays in producing records approved for release. In effect, she said freedom of information means just that. The case involved a pilot program operated jointly by the Department of Defense and Department of Homeland Security started in 2011 to monitor electronic traffic passing through certain Internet-service providers in an effort to catch hackers launching computerized attacks against defense contractors’ networks. The Pentagon’s intelligence branch, the National Security Agency (NSA), partnered with AT&T, Verizon and CenturyLink to snoop on the Internet traffic of 15 defense firms that agreed to participate, including Lockheed Martin, Northrop Grumman, CSC and SAIC. Rather than scrutinize all their traffic, the NSA says it used filters that only looked for certain malicious code that would be a sign of hacker penetration. Privacy advocates feared that having the feds tap into the public Internet flow could lead to government spying on the electronic communications of private citizens. The Electronic Communications Privacy Act prohibits the interception of online traffic without a court order. The Electronic Privacy Information Center filed a FOIA request for documents related to the program and sued when the NSA did not hand over the information. The center prevailed in its suit, but the Justice Department, representing the Obama administration, petitioned the court for a protective order that would have prohibited the center from making public the documents it obtained through its FOIA filing. By denying the request, Judge Kessler affirmed the inviolable role of freedom of information rules in exposing government acts that would compromise the right to privacy. To be sure, the nation needs robust tools to prevent terrorists and industrial thieves from undermining information links vital to national security. Defense Department officials estimate that Pentagon networks are probed by intruders about 250,000 times an hour. However, the war on terrorism could end up transforming the “Land of the Free” into a surveillance society. Already, many American city streets and buildings are equipped with invasive video cameras. Smartphones contain GPS chips that track users’ movements. Law enforcement agencies deploy overhead drones to snap high-definition photos of suspects on the ground. Some school districts require students to wear ID badges that allow their whereabouts to be traced by school officials. As government seeks ways to defend us from our enemies, it is crucial that the Freedom of Information Act be preserved as a means of preventing Uncle Sam from attempting to fix his unblinking gaze on us instead. The Washington Times © Copyright 2013 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission. About the Author THE WASHINGTON TIMES Latest Stories * EDITORIAL: Bring up right to work * EDITORIAL: Rand Paul's foreign-policy vision * EDITORIAL: A bad rap on Richard III * EDITORIAL: Attack of the Obama drones * EDITORIAL: Government land grab put to bed Latest Blog Entries * VIDEO: Emily Miller on Fox News (Feb. 4, 2013) * VIDEO: Emily Miller on NRA News (Jan. 30, 2013) * VIDEO: Emily Miller on Fox News (Jan. 28, 2013) * VIDEO: Emily Miller on Fox News (Jan. 19, 2013) * Ethics panel clears Rep. Waters, reproves grandson Comments * Most Read * Most Shared * Most Emailed * Ted Nugent to be guest at State of the Union * Military warns cuts would create hollow force akin to 1970s * Conservative Dr. Ben Carson speech upstages Obama at prayer breakfast * SEAL who killed bin Laden left jobless, uninsured * Democrat Jan Schakowsky strikes back at Dr. Ben Carson for prayer breakfast speech * First black pope? Emerging contenders include cardinals from Africa * FORBES: America's new government-imposed religion * CNN host suggests link between asteroid, global warming * MILLER: How Obama got a gun * White House: All questions answered on Benghazi attack Recent Editorials * EDITORIAL: Bring up right to work * MILLER: Obama's insatiable appetite for taxes * GHEI: Taking an ax to spending * GHEI: Argentina's wishful thinking * EDITORIAL: A bad rap on Richard III Recent Commentary * BOOK REVIEW: ‘The Man Called Brown Condor’ * STANEK: Suspension may be sign of the end for debt ceiling * SMYTH: ‘No discrimination of abortion rights’ a dangerous policy * BOYD: Generation Y facing a tough future * MAUCK: Defense of Marriage Act protects children Recent Letters to the Editor * LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Homosexual ‘marriage’ a contradiction in terms * LETTER TO THE EDITOR: A ‘Pride Month’ for everybody * LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Chimp sanctuaries humane, cost-saving * LETTER TO THE EDITOR: The ‘sissification’ of football * LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Wind — the cheap, clean alternative Business Directory ____________________ [pg-widget-submit.gif]-Submit Popular Searches Apartments in Washington Attorneys in Washington Auto Dealers in Washington Auto Parts in Washington Auto Repair in Washington Beauty Salons in Washington Car Rental in Washington Dentists in Washington Doctors in Washington Flowers in Washington Hotels in Washington Insurance in Washington Loans in Washington Mortgages in Washington Movers in Washington Pizza in Washington Realtors in Washington Restaurants in Washington Storage in Washington Tax Preparation in Washington Travel in Washington Featured More... Powered by Local.com Newsletter Get free daily emails on topics of interest to you, from breaking news to the day’s top stories. Privacy Policy To sign up for our daily emails, click here. To manage your email subscriptions, click here. Find Us On Facebook * - The Washington Times * - Sports * - Opinion * - Andy Parks * - Photos * - Communities Follow Us On Twitter * - The Washington Times * - Politics * - Opinion * - Nation * - World * - D.C. Local * - Culture * - Sports * - Books * - Andy Parks * - Photos * - Communities * Home * News + - Politics + - National + - World + - Security + - Economy + - D.C. Local + - Newsmakers + - Inside the Beltway + - Inside the Ring + - Pruden on Politics + - Embassy Row + - Weather * Opinion + - Editorials + - Commentary + - Letters + - Water Cooler + - Books + - Kuhner + - Nugent + - Cartoons * Video * Specials * Sports + - Football + - Baseball + - Basketball + - NCAA + - Olympics + - Tennis + - Golf + - Hockey + - Soccer + - Horse Racing + - Video * Life + - Entertainment + - Home and Lifestyle + - Travel + - Health + - The List + - Technology + - Books + - Video * Books * Communities * Multimedia * Radio * Specials * Blogs + - Inside Politics + - Water Cooler + - Capitals Watch + - Daly OT + - D1scourse + - From the Sports Editors + - Guns + - Mystics Watch + - Nationals Watch + - Redskins Watch + - Screen Play + - United Watch + - Wizards Watch + - Technology * Subscribe | * Classifieds | * E-Edition | * Customer Service | * Careers | * Terms | * Privacy | * Marketing | * Directory | * RSS | * Advertise | * About | * Contact * All site contents © Copyright 2013 The Washington Times, LLC | 3600 New York Avenue NE | Washington, DC 20002 | 202-636-3000 Quantcast Quantcast