#RSS 2.0 RSS .92 Marilyn Stowe Blog » Gay marriage push in Northern Ireland Comments Feed Rich people more likely to marry What family lawyers were talking about this week… by John Bolch Marilyn Stowe MENU * Categories + Arbitration + children and divorce + Cohabiting Couples + CSA + divorce + Divorce & Splitting Up Book + Family Law + Family Life + Finances and Divorce + Fostering & Adoption + Gay Marriage + international divorce + News + Powers of Attorney & Court of Protection + Prenuptial Agreements + Relationships + Stowe Family Law + Surrogacy + Wills & Probate * Newswire * About * Video * Book * Downloads * Contact * * * * * Home 2014 November 14 Gay marriage push in Northern Ireland ____________________ Search Gay marriage push in Northern Ireland November 14, 2014 5 comments Belfast City Hall Gay rights campaigners are trying a new legal strategy to have same-sex marriage recognised in Northern Ireland. A legal challenge to the current ban is being prepared by LGBT campaign group the Rainbow Project. They claim that the law is discriminatory and breaches the human rights of same-sex couples. The focus of the challenge will be on the plight of a gay couple who got legally married in England before returning to Northern Ireland. As things stand, same-sex couples who lawfully marry elsewhere in the UK, or anywhere else where it is legal, are not legally recognised as married upon their return home. Gavin Boyd, Policy and Advocacy Manager of the Rainbow Project, said that this was an “unlawful, unjust, and unjustifiable” state of affairs. The new legal challenge may prove to be a popular move. A recent poll suggested that the legalisation of gay marriage would be supported by a majority of people. Despite its apparent popularity, Northern Ireland is currently the only part of the UK which does not have marriage equality. In May, its MPs voted against legalising gay marriage for the third time. Same-sex marriage has been legal in Scotland since February, when its parliament voted in favour of legalisation. Not long afterwards, England and Wales followed suit with the passage of the Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act. Photo of Belfast City Hall by Macnolete via Wikipedia Stowe Family Law Web Team View more from this author Was This Post Valuable? Share This Post Get Free Family Law Updates ____________________ November 14, 2014 Categories: Gay Marriage Tags: England, England and Wales, gay marriage, gay rights, human rights, LGBT, Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act, Northern Ireland, Rainbow Project, same sex couples, Scotland, UK 5 comments Andrew - November 14, 2014 at 5:38pm Report/Reply Under the Civil Partnerships Act a same-sex marriage in another country was treated as a civil partnership throughout the UK. That of course has now changed in GB where both jurisdictions recognise same-sex marriage; but not in NI, at least not yet. In Wilkinson -v- Kitzinger and the A-G two ladies who had married in Canada claimed that their marriage should be recognised in England as a marriage, not just as a c.p. – and lost. It seems to me that unless the NI court is persuaded not to follow the judgment of the President in that case this challenge must fail. George - November 27, 2014 at 11:49pm Report/Reply What you are talking about is a completely different situation. That couple went to a country far away almost a decade ago and came back asking for the same laws to be implemented in England which was at a different stage in its developement to Canada. It was bound to fail. This case involves the last remaining country in the UK to have the same rights as all other parts of the UK. I think this case is much more likely to succeed than the case you are citing. As well as that, a recent poll in Northern Ireland showed that there was a majority, albeit a narrow one, of people that would support the implementation of gay marriage in the country. This indicates that NI is ready, or almost ready, for this potential change and this may positively influence the judges decision on the matter. Andrew - November 28, 2014 at 12:34pm Report/Reply George: Distance is irrelevant. So is membership of the UK. NI and England are separate jurisdictions for the purposes of private law. NI is now where England was then; it allows c.p. but not s.s.m. and recognises foreign s.s.m., legal where the ceremony was, but only as a c.p. So not a “completely different situation”; in domestic terms, an identical situation, If the plaintiffs, as they still call them in NI (good for NI) take a Convention point the court might see a change there: at least one more country (France) permits s.s.m. now which did not then. I doubt if the opinion poll is admissible even in submissions, let alone in evidence; it should not be and would not be here. Following Pepper -v- Hart the vote against might be. A bit of backstory here. When homosexual acts were decriminalised in NI, c. 1981, all the parties opposed it. That includes the SDLP in the House and Sinn Fein from outside; they both prefer to forget about that now. Paisley had a real go at the majority in the House, as only he could. He said that the English laughed at the NI people for arguing about things which they, the English, no longer thought important. And then, when for once the NI people agreed about something what happened? The English ignored and outvoted them! George - November 30, 2014 at 2:44am Report/Reply Andrew: All of Britian has same sex marriage. The Republic of Ireland will have Same sex marriage within six months time if the strong support shown in all opinion polls holds up for the referendum, and I believe it will. That leaves this tiny piece of land that I live in, which doesn’t have it. Finland, Denmark, Iceland, Norway and Sweden (to name a few as well as France) within europe also have same sex marriage now but did not then. Why are you talking about things that happened 35 years ago. Things have changed. People have moved on. Many parties support it now including: Sinn Fein, SDLP, Alliance and Green party. Only unionist parties are against it, specifically the DUP. In fact 4 people in the UUP voted yes the last time the bill was proposed. My point is there is a lot of political support for equality at present. There is pressure from Britian and the south to implement it. The public is in favour of it: and this support is growing. Other countries within the European union, of which the UK is a part of, are implementing it. I’m not sure you know what you are talking about. The English did not “outvote” NI people to decriminalise homosexuality. It was decriminalised because of a case, Dudgeon v. United Kingdom in which the European court of Human Rights ruled it violated the European Convention on Human Rights. This led to its decriminalisation, not the English. It seems to me that you are against gay marriage and I respect your opinion on that. However I am in full support of it and I personally hope this case will succeed. I honestly think it has a good chance of it too. Andrew - December 1, 2014 at 12:27am Report/Reply If by “Britain” you mean Great Britain, England and Wales and Scotland, then indeed they all have s.s.m. You are right also in saying that the countries you name have it which did not at the time of Wilkinson. That is the best chance for the plaintiffs in this proposed claim in that part of the the UK which does not have it. However, in a jurisdiction with an elected legislature the best measure of public opinion is the vote of the legislature or, where the constitution so requires or permits as in the RoI a referendum – buy not an opinion poll. Now as to Dudgeon: of course I am aware of it! My tale from 1981 was a bit of anecdotage, no more and no less. The fact remains that had there been an elected legislature in Northern Ireland at the time the idea of decriminalising homosexual acts would have been voted down, and that all the MPs from NI voted against it Westminster – so yes, it was forced through by votes from GB, mainly of course from England. That is fact, however uncomfortable it may be for the parties from NI of today. If the old Parliament of NI had still been functioning at the time Parliament at Westminster would have had to overrule its wishes in the exercise of its ultimate sovereignty and I can well imagine – and so can you – how the parties in NI would have reacted, especially the nationalist/Republican parties. The Conservatives in GB have admitted that they were wrong over Section 28 and similar humility from the parties in NI would not come amiss. (I cannot resist the further story that when the law was changed in England and Wales (but not Scotland, let alone NI) in 1967 the RC Archbishop of Armagh remarked that such a law in NI would not only be wrong, it would be pointless, because “such things did not happen anywhere in Ireland”!) My view on s.s.m? Up to the people acting through the political process in each jurisdiction. It should not be forced upon them by supra-national institutions, This is a matter where the law of each jurisdiction should be sensitive to the culture of that jurisdiction, just like the existence of divorce or the grounds for it, or the very different laws of testate and intestate succession in different countries within the Council of Europe, and indeed within the UK. If you are right about opinion in NI it will sooner or alter be reflected in the law. Leave a comment Name: ______________________________ Email: ______________________________ Website: ______________________________ Your comment: ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ Submit comment By leaving a comment you confirm you have read and agreed to our Terms of Use. Please note that due to the volume of questions now received by this blog, we regret that we cannot guarantee a reply to every one. [ ] Notify me of follow-up comments by email. [ ] Notify me of new posts by email. Divorce & Splitting Up Book New Edition for 2015 Marilyn Stowe’s bestselling book: expert advice on all aspects of divorce, just 99p Digital Copy - 99p Subscribe & Follow All the latest news straight to your inbox. Sign up for instant access today. ____________________ Contact by E-mail / Tel / Fax * * * * * Categories * Adoption and Children Act 2002 * Arbitration * children and divorce * Cohabiting Couples * CSA * divorce * Divorce & Splitting Up Book * Family Law * Family Life * Finances and Divorce * Fostering & Adoption * Gay Marriage * international divorce * Mediation * News * Powers of Attorney & Court of Protection * Prenuptial Agreements * Relationships * Stowe Family Law * Surrogacy * Wills & Probate Recent Comments * Cameron Paterson on 75 per cent of LAs not good enough says Ofsted * Andrew on Enforcing contact orders by John Bolch * Paul Apreda on 75 per cent of LAs not good enough says Ofsted * Nordic on Enforcing contact orders by John Bolch * Randox Drug & Alcohol Testing Services | Enforcing a contact order on Enforcing contact orders by John Bolch Related Posts gay marriage US Supreme Court to review gay marriage gay marriage Couple to challenge ban on same sex marriage in NI gay marriage Gay divorce granted in Kentucky gay marriage US Supreme Court reopens discussions on gay marriage Dominican Republic, gay marriage Dominican Republic won’t recognise UK Embassy gay marriage Tags Cafcass care child abduction child maintenance children Children Act 1989 children and divorce children in care child support Cohabitation contact arrangements Court of Appeal Court of Protection divorce domestic violence England family courts Family Law family life finances and divorce financial settlement foster care fostering and adoption gay marriage Government High Court international divorce legal aid litigants in person local authority London Marilyn Stowe marriage mediation Ministry of Justice news parents President of the Family Division Relationships separation Sir James Munby Stowe Family Law Supreme Court UK United States Recent Posts children and divorce Support group for Canadian children of divorce family life Family life: Americans hiding money issues from partners family life 75 per cent of LAs not good enough says Ofsted family law A week in family law: court fees, contact centres and more by John Bolch children and divorce Mother allowed to move to Russia under the Hague Convention 1996 Stowe Family Law Founded by Marilyn Stowe in 1982, Stowe Family Law has grown to become the UK’s largest standalone family law firm with offices in Central London, North Yorkshire, West Yorkshire, Greater Manchester & Hertfordshire. www.stowefamilylaw.co.uk ____________________ Search Report this comment * Name:* ____________________ * Email:* ____________________ * Why would you like to report this post? Please help us by adding your comment below. * __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ * Thank you. * * * Phone ____________________ This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. Report this comment IFRAME: gform_ajax_frame_1 Digital Copy - £0.99 Marilyn Stowe’s bestselling book: expert advice on all aspects of divorce, just 99p! Divorce & Splitting Up by Marilyn Stowe is the essential how-to book for anyone who is getting divorced or splitting up from a partner. Read more >> "A must buy that really opens your eyes to what is involved if you are considering or going through a divorce." Amanda Brown "This will answer your questions in a way that non-lawyers can understand." Miss P "Don't get divorced without it. I read this book despite being divorced for more than 10 years. I wish I'd had this book to hand at the time. Great examples, simple to read and understand." Jamie "This really has helped me to see that there is light at the end of the tunnel and I will come out of it a stronger person."J Marilyn Stowe Marilyn Stowe One of the UK’s best-known family lawyers, Marilyn Stowe has helped more than 12,000 clients. She is the founder of Stowe Family Law, the UK’s largest standalone family law firm. Explore * About * Downloads * Book * Video * Newswire * Contact * * * * * © 2007-2014 Marilyn Stowe. All Rights Reserved. Complaints Policy Terms of Use Cookie Policy Pin It on Pinterest Share This Post If you found this article interesting, please share it with others on social media: * Facebook * Twitter * Google+ * LinkedIn * Tumblr * Pinterest