#Slate Magazine Slate Search Should You Put Your Money in an Offshore Tax Haven? [facebook-share.032f05b5.png] Slate Sign In Sign Up Search Slate Explainer Answers to your questions about the news. Feb. 15 2013 1:17 PM Tax Holiday [facebook-share.032f05b5.png] Should you stash your money in the Cayman Islands? By Brian Palmer Jack Lew testifying before the Senate Finance Committee. Jack Lew testifies before the Senate Finance Committee Photo by Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images Jack Lew, President Obama’s nominee for treasury secretary, faced questions about his investment in a Cayman Islands-based hedge fund during his confirmation hearings Wednesday. President Obama railed against offshore tax havens in both of his presidential campaigns. But if offshoring is generally legal—and seemingly lucrative—should you try it? Probably not. You can avoid only specific kinds of taxes using an offshore tax haven, and, for the most part, those taxes are significant only to large groups or very wealthy individuals. Consider, for example, the unrelated-business-income tax. Income from investments inside retirement accounts is generally untaxed until the owner withdraws the profits later in life. However, for complicated historical-legal reasons, if you use retirement funds to borrow money, and then invest that borrowed money in a partnership, you must pay a 35 percent tax on the profits. Hedge funds and pensions circumvent this tax by routing borrowed money through a corporation in an offshore tax haven, which is not the sort of business investment that triggers the 35 percent tax. The trick is known as “round-tripping,” because the money passes through a foreign country on a round trip from the United States. (You may be involved in round-tripping through your own pension fund without knowing it.) It costs money to set up a foreign corporation, though, so this strategy only makes sense for individuals who have vast wealth. If you have enough money in your IRA to consider buying a controlling stake in a business, you probably shouldn’t rely on the Explainer for tax advice. There are a couple of other scenarios in which you might want to use an offshore tax haven, like if you’re starting a dot-com with friends from other countries. But, for the most part, there are no lawful benefits to opening a savings or investment account in a low-tax or no-tax foreign country. U.S. citizens are required to pay tax to the federal government on foreign investment income, even if the interest, dividends, and appreciation never come home to the United States. Failing to report such income constitutes tax fraud and carries the potential for a 75 percent penalty and a prison sentence. In fact, the federal government requires you to disclose all foreign holdings if they total more than $10,000, even if you have no interest to report on that money. Failure to notify the government of those accounts, using the colorfully named “FBAR” form, carries a penalty of 50 percent of the account value or $100,000, whichever is greater. (The IRS periodically announces amnesties for people willing to come clean about their offshore accounts.) Countries that have served as tax havens, like Switzerland, Panama, and Lichtenstein, are increasingly signing agreements to disclose the existence of these accounts to foreign governments, making it difficult to avoid detection. Advertisement If you’re really serious about tax avoidance, you can’t stop at offshoring your savings—you’ll have to offshore yourself. Last year, the federal government predicted that thousands of people would renounce their citizenship by the end of 2012, many of them to avoid paying U.S. tax. There’s still a financial hit, though. When you give up your citizenship, you have to pay a one-time 15 percent tax on all assets. It could still make financial sense: The effective tax rate for U.S. expatriates in some Caribbean islands is under 5 percent. In giving up your passport, you’d be following Facebook co-founder Eduardo Saverin—who relinquished U.S. citizenship before the company’s IPO—and actor Jet Li. Gerard Depardieu became a Russian citizen this year to avoid French taxes. Got a question about today’s news? Ask the Explainer Explainer thanks Samuel Brunson of Loyola University of Chicago, James Hines of the University of Michigan Law School, and Daniel Shaviro of the NYU School of Law. Brian Palmer is Slate's chief explainer. He also writes How and Why and Ecologic for the Washington Post. Email him at explainerbrian@gmail.com. Follow him on Twitter. REPRINT PRINT EMAIL [facebook-share.032f05b5.png] (BUTTON) Load Comments Powered by Livefyre Slate Sign In Sign Up Search Most Read * 1. Phil Robertson Advised Men to Marry 15-Year-Old Girls Because They Will “Pick Your Ducks” * 2. What Happened With That Biological Mother? Dear Prudence Follows Up. * 3. Why Buying Cocaine Is Like Donating to the Nazi Party * 4. Starbucks Sends Cease and Desist Letter to Bar for “F Word” Beer, Owner Sends Back $6 Check and This Letter * 5. Downton Abbey and Other Examples of Total Quality Collapse Most Shared * 1. Why Buying Cocaine Is Like Donating to the Nazi Party * 2. Phil Robertson Advised Men to Marry 15-Year-Old Girls Because They Will “Pick Your Ducks” * 3. Republican Acceptance of Evolution Plummets * 4. How Would the U.S. Media Cover Duck Dynasty If It Were in Another Country? * 5. Woah! Why Are You Spelling It That Way? [78144477_2990754138001_TNC131230-pigs-1280.jpg.CROP.hd-large.jpg] Some Pig Dear Prudence Dec. 29 2013 11:39 PMNew Year, New YouPrudie hears back from the most memorable letter writers of 2013.Emily Yoffe Medical Examiner Dec. 29 2013 11:35 PMCocaine Is EvilThe gruesomeness of the drug trade rivals any atrocities in history.Erik Vance Science Dec. 30 2013 8:24 AMAre Hobbits Human?Textual and genetic analysis of our closest real and magical relatives.Matthew Yglesias [footer-top-row-1.01c87d51.png] Slate Book Club APRIL - THE BLUE FOX [footer-top-row-2.9b95217b.png] Slate Live Events APRIL 26 - DEAR PRUDENCE NYC [footer-top-row-3.3fea82b9.png] Slate Store NEW SPRING SHIRTS [footer-top-row-4.2992d975.png] Slate Membership VIP ACCESS FOLLOW SLATE [yellow-twitterNew.821dc365.png] [yellow-facebookNew.74981e6f.png] SLATE ON IPAD IPHONE ANDROID KINDLE REPRINTS ADVERTISE WITH US * ABOUT US * CONTACT US * WORK WITH US * USER AGREEMENT * PRIVACY POLICY * FAQ * FEEDBACK * CORRECTIONS * PHOTO COVER CREDITS * [the-slate-group-logo.12cbe5ac.png] * [the-root-logo.74009c0a.png] * Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company. All contents © 2013 The Slate Group, LLC. All rights reserved. Slate Sign In Sign Up Search ____________________ Search ____________________ This will never be shared ____________________ This will appear when you post on the site ____________________ Create Free Account ____________________ Forgot Username or Password? ____________________ Go OR (BUTTON) Facebook (BUTTON) Twitter (BUTTON) Google ____________________ The XX Factor [144108809.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] Phil Robertson Advised Men to Marry 15-Year-Old Girls Because They Will “Pick Your Ducks” What Happened With That Biological Mother? Dear Prudence Follows Up. Why Buying Cocaine Is Like Donating to the Nazi Party Starbucks Sends Cease and Desist Letter to Bar for “F Word” Beer, Owner Sends Back $6 Check and This Letter Downton Abbey and Other Examples of Total Quality Collapse The Slatest [98571828.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] Starbucks Sends Cease and Desist Letter to Bar for “F Word” Beer, Owner Sends Back $6 Check and This Letter Tim Tebow Joins ESPN, But Not Giving Up on NFL How Does Al Qaeda Spend Its Money? Just Check Out These Expense Reports. Beyoncé’s Sample of the Challenger Explosion Isn’t As Random As You Think Astronauts Slam Beyoncé's Sampling Challenger Space Shuttle Explosion Audio VIEW ALL The World [51392818.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] The Next County Adopting the Euro Could Be the Last China’s Most Famous Movie Director Under Fire for Violating One-Child Policy Judge Pauley Got It Right: The NSA’s Metadata Program Is Perfectly Constitutional How Would the U.S. Media Cover Duck Dynasty If It Were in Another Country? VIEW ALL Brow Beat [180615781.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] Beyoncé’s Sample of the Challenger Explosion Isn’t As Random As You Think TV 2013: The Hirsute Hams of Duck Dynasty New York’s Restaurant Critic Just Dropped the Pretense of Anonymity. Good for Him! I’d Love to See the Headless Horseman Battle Brienne of Tarth VIEW ALL Future Tense [1388439675.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] The Death and Burial of Facebook, In Two Charts How Do You Tell a Whole City to Shush? How Google Wins When the Economy Suffers Five Ways Drones Could Do Some Good In 2014 VIEW ALL Moneybox [1388431515.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] Here's How to Improve Mass Transit The Lobbyists and Legislators Who Kill Municipal Broadband in America All This Time I've Been Wrong About the Fed How to Fix the Calendar VIEW ALL Outward [82675846.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] The Libertarian Party Has Failed Gay Rights What Were the Design Goals for The Sims 2? Let's Resolve in the New Year to Stop Using That Expression About Breaking Eggs and Making Omelets A Map of Noise Complaints in 1920s Manhattan, and Other Stupendous Digital History Projects VIEW ALL Science [131227_SCI_ArwenAragorn.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] Are Hobbits Human? We Don’t Necessarily Need to Mate to Find Out. Two Fireballs Light Up the Midwest after Christmas Why Buying Cocaine Is Like Donating to the Nazi Party Another Brain-Melting Illusion: The Dragon That Follows Your Gaze VIEW ALL The XX Factor [144108809.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] Phil Robertson Advised Men to Marry 15-Year-Old Girls Because They Will “Pick Your Ducks” The Year of the Trigger Warning Oh, SoulCycle. You Jumped the Shark in 2013. Frozen Teaches Girls the Dangers of a Whirlwind Romance VIEW ALL Sports Nut [131230_SNUT_CalBearsFans.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] It’s Time to Evict Big-Time Sports from American Higher Education How Impressive Was Matt Prater’s NFL Record 64-Yard Field Goal? How Will the United States Fare in the World Cup’s Group of Death? How Did Jameis Winston Evade a Rape Charge? VIEW ALL Video [78144477_2990754138001_TNC131230-pigs-1280.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall. jpg] Important Science of the Day: Living, Breathing, Glow-in-the-Dark Pigs An Amazing Supermaterial That Could Be Used for Terminator-Style Robots Australia's Sharks Are Tweeting When They're Near a Beach The Next Great Wine, Made in ... China? VIEW ALL Behold [slate_10.jpg.CROP.promo-mediumsmall.jpg] The Homes of Hoarders Returning Home and Capturing the Old Russia Documenting a Way of Life Along the River Gambia Christmas Cheer Never Looked So Unsettling Lexicon Valley: Why Is No Among a Child's First Words? Collision Low Crossers Is an Instant Classic on Life in the NFL Would You Rather Be Funnier or Smarter? The Best Political Gabfest Segments of the Year, Including Colbert’s Surprise Appearance VIEW ALL * POPULAR * RECENT * NEWS & POLITICS * ARTS * TECHNOLOGY * BUSINESS * LIFE * HEALTH & SCIENCE * DOUBLE X * SPORTS * VIDEO * PHOTOS * PODCASTS Follow Slate * NORTH KOREA * GUN CONTROL * SEX * BOSTON * IMMIGRATION * BOSTON * NORTH KOREA * BOSTON Voices * Emily Bazelon * John Dickerson * Simon Doonan * Daniel Engber * Fred Kaplan * Josh Levin * Dahlia Lithwick * Willa Paskin * Troy Patterson * William Saletan * Dana Stevens * Seth Stevenson * David Weigel * Matthew Yglesias * Emily Yoffe Blogs * Atlas Obscura * Bad Astronomy * Behold * Brow Beat * Crime * The Eye * Future Tense * Lexicon Valley * Moneybox * Outward * Quora * The Vault * The World * Weigel * Wild Things * The XX Factor * The Slatest Sign Up Sign In (BUTTON) YOUR RECOMMENDED STORIES Slate Sign In Sign Up Search