#Culture RSS feed Twilight RSS feed World news RSS feed Feminism RSS feed Life and style RSS feed Women RSS feed Books RSS feed Fifty Shades of Grey RSS feed Comment is free RSS feed Turn autoplay off Turn autoplay on Please activate cookies in order to turn autoplay off * Jump to content [s] * Jump to comments [c] * Jump to site navigation [0] * Jump to search [4] * Terms and conditions [8] Edition: UK * US Sign in Mobile * Your profile * Your details * Your comments * Your clippings * Your lists Sign out Mobile About us * About us * Contact us * Press office * Guardian Print Centre * Guardian readers' editor * Observer readers' editor * Terms of service * Privacy policy * Advertising guide * Digital archive * Digital edition * Guardian Weekly * Buy Guardian and Observer photos Today's paper * The Observer * Comment * Sport * New Review * Magazine * Observer Food Monthly Subscribe * Subscribe to the Guardian * iPhone app * iPad edition * Kindle * Extra * Guardian Weekly * Digital edition * All our services The Guardian home ____________________ [Comment is free] Search * News * Sport * Comment * Culture * Business * Money * Life & style * Travel * Environment * Tech * TV * Video * Dating * Offers * Jobs * Comment is free Twilight is not feminist: it's female masochism This saga is a teen version of Fifty Shades of Grey and illustrates the growth of the loving-slave fantasy in popular fiction * Share * Tweet this * * * Email * Tanya Gold * + Tanya Gold + The Guardian, Friday 16 November 2012 21.30 GMT * Jump to comments (…) Simon pemberton illo Illustration by Simon Pemberton The Yahoo homepage streamed the red carpet premiere of Twilight: Breaking Dawn (Part 2) this week; the final film adaptation of Stephenie Meyer's series of teen vampire novels has finally escaped. The novels sold more than 100m copies, and are considered so significant that the Vatican, ever in search of devils, has attacked them â as it attacked the more benevolent Harry Potter novels before. But this is only partly a story about the power of marketing, even if a group of Boston schoolchildren decided that vampires did exist and, in a strange and tiny re-enactment of the Salem witch trials, accordingly looked for a victim to punish. This is a story about the swelling of female masochism in popular fiction. Like Fifty Shades of Grey by EL James, which Meyer's novels inspired, Twilight is a loving-slave fantasy â Fifty Shades for teenage girls, except with vampires, because teenagers are too young for shades of grey, and prefer their disempowerment fantasies to look like fairytales. (Older women, I think, like them to look like expensive hotels or adverts for Audis.) Some women have suggested that Fifty Shades is a feminist novel in disguise, but this is nonsense: if so, why doesn't the heroine, Anastasia Steele, like so many masochists, switch and give Christian Grey â the billionaire who reminds me of a young Jeffrey Archer, or maybe even of Richard Branson â a kick in his cable-knit jumper? I was momentarily happy to see women reading explicit pornography on the London Underground but then I realised it was S&M â he S, she M. Why would it be anything else? Twilight is equally reductive. Bella Swan falls in love with a vampire called Edward Cullen, who is very rich, because if you aren't rich in trashy teen fiction, you're not worth loving: Stephenie Meyer is not Thomas Hardy. (The more wholesome suitor, who is a werewolf, obviously has no money at all; he is essentially a trailer-park mythical creature from the wrong side of Grimm.) Work is an irrelevance for Bella because this is princess fiction too: in one passage, which I read screaming at midnight, Edward tells her: "No, you don't [want to go to college! You want to be an accessories buyer for Jigsaw]!" Well, yes, maybe she doesn't want to go to college if passion is, literally, consuming. Bella is rescued from a buffet of terrible fates, including a nest of Italian vampires who look like fashion designers; whole tracts of the movie scripts consist of repetitions of the line, "Bella has got to be safe!" â which is not only offensive but also incredibly boring. But the most terrible fate is already with her: she cooks, she cleans (she is a sexually promising Famous Five heroine); she does not have sex with Edward before her marriage, because nice girls don't in abstinence porn â which, if Twilight has a genre, is surely the one. Finally â and if you hate a spoiler, I care not â she becomes a vampire. Two of Twilight's themes are particularly disturbing. One is the sexual violence of the central relationship. In a fascinating blog, the anonymous Live Journal user kar3ning detailed 15 signs of an abusive relationship, as named by the American National Domestic Violence hotline, and found many of them in Twilight. Kar3ning was attacked online by angry fans, in the same way you might be attacked for suggesting the Mr Men books were racist, but kar3ning is right. There is the controlling male, the female with low self-esteem, the threats of suicide and murder, and so on. The day after her wedding night Bella examines the bruises on her body with something like aroused awe: "There was a faint shadow across one of my cheekbones, and my lips were a little swollen ⦠the rest of me was decorated with patches of blue and purple." The other is the anti-abortion agenda, which could be ignored were the premiere not live on Yahoo, as Meyer acts as the cultural arm of Abort67. Bella conceives a child on her wedding night. She resists all pleas to remove it: it breaks her ribs, her pelvis and, in an unconscious homage to early Ian McEwan, her spine; then it kills her. All this is noble, because Bella is a good mother and dies for her child as a loving martyr to the weakness of her own body. (The star of the movies, Kristen Stewart, is also rather unlucky in real life. She was photographed kissing a married man last year and, because abstinence porn can bleed into life, she is now talked of as "unbankable", Hollywood's own death, and her personal morality is â in ways the actresses of the 1950s would recognise â a public issue.) Because Bella becomes a vampire and can, by the end, jump off cliffs and wrestle with mountain lions, it has been said that Twilight is a story of female empowerment. However, with all that goes before, it is more likely that Bella Swan surrendered her mortality (and what more can you surrender?) for a murderous love, and a private island. A kind of twilight, sure. Twitter: @TanyaGold1 * Print this Print this * Share * Contact us Send to a friend Close this popup Sender's name ____________________ Recipient's email address ____________________ Send Your IP address will be logged Share Close this popup Short link for this page: http://gu.com/p/3bqf5 * StumbleUpon * reddit * Tumblr * Digg * LinkedIn * Google Bookmarks * del.icio.us * livejournal * Facebook * Twitter Contact us Close this popup * Report errors or inaccuracies: reader@guardian.co.uk * Letters for publication should be sent to: letters@guardian.co.uk * If you need help using the site: userhelp@guardian.co.uk * Call the main Guardian and Observer switchboard: +44 (0)20 3353 2000 * + Advertising guide + License/buy our content Article history About this article Close this popup Twilight is not feminist: it's female masochism | Tanya Gold This article was published on guardian.co.uk at 21.30 GMT on Friday 16 November 2012. A version appeared on p46 of the Main section section of the Guardian on Saturday 17 November 2012. It was last modified at 00.02 GMT on Saturday 17 November 2012. Culture * Twilight World news * Feminism Life and style * Women Books * Fifty Shades of Grey More from Comment is free on Culture * Twilight World news * Feminism Life and style * Women Books * Fifty Shades of Grey * Share * Tweet this * * * Email Comments Click here to join the discussion. We can't load the discussion on guardian.co.uk because you don't have JavaScript enabled. We Own The Weekend * Get £2 off Guardian & Observer Celebrate the Guardian and Observer Weekend by signing up to receive £1 off the Saturday Guardian and £1 off the Observer for two weekends. Watch our video and get your vouchers Soulmates The Guardian's online dating site Start dating like-minded people today Join Soulmates for free and find your perfect match * sofani5, 27 * GuyJ-81, 31 * I am a[Man__] * Seeking[Women______] * Aged[25_] to [45_] * In[United Kingdom______________________________] * Within[20 miles_] * Of ____________________ (Submit) Search * Join for free Create your own dating profile and view your matches * Join for free Create your own profile and view your matches * Find a Soulmate Find like-minded people looking for a date in your area * Learn more Discover how Soulmates can help you find who you're looking for Today's best video * Composite of images from films reviewed on this week's Guardian Film Show The Guardian Film Show: Flight Xan Brooks, Peter Bradshaw and Catherine Shoard review Flight, Bullhead, Hyde Park on Hudson and Antiviral * Adam Jones Six Nations 2013: what are Wales's chances? Can Wales turn their fortunes around in the Six Nations? * Colourful tin cans of air on stall in China Cans of fresh air given out in China Chen Guangbiao gives away tins of air to raise awareness about pollution * Bela Bartok The Rest is Noise: Rise of Nationalism The Rest Is Noise festival series continues with the Rise of Nationalism On Comment is free * Most viewed * Latest Last 24 hours 1. [How-To-Lose-Friends-And-A-005.jpg] 1. Five reasons to leave Britain | Victoria Coren 2. 2. Tips are not optional, they are how waiters get paid in America | Chelsea Welch 3. 3. Seriously â do teachers in private schools really expect our applause? 4. 4. Brooklyn College's academic freedom increasingly threatened over Israel event | Glenn Greenwald 5. 5. A poisoned vagina? What an intriguing yet stupid murder weapon | Naomi McAuliffe 6. More most viewed Last 24 hours 1. [Syrian-rebel-fighters-sta-003.jpg] 1. The new Syria will need human rights, not reprisals | Kenneth Roth 2. 2. Martin Rowson on the gay marriage debate â cartoon 3. 3. Open door: Chris Elliott: The readers' editor on⦠the ratio of men to women in the birthdays column 4. 4. Mid Staffs was a betrayal of the NHS | Mike Farrar 5. 5. Beyoncé has earned our respect | Nadifa Mohamed 6. All today's stories Comment is free on Twitter Latest news, views and links from Comment is free journalists and editors * mattseaton mattseaton: Steaming http://t.co/5aCXGqsf about 54 minutes ago * SeumasMilne SeumasMilne: Sunday Times story today on ex-BAE boss Evans & Saudi kickbacks part of vicious UK-Saudi arms racket going back decades http://t.co/MNTZH5W5 about 1 hour, 54 minutes ago * HadleyFreeman HadleyFreeman: Less than 4 hours until THE sporting event of the year, people! #sporty #ohyeah http://t.co/3R1xzrTK about 2 hours, 24 minutes ago ⢠Follow our writers and editors on a Twitter list eatright Look and feel great with our online healthy eating and dieting service. eatright * 13 personalised diet plans * Tasty recipes * Support from qualified nutrionists * Personalised fitness programme Join today and get 3 months for the price of 2 Guardian Bookshop This week's bestsellers 1. Examined Life 1. Examined Life by Stephen Grosz £11.99 2. 2. Return of a King by William Dalrymple £20.00 3. 3. Landscapes of the Metropolis of Death by Otto Dov Kulka £11.99 4. 4. Stag's Leap by Sharon Olds £8.00 5. 5. You are Awful (but I Like You) by Tim Moore £6.39 Search the Guardian bookshop ____________________ (Submit) Search comment is free… Latest posts * Kenneth Roth 23min ago The new Syria will need human rights, not reprisals Kenneth Roth: The top priority is bringing an end to the slaughter. But we must ensure that, after Assad, revenge does not lead to abuses * Martin Rowson 36min ago Martin Rowson on the gay marriage debate â cartoon A major rebellion among Tory backbenchers is expected when the equal marriage bill gets its second reading Comment from the paper * Mike Farrar: Mid Staffs was a betrayal of the NHS * Should parents have the right to smack their children? * Matthew Todd: The roots of gay shame Bestsellers from our Guardian stores * halogenheaters - guardianessentials - promo Halogen heaters Halogen heaters for flexible, immediate warmth. Get two for just £44.99 plus p&p. More from Guardian Essentials * icetreads - guardianoffers.co.uk - promo Ice Treads Ice treads simply fit over your shoe. One pair just £12.99, two pairs £19.99. More from Guardian Essentials Sponsored feature guardian jobs Find the latest jobs in your sector: * Arts & heritage * Charities * Education * Environment * Government * Graduate * Health * Marketing & PR * Media * Sales * Senior executive * Social care Browse all jobs media_______________ Search Manager, Marketing International New Media (EMEA) London | £Competitive NBC UNIVERSAL Top stories in this section Top videos Most popular Today in pictures * sports peronality 2012 BBC Sports Personality of the Year â in pictures Bradley Wiggins capped his remarkable sporting year by taking home the big prize at the ceremony in London * Martin Parr's M Video Christmas party photograph Dinner, dusk and dancing Russians: my best winter shot A glass of wine with a rough sleeper, Santa in trunks, a thousand partying Muscovites ⦠in a My Best Shot special, top photographers pick the image that sums up winter for them * Kimon, a long-tailed monkey grooms a kitten, whom, she treats as her baby, Bintan Island, Indonesia Monkey adopts kitten â in pictures Kimon, an eight-year-old pet female long-tailed monkey, treats a kitten as her baby in Bintan Island, Indonesia * License/buy our content | * Privacy policy | * Terms & conditions | * Advertising guide | * Accessibility | * A-Z index | * Inside the Guardian blog | * About us | * Work for us | * Join our dating site today * © 2013 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. * Share * Tweet this * * Quantcast