#alternate Skip to navigation Skip to content Help using this website - Accessibility statement JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings. * My News * My Clippings * My Comments * My History * My Benefits * Subscribe * Log in * Register Personalise your news, save articles to read later and customise settings If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page. If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page. The Sydney Morning Herald Business * News 1. Today's News & Views 2. Comment & Analysis 3. World Business 4. Mining & Resources 5. Banking & Finance 6. The Economy * Markets * Quotes * Portfolio * Money * Property Focus * Small Business + Startup + Growing + Managing + Franchising + Trends + Entrepreneur + Marketing + Finance + Technology + Resources * Executive Style * Compare & Save + Credit Cards + Debit Cards + Home Loans + Personal Loans + Car Loans + Term Deposits + Bank Accounts + Saving Accounts * Events You are here: Home BusinessDay Michael West Search smh: ____________________ Search in: * Business + smh.com.au + Web + Business Search Banks use tax havens to conceal Business Date September 9, 2013 * (1) * (BUTTON) Read later Michael West Michael West Business columnist View more articles from Michael West Email Michael * Tweet * * * * submit to reddit * Email article * Print * Reprints & permissions * IFRAME: http://ad-apac.doubleclick.net/N6411/adi/onl.smh.bus/bus/columnist; cat1=columnist;cat=bus;ctype=article;sz=120x50;tile=3;ord=2.7747447 E7? Why does BHP have offices in the Swiss town Zug? Why did the Commonwealth Bank previously make such a handsome profit in Malta? Why does Macquarie control 49 entities registered in the Cayman Islands, 18 in Bermuda, nine in Mauritius, six in the Isle of Jersey, four in the British Virgin Islands, two in Aruba and one apiece in the Dominican Republic, Isle of Man, Curacao and the Netherland Antilles? Is it that the bank has diversified its island operations between the Caribbean Sea, the Indian Ocean and the English Channel in case there is a tsunami? No, this significant island presence is complemented by 14 entities in Luxembourg, 58 in Ireland and four in landlocked Switzerland. Advertisement IFRAME: http://ad-apac.doubleclick.net/N6411/adi/onl.smh.bus/bus/columnist;cat1 =columnist;cat=bus;ctype=article;pos=3;sz=300x250;tile=4;ord=2.7747447E 7? What all these places have in common is that they are tax havens. And the reason companies, funds and trusts are registered in such exotic locations is that they have something to hide. Most often, but not always, that something is profits. It would do no good, for instance, for this reporter to inquire why Macquarie's Caliburn Greater China Fund Segregated Portfolio (a sub-fund of Caliburn Absolute Strategies SPC) is domiciled in the Cayman Islands. One can only surmise that if the shareholders and directors of this Caliburn wanted their business known more intimately by the public they would not be locating it in the Caymans. Same deal for Rupert Murdoch's News Corp, with its 19 Caymans companies, 17 entities in Mauritius and a prolific 25 in the British Virgin Islands. This is not to say, as a generalisation, that there is anything wrong with minimising tax. Within the law, it is perfectly acceptable to get your tax bill down. Just as, in a democracy that holds dear to the principles of free speech, a journalist is perfectly entitled to say, for instance, that Google Australia is a disgrace for paying almost no tax on its billions in income in this country. Google - which shifts its profits offshore to low-tax jurisdictions - is a worse offender on aggressive tax plays than Macquarie or News. For governments and their citizens around the world, however, the law is proving to be a blunt and clumsy instrument when it comes to enforcing tax. If Joe Citizen pulls off a $2000 swiftie on the social security apparatus he could invite a stint behind bars for his second offence. If Joe Corporation Limited pulls off a fancy $200 million tax scam and is pinged by the Australian Taxation Office, it merely behaves in an indignant and victimised manner, cites its expensive legal advice and appeals the impertinence of the taxman in the Federal Court. Joe Citizen picks up a good deal of the costs - the silks, the solicitors, the lot - even if Joe Corporation loses. Appealing and appealing again are deductible expenses of doing business. The point of all this is that tax is soon to be an increasingly public issue globally as governments struggle to fund their deficits in the face of ever more sophisticated corporate tax frolics. But, the taxman is turning up the screws - as evinced by last week's judgment in the Federal Court, where Justice Richard Edmonds tossed out Macquarie's application for an injunction to stop the ATO from issuing amended tax assessments for 2006, 2007 and 2008. An amended assessment, potentially in the vicinity of $295 million, poses not merely financial risk but reputational risk too. Which brings us to last month's story here that Sydney Airport had paid no tax since Macquarie bought it in 2002. We are going to undertake a ''reverse James Hird'' here - that is, do the opposite of saying sorry while not really meaning it and claiming to have done nothing wrong. While the story was correct, and we don't apologise for it, it did suffer from an error of omission for which we owe further clarity on Macquarie's behalf. Thanks to its trust structure, it is the investors, rather than the airport, which are obliged to pay tax - not that they necessarily do (vid the ATO's investigation into the redeemable preference shares). Still, trust or not, this stuff needs to be tightened up. As one of the finest tax brains in the country chuckled in the aftermath of the story: ''It's a 'zero leakage' structure, as we call it in the tax trade''! * Tweet * * * * submit to reddit * Email article * Print * Reprints & permissions Advertisement Most popular 1 ELECTRICITY. MELB.000407. AFR . PIC BY JESSICA SHAPIRO... ELECTRICITY METER GENERIC, ENERGY, POWER USAGE, INDUSTRY, RESOURCES. Putting a price on your bill-paying laziness Contains: total comments102 2 Generic photo of the ASX board in Melbourne.I Shares lift as weaker dollar helps miners Contains: 3 bernie brookes Myer says sorry for Boxing Day online shopping ... Contains: 4 Forge Group workers. Forge denies takeover offer as shares rocket up 54pc Contains: 5 Gold Gold set for biggest annual plunge in 30 years Contains: Most Searched Shares Get the latest quotes & charts Enter company name or ASX code ____________________ Find Featured advertisers IFRAME: http://ad-apac.doubleclick.net/N6411/adi/onl.smh.bus/bus/columnist;cat1 =columnist;cat=bus;ctype=article;pos=1;sz=149x170;tile=8;ord=2.7747447E 7? IFRAME: http://ad-apac.doubleclick.net/N6411/adi/onl.smh.bus/bus/columnist;cat1 =columnist;cat=bus;ctype=article;pos=2;sz=149x170;tile=9;ord=2.7747447E 7? Special offers Powered by Mozo IFRAME: http://mozo-widgets.f2.com.au/widgets/multiwidget3/SMH/FM-BUSINESS View these special offers by Mozo. Executive Style (BUTTON) More * Travel * Motors * Culture * Luxury * Management * Fitness Where the super-rich will be in 2014 Megan Willett If you want to hang with the upper crust in 2014, here's a copy of the flight plan. Advertisement IFRAME: http://ad-apac.doubleclick.net/N6411/adi/onl.smh.bus/bus/columnist;cat1 =columnist;cat=bus;ctype=article;pos=2;sz=300x250;tile=10;ord=2.7747447 E7? Money mozo image for Money unit of Rainbow strip 0% intro rate cards for the silly season * Smh.com.au * Compare All Saving Accounts * Compare All Credit Cards * Compare All Home Loans Motoring Porsche 918 Spyder Best cars of 2013 * Drive.com.au * Holden shutdown: Full story * Over 500 car reviews a year * Cars for sale on Drive.com.au Real Estate Searching for property has never been easier Find your perfect property match now * Smh.com.au * Buy real estate * How much is my house worth? * Euro investors eye market Holiday Rentals Life's too short Life's too short! * Stayz.com.au * Escape to Brisbane * Escape to Broome * Escape to Melbourne TheVine panties Why I hate the word 'panties' * Thevine.com.au * Entertainment & celebrity news * Latest fashion coverage * Music news and reviews Compare and Save Skip to: * Best Deals * Mobile * Broadband * Home Loans * Credit Cards * Low Rate Cards * Rewards Cards * Savings Accts * Term Deposits * Loans Check out today's best deals Virgin No Annual Fee [cs-virgin-no-annual-fee.png] $50 gift card offer until 14 Jan 2014. Conditions apply Find Out More Top Home Loans [cs-hl-trim.png] Trim $1000s off your mortgage. Compare home loans & save Compare Now Cheap Personal Loans [cs-pl-generic-neon.png] Borrow money on the cheap with loans from 6.99% p.a. Today's Top Rates Bonus $100 Visa [mobile_160x70_1213_100card_a.jpg] Hurry for December deal on Telstra and Optus $100 Visa Card iPhone 5s [mobile_160x70_0913_iphone5s_g.jpg] Bonus $100 on iPhone Plans from two major carriers Compare plans Readers' most viewed Most viewed articles on Brisbane Times Top 5 Business articles 1. Putting a price on your bill-paying laziness 2. Myer says sorry for Boxing Day online shopping failure with free delivery 3. Shares lift as weaker dollar helps miners 4. Gold set for biggest annual plunge in 30 years 5. Most importers and exporters prefer dollar value of $US90-c--$1 Most viewed articles on WA Today Top 5 Business articles 1. Myer says sorry for Boxing Day online shopping failure with free delivery 2. Putting a price on your bill-paying laziness 3. Gold set for biggest annual plunge in 30 years 4. Forge denies takeover offer as shares rocket up 54pc 5. Shares lift as weaker dollar helps miners Most viewed articles on The Age Top 5 Business articles 1. Putting a price on your bill-paying laziness 2. Myer says sorry for Boxing Day online shopping failure with free delivery 3. Shares lift as weaker dollar helps miners 4. Gold set for biggest annual plunge in 30 years 5. Forge denies takeover offer as shares rocket up 54pc Most viewed articles on Canberra Times Top 5 Business articles 1. Putting a price on your bill-paying laziness 2. Myer says sorry for Boxing Day online shopping failure with free delivery 3. Shares lift as weaker dollar helps miners 4. Crocs CEO departs with private equity bailout as popularity slides 5. Most importers and exporters prefer dollar value of $US90-c--$1 Most viewed articles on The Sydney Morning Herald Top 5 Business articles 1. Putting a price on your bill-paying laziness 2. Shares lift as weaker dollar helps miners 3. Myer says sorry for Boxing Day online shopping failure with free delivery 4. Forge denies takeover offer as shares rocket up 54pc 5. Gold set for biggest annual plunge in 30 years * SMH Home * NSW * Federal Politics * World * National * Environment * Business * Digital Life * Entertainment * Life & Style * Travel * Cars * Exec Style * Sport * Weather * Sydney Morning Herald * Sitemap * About Us * Contact Us * Advertise with Us * AM Today * Last 8 days * Text Version * Site Accessibility Guide * Connect * Mobile Site * SMH for iPad * Newspaper Replica * RSS * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * Products & Services * Subscribe * Manage My Subscription * My Benefits * Digital Subscription FAQs * Good Food Guide * SMH Shop * Newsletters * Classifieds * Place an Ad * Accommodation * Cars * Dating * Jobs * Property Price Data * Real Estate * Buy and Sell * Tributes * Celebrations * Special Reports * Fairfax Media * Member Centre * Conditions of Use * Privacy Policy * News Store Archive * Photo Sales * Purchase Front Pages * Fairfax Syndication * Fairfax Events * Fairfax Careers * Press Council Fairfax Media Our Sites * The Sydney Morning Herald * The Age * MyCareer * Domain * Drive * RSVP * Essential Baby * InvestSMART * APM * Stayz * Weatherzone * TheVine Our Partners * Buy & Sell * Cracker Copyright (c) 2013 Fairfax Media Feedback Form * 3:20PM Tuesday Dec 31, 2013 * 16,985 online now * Do you know more about a story? (BUTTON) contact us (BUTTON) Close Provide detailed information, including contact details (if relevant) ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ Post * Real Estate * Cars * Jobs * Dating * Newsletters * (BUTTON) Fairfax Media NetworkMore (BUTTON) Close News & Weather + smh.com.au + theage.com.au + brisbanetimes.com.au + canberratimes.com.au + watoday.com.au + weatherzone.com.au Business & Finance + businessday.com.au + brw.com.au + afr.com + afrmagazine.com.au + smartinvestor.com.au + investsmart.com.au Lifestyle + life & style + dailylife.com.au + thevine.com.au + essentialbaby.com.au + essentialkids.com.au + findababysitter.com.au + goodfood.com.au Classifieds + domain.com.au + drive.com.au + mycareer.com.au + rsvp.com.au + stayz.com.au + Member benefits + Advertise with us + Newsletters + Full list of sites + About Fairfax Media + Privacy + Terms & Conditions