#next Nydn All Featured Columnist feed NYDN Rss Opinion Rss [p?c1=2&c2=7190388&c3=&c4=&c5=&c6=&c15=&cj=1] * Friday, December 27, 2013 * NYDailyNews.com / Opinion IFRAME: http://www.facebook.com/plugins/like.php?href=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.faceboo k.com%2Fthenewyorkdailynews&send=false&layout=box_count&width=48&show_f aces=false&font&colorscheme=light&action=like&height=90 Follow @nydailynews Jobs Classifieds Contests Reader Offers Home Delivery Services Apps Search site_________ Search Field [BUTTON Input] (not implemented)______ * site * blogs Daily News * America * New York * Local * News * Politics * Sports * Showbiz * Opinion More of Opinion : Discussions Blogs * Living * Photos * Video * Autos Opinion Death penalty is dead wrong: It's time to outlaw capital punishment in America - completely By Mario M. Cuomo / SPECIAL TO THE DAILY NEWS Sunday, October 2, 2011, 4:00 AM Print * Print * Comment In 2008, 46 people were sent to the execution chamber in the United States. Ted S. Warren/AP In 2008, 46 people were sent to the execution chamber in the United States. Related Stories * Oklahoma man pleads guilty to strangling 5, gets life sentence without parole * Execution of Oklahoma death row inmate Garry Allen postponed even though Supreme Court had not yet issued ruling in case * Oklahoma and New York battle over the life of killer * Boston mobster James (Whitey) Bulger lands in Oklahoma prison Powered by Inform Take our Poll Dead wrong Do you think that capital punishment should be outlawed? (*) Yes ( ) No ( ) I'm not sure vote I have studied the death penalty for more than half my lifetime. I have debated it hundreds of times. I have heard all the arguments, analyzed all the evidence I could find, measured public opinion when it was opposed to the practice, when it was indifferent, and when it was passionately in favor. Always I have concluded the death penalty is wrong because it lowers us all; it is a surrender to the worst that is in us; it uses a power - the official power to kill by execution - that has never elevated a society, never brought back a life, never inspired anything but hate. And it has killed many innocent people. This is a serious moral problem for every U.S. governor who presides over executions - whether in Georgia, Texas or even, theoretically, New York. All states should do as the bold few have done and officially outlaw this form of punishment. For 12 years as governor, I prevented the death penalty from becoming law in New York by my vetoes. But for all that time, there was a disconcertingly strong preference for the death penalty in the general public. New York returned to the death penalty shortly after I was defeated by a Republican candidate; the state's highest court has effectively prevented the law from being applied - but New York continues to have the law on its books with no signs of a movement to remove it. That law is a stain on our conscience. The 46 executions in the United States in 2008 were, I believe, an abomination. People have a right to demand a civilized level of law and peace. They have a right to expect it, and when at times it appears to them that a murder has been particularly egregious, it is not surprising that the public anger is great and demands some psychic satisfaction. I understand that. I have felt the anger myself, more than once. Like too many other citizens, I know what it is to be violated and even to have one's closest family violated through despicable criminal behavior. Even today, I tremble at the thought of how I might react to a killer who took the life of someone in my own family. I know that I might not be able to suppress my anger or put down a desire for revenge, but I also know this society should strive for something better than what it feels at its weakest moments. There is absolutely no good reason to believe that using death as a punishment today is any better an answer now than it was in the past - when New York State had it, used it, regretted it and discarded it. Experts throughout the nation have come out strongly against the death penalty after hundreds of years of lawyers' cumulative experiences and studies revealed that the death penalty is ineffective as a deterrent. Some of history's most notorious murders occurred in the face of existing death penalty statutes. Psychiatrists will tell you there is reason to believe that some madmen - for example, Ted Bundy - may even be tempted to murder because of a perverse desire to challenge the ultimate penalty. It is also unfairly applied. Notwithstanding the executions of mass killers like Timothy McVeigh, capital punishment appears to threaten white drug dealers, white rapists and white killers less frequently than those of other races. Of the last 18 people in New York State to be executed (ending in 1963), 13 were black and one was Hispanic. That racial makeup seems an extraordinary improbability for a system operating with any kind of objectivity and consistency. Because death penalty proponents have no other way to defend this policy, they cling unabashedly to the blunt simplicity of the ancient impulse that has always spurred the call for death: the desire for revenge. That was the bottom line of many debates on the floor of the state Senate and Assembly, to which I listened with great care during my tenure as governor. It came down to "an eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth." If we adopted this maxim, where would it end? "You kill my son; I kill yours." "You rape my daughter; I rape yours." "You mutilate my body; I mutilate yours." And we would pursue this course, despite the lack of any reason to believe it will protect us even if it is clear that occasionally the victim of our official barbarism will be innocent. It is believed that at least 23 people were wrongfully executed in the United States during the twentieth century. Twenty-three innocent people killed by the official workings of the state, but it is not called murder. According to the Innocence Project, 17 people have been proven innocent - exonerated by DNA testing - after serving time on Death Row. These people were convicted in 11 different states. They served a combined 209 years in prison. And government was prepared to end their lives. Tragically, New York holds the record for the greatest number of innocents put to death over the years. According to some, New York leads all states with at least six (perhaps more) wrongful executions since 1905. Yet proponents of the death penalty continue to assume that the criminal justice system will not make a mistake, or they simply don't care. As was shown by the recent Troy Davis execution in Georgia, where shaky witness testimony and a lack of physical evidence were considered insufficient to create "reasonable doubt," too many people seem unconcerned about the overly ambitious prosecutor, the sloppy detective, the incompetent defense counsel, the witness with an ax to grind, the judge who keeps courthouse conviction box scores. But these imperfections - as well as the horrible and irreversible injustice they can produce - are inevitable. In this country, a defendant is convicted on proof beyond a reasonable doubt - not proof that can be known with absolute certainty. There's no such thing as absolute certainty in our law. We need to continue to do the things that will control crime by making the apprehension and punishment of criminals more effective and more precise. We need adequate police and prisons and alternatives to incarceration. We should also have a tough, effective punishment for deliberate murder. There is a punishment that is much better than the death penalty: one that juries will not be reluctant to impose; one that is so menacing to a potential killer, that it could actually deter; one that does not require us to be infallible so as to avoid taking an innocent life; and one that does not require us to stoop to the level of the killers. There is a penalty that is - for those who insist on measuring this question in terms of financial cost - millions of dollars less expensive than the death penalty: true life imprisonment, with no possibility of parole under any circumstances. True life imprisonment is a more effective deterrent than capital punishment. To most inmates, the thought of living a whole lifetime behind bars only to die in a cell, is worse than the quick, final termination of the electric chair or lethal injection. I've heard this sentiment personally at least three times in my life. The second time it came from a man on the way to his execution in Oklahoma. He was serving a life sentence for murder in New York at the same time that Oklahoma was eager to take him from New York so they could execute him for a murder he had committed in Oklahoma. I refused to release him so that he could be executed in Oklahoma, but then the governor who replaced me in 1995 was able to get New York to adopt the death penalty - and to prove New York really approved of death as a punishment, he released the inmate from prison and sent him to Oklahoma, where he was promptly executed. On the night before he died, he left a note that was published in the New York Post that said, "Tell Governor Cuomo I would rather be executed than to serve life behind bars." Because the death penalty was so popular during the time I served as governor, I was often asked why I spoke out so forcefully against it although the voters very much favored it. I tried to explain that I pushed this issue into the center of public dialogue because I believed the stakes went far beyond the death penalty itself. Capital punishment raises important questions about how, as a society, we view human beings. I believed as governor, and I still believe, that the practice and support for capital punishment is corrosive; that it is bad for a democratic citizenry and that it had to be objected to and so I did then, and I do now and will continue to for as long as it and I exist, because I believe we should be better than what we are in our weakest moments. Cuomo was governor of New York. Post a Comment » Daily News Readers alert Going forward, the Daily News will require new users to register to the site using full names in order to comment on stories. If you have an existing Daily News account and you registered with only a screen name, that name will still be valid. If you are an existing user and you registered using both a screen name and your full name, your full name will appear on comments posted after October 21, 2013. We are always seeking new ways to improve your experience and we know this change will only make our Daily News community better. Comments See All Comments [Discussion Guidelines ] To post your comments, please, Sign in » . X Show more comments Ads by Yahoo! Most Popular * Most Read * Most Shared 1. 1 India, take a look in the mirror 2. 2 We will lead on climate change 3. 3 What killed the liberal radio star? 4. 4 ‘Yes, Virginia’: Read the iconic 1897 editorial 5. 5 Axis of insanity 6. 6 ‘Twas the night before Christmas’: Read the poem 7. 7 In debt to a giant 8. 8 REFLECTION: Those lost in 2013 will be missed 9. 9 Dec. 26: Christmas, Christmas and more Christmas 10. 10 The Obamacare fraud 1. 1 India, take a look in the mirror 2. 2 Dec. 26: Justice for Pvt. Danny Chen and interviewing for a job 3. 3 Gingrich gets grilled 4. 4 Cuomo must hack it 5. 5 Chris-mas present 6. 6 Putting the squeeze on Syria 7. 7 Editorial: A premium on openness 8. 8 Nazaryan: Brooklyn Nets desperately need a new name 9. 9 A test saved my schooling 10. 10 Editorial: Mapmaking for dummies Editor's Picks A pox on both our houses A sorry pair. In 2013, the political powers in Washington put on pathetic displays. In the coming days, we’ll address President Obama’s many costly failures. Today, the subject is Congress — which, consumed by partisan paralysis, did far more harm than good to the nation. Dec. 27: Package delivery, mercury and Eli Manning Neither snow, nor rain, nor heat, nor gloom of night . . . Oakland Gardens: ’Twas the day of Xmas, and all on the news, the anchors were crying and singing the blues Derail this deal The Long Island Rail Road can’t afford the raises that the unions want. A federal panel is trying to stick New Yorkers with an unaffordable bill for higher Long Island Rail Road salaries — which would then drive up costs, and fares, across the system. Man shot dead in Coney Island housing project The man was found sprawled on the fourth-floor staircase and was declared dead by emergency workers who rushed to the scene, according to police. A motive for the killing has not been determined, and no arrests have been made as cops continue their investigation, officials said. Turkish PM: They’re all out to get me TOPSHOTS Turkey’s prime minister says he believes he is the ultimate target of a corruption and bribery probe of his allies that has shaken the government. Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said anyone attempting to draw him into the scandal would be “left empty-handed.” Homeless man runs on to Phoenix airport taxiway BEST QUALITY AVAILABLE. AP PROVIDES ACCESS TO THIS PUBLICLY DISTRIBUTED HANDOUT PHOTO PROVIDED BY THE MARICOPA COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE The seemingly drunk and high Bump was spotted by workers in the airport’s tower about 5:30 p.m. climbing the fence and pounding on the engine of a Southwest Airlines plane, Phoenix police spokesman Office James Holmes said. Bump, 49, was booked on a misdemeanor charge of entering a restricted area, Holmes said. No injuries were reported, and Holmes said passengers were never in danger. American held hostage by Al Qaeda begs U.S. for help Warren Weinstein, who has been held hostage by Al Qaeda for two years, urges President Obama to negotiate his release in a new video. Warren Weinstein, of Rockville, Md., looks pale and lethargic in the video — the first proof of life in his disappearance since a pair of similar videos were released in September 2012. He says he has a heart condition and acute asthma — and needs his government to secure his release. Supersmart cruiser could be future of NYPD NYC PAPERS OUT. Social media use restricted to low res file max 184 x 128 pixels and 72 dpi The police cruiser of the future is here — and it’s being driven in Brooklyn. An NYPD “supersmart car” prototype — that could leave KITT, the chatty Trans-Am from 'Knight Rider,' tongue-tied — is being tested on the streets of Brooklyn Heights and DUMBO, officials said Thursday. Talbot eyes third straight start as Rangers visit Caps NYC PAPERS OUT. Social media use restricted to low res file max 184 x 128 pixels and 72 dpi Rangers backup goalie Cam Talbot could go from the Christmas tree to the Christmas three on Friday night - as in a third consecutive start ahead of a healthy Henrik Lundqvist, as the Rangers emerge from the NHL's three-day holiday break. In the Now: New York City events for Friday, Dec. 27 Teddy Bear Tea Party at the Mount Vernon Hotel Museum and Garden. Kids get a tour from an actress who plays the proprietor’s wife. The Mount Vernon Hotel Museum and Garden on the Upper East Side hosts a honey of a brunch on Sunday to cure kids’ post-holiday blahs. Valerie June's Americana at the Highline Ballroom Valerie June brings her unique take on roots music to the Highline Ballroom. Valerie June sings in a voice full of hard angles and rough surfaces. There’s a clanging quality to her tone, and a tinniness in her timbre, that speaks of the most unfiltered part of the American South. “By no measure is my voice for everybody,” June admits. “Most of the world loves smooth, autotuned voices or beautiful ones, like Sam Cooke. But this is something different.” WOR's new morning man will be on a tightrope Elliot Segal would be happy never to hear the phrase “shock jock” again. Charities get some fine Tayloring . EXCLUSIVE COVERAGE Taylor Swift leads the pack when it comes to the most charitable celebs around. Not only did the “Trouble” singer personally phone a cancer-stricken 8-year-old girl on Christmas, she also celebrated her recent 24th birthday by writing a $100,000 check to the Nashville Symphony, which hit money troubles this year. TV's most pirated show: 'Game of Thrones' GAME OF THRONES episode 24 (season 3, episode 4): Emilia Clarke HBO’s “Game of Thrones” has taken the crown for the most illegally downloaded show of 2013, according to the piracy news site TorrentFreak. An innovation to keep love matches from fizzling NYC PAPERS OUT. Social media use restricted to low res file max 184 x 128 pixels and 72 dpi Experts would tell you that it’s not good to brag about personal failings on a first date. But Rahul Saggar is no expert. His strategy involves boasting to prospective lovers about coming up with wacky inventions — yet selling none of them. 'American Masters' profiles Marvin Hamlisch Rentals grant one-time, EDITORIAL use only, unless otherwise negotiated. Please inform us about usage or non-usage as soon as possible. Research fees may apply if no images are used. Marvin Hamlisch, who changed Broadway and won a Tony and a Pulitzer for “A Chorus Line,” is the subject of the “American Masters” bio “What He Did For Love.” * Media Kit * Autos * Home Delivery * Newsletters * Businesses * Place an Ad * About our Ads * Contact Us * Careers * FAQ's * Feeds * Site Map Use of this website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. © Copyright 2013 NYDailyNews.com. All rights reserved. Quantcast