____________________ * News & Politics * Tech * Business * Arts * Life * Health & Science * Sports * Double X * Podcasts * Photos * Video * Slatest * Blogs * MySlate * 99+ * Future Tense The Citizen's Guide to the Future «OLDER A Cutting-Edge Solution to the Old Ketchup Bottle Problem NEWER » NASA May Aim for Manned Mission to Mars by 2033 Canada Also Wants Ability To "Eavesdrop" on Internet Communications By Ryan Gallagher | Posted Wednesday, May 23, 2012, at 7:48 PM ET Share on Facebook Tweet [mySlateLogoBubble.png] MYSLATE [close.jpg] [ ] Save this story. [ ] Follow all Future Tense articles. [ ] Follow the Future Tense blog. [ ] Follow stories by Ryan Gallagher. [saveChanges.png] [close.jpg] [mySlateLogoSmall.png] MySlate is a new tool that lets you track your favorite parts of Slate. You can follow authors and sections, track comment threads you're interested in, and more. [go.png] Canada's Public Safety Minister Vic Toews has spoken in favor of the controversial Internet surveillance bill known as C-30. Canada's Public Safety Minister Vic Toews has spoken in favor of the controversial Internet surveillance bill known as C-30. Photo by MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images As authorities in the United States and United Kingdom push for greater Internet surveillance powers, the Canadian government is locked in its own controversial struggle to wiretap the Web. Canada’s C-30 surveillance bill is much like the FBI’s recently revealed effort to force Internet communications providers such as Skype and Facebook to provide “back doors” for eavesdropping. In some cases, the Canadian legislation would allow police to obtain user data without a warrant. C-30 had appeared dead following a Supreme Court ruling in April that deemed warrantless wiretaps unconstitutional, plus a storm of opposition from privacy groups. But the government said last week it is still moving forward with the plan. Now, new documents obtained under Access to Information laws have revealed Canada’s largest telecoms providers held secret meetings with government officials about the wiretapping proposals. The documents show that after forming a behind-closed-doors working group, the companies and government officials discussed the technical reality of introducing new mass eavesdropping capabilities in fascinating detail. As reported yesterday by Canadian academic Michael Geist, at a September 2011 meeting that included Microsoft, RIM, Bell Canada, Cogeco, Telus, Rogers, and the Information Technology Association of Canada, a government policy document (see below) was distributed, offering guidance to accompany the planned Internet surveillance legislation. The document outlined that under the new law, a “global limit” would set out to define the maximum number of communications interceptions telecoms providers would have to be capable of. This limit would be worked out by dividing the company’s total subscribers by 5,000. So Telus, one of Canada’s largest telecoms firms with more than 7 million subscribers, would have to have capacity to simultaneously wiretap the communications of up to 1,400 users (a number that could be increased by an order issued by government). If it was unable to, or produced errors in the process, it could face fines. The document, which includes detail likely very similar to what is being proposed under the FBI’s CALEA amendment and the U.K.’s Communications Capabilities Development Program, also informed the telecoms firms that they may be expected to “have the capability to transmit the intercepted communications to authorities while they are occurring (in real-time).” And if real-time is not possible, “no later than one second after” will do. It also notes that a service provider may be required enable the interception of “all communications of a single interception subject, by up to five different agencies at the same time.” In most cases, the telecoms providers would have two business days to enable the wiretap. But in some “exceptional circumstances”—on national security grounds or to prevent serious harm to any person or property—a written or verbal request from an “authorized person” would require the company to set up a wiretap within 30 minutes without a court order. And in some cases “any police officer (not necessarily one who has been officially designated) may request subscriber information.” If C-30 is to become law, it is likely some of the provisions will have to be scaled back—particularly elements that include warrantless wiretapping in contravention of the Canadian Supreme Court’s judgment. And public outrage will only be fed by the revelation that the government has been holding rather shady meetings with telecoms providers. The United States is facing its own debate about the secrecy surrounding Internet surveillance policy: Just yesterday CNET revealed that the FBI has recently formed a shadowy Domestic Communications Assistance Center to wiretap Internet and wireless communications. The FBI declined to tell CNET who was responsible for running DCAC, prompting criticism from Jennifer Lynch, a staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation. “We should know more about the program and what the FBI is doing,” Lynch said. “They're doing the best they can to avoid being transparent." Read the C-30 document below. Investigating and Preventing Criminal Electronic Communications Act: Regulations Policy IFRAME: http://www.scribd.com/embeds/94607176/content?start_page=1&view_mode=li st&access_key=key-24buhx2m73ipgzjtqqcv&secret_password=2nzowhkck0lzsqd1 k5rz Want more of your favorite content on the MSN homepage? Try the news, sports or entertainment editons. Share on Facebook Tweet [mySlateLogoSmall.png] __________________________________________________________________ «OLDER A Cutting-Edge Solution to the Old Ketchup Bottle Problem NEWER » NASA May Aim for Manned Mission to Mars by 2033 SLATE'S MOST VIRAL * Pope Benedict’s Abdication Should Remind Us of Long-Standing Allegations Against the Church * This 1922 Kodachrome Test Footage is Strangely Bewitching * Pope Stuns World, Snubs Twitter in Latin Click here to load comments. __________________________________________________________________ « PREV NEXT » __________________________________________________________________ Follow RSS Will Oremus is the lead blogger for Future Tense, reporting on emerging technologies, tech policy, and digital culture. Future Tense is a project from Slate, the New America Foundation, and Arizona State University. [BIO_oremus-will-2011.jpg] * * * * * * 1. Explainer Answers Your Papal Resignation Questions By L.V. Anderson | February 11, 2013 * 2. Pope Benedict’s Abdication Should Remind Us of Long-Standing Allegations Against the Church By Christopher Hitchens | February 11, 2013 * 3. Help! There’s a Dead Guy Who Looks Exactly Like Me. Did I Have a Secret Twin? By Emily Yoffe | February 11, 2013 * 4. SI's Swimsuit Issue Reaches Out to Female Readers With ... Beauty Tips. Where Are the Guys In Speedos? By Amanda Hess | February 11, 2013 * 5. Navy SEAL Recalls Moment He Killed Bin Laden By Josh Voorhees | February 11, 2013 * 1. Pope Benedict’s Abdication Should Remind Us of Long-Standing Allegations Against the Church By Christopher Hitchens | February 11, 2013 * 2. This 1922 Kodachrome Test Footage is Strangely Bewitching By Joan Neuberger | February 8, 2013 * 3. Pope Stuns World, Snubs Twitter in Latin By Josh Voorhees | February 11, 2013 * 4. The Story Behind the Last Papal Resignation By Abby Ohlheiser | February 11, 2013 * 5. Fox News Claims Solar Won't Work in America Because It's Not Sunny Like Germany By Will Oremus | February 7, 2013 * Ars Technica * Atlantic Technology Coverage * Boing Boing * Cross-Check * Danger Room * Edge.org * Electronic Frontier Foundation * Engadget * Ethical Technology * Futurisms * Guardian Notes & Theories * Gizmodo * IO9 * Kurzweil AI * The Loom * Mind Hacks * Nature News Blog * Not Exactly Rocket Science * President’s Bioethics Commission Blog * Robot Overlords * Science Insider * Science Not Fiction * Science Progress * Science Punk * SmartPlanet * Technology Review * Technosociology * Threat Level * Wired Science * Hitchens Archive: Pope Benedict's Entire Career Has the Stench of Evil About It * Who Will Be the Next Pope? Here Are the Front-Runners. * * Why Small-Business Owners Are a Grumpy and Pessimistic Lot * The Problem With Telling People To Rest More So They Can Work Harder [facebook_man_rightrail.gif] Discover Slate With Your Friends See what your friends are reading and automatically share how you're browsing Slate. You control what gets published to your Facebook News Feed. [enableSocialReading.png] Social Reading is Turn ON Turn OFF Feedback < newer | older > To temporarily turn off Social Reading, toggle the social reading button to OFF at the top of this box or in the toolbar areas of this page. This will allow you to see what your friends have read but won't show your reading activity on Slate. [ ] Always notify me when I've shared an article. LOG INTO FACEBOOK To enable Social Reading on Slate, log into... [ Cancel | OK ] * Hitchens Archive: Pope Benedict's Entire Career Has the Stench of Evil About It * Who Will Be the Next Pope? Here Are the Front-Runners. * Why Small-Business Owners Are a Grumpy and Pessimistic Lot * The Problem With Telling People To Rest More So They Can Work Harder * Will the Pope Get a Pension? Is He Still Infallible? Answers to All Your Pope Questions. * A Way To Make Drone Attacks Legal about us | contact us | User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Discussion and Submission Guidelines | Slate on Facebook | ad choices feedback | help | advertise | newsletters | mobile | make Slate your homepage Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Division of the Washington Post Company All contents © 2013 The Slate Group, LLC. All rights reserved.