IFRAME: //www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-5QL237 * Jobs * Cars * Real Estate * Classifieds * E-Edition * Subscriber Services * Account * Register * Login * () * Subscribe * About * Access E-Edition * Reader Rewards * Manage Subscription * Customer Service * Live chat * Favorites & Comments * Newsletters * Manage Account * Log Out Columbus, Ohio • Jan 25, 2015 • 34° Overcast [header-image.jpg?cmpid=tplnnv] The Columbus Dispatch * News RSS Feeds Podcasts _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ News Topics + Business + Crime & Safety + Education + Environment + Government & Politics + Legal Notices + Local + Lottery + Medicine & Health + Obituaries + Offbeat + Religion + Science + Special Reports + US & World + Weather + Corrections News Blogs [-Browse by Topic-______] + News Blog Directory Commentary + Dispatch Editor Benjamin Marrison + John Switzer * Sports RSS Feeds Podcasts _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ College Sports + Ohio State Sports at BuckeyeXtra.com + Other Colleges High School + High School Sports Other Sports + Outdoors Pro Sports + NHL: Blue Jackets at BlueJacketsXtra.com + MLS: Crew + MiLB: Clippers + MLB: Reds & Indians + NBA: Cavaliers + NFL: Bengals & Browns + Golf + Auto Racing Sports Blogs [-Browse by Sport-_________] + Sports Blog Directory Commentary + Michael Arace + Bob Hunter + Rob Oller * Opinion RSS Feeds Podcasts _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Editorials + Today's staff editorials + 7-day archive Editorial Cartoons + Recent Nate Beeler Cartoons + Searchable Archive Letters to the Editor + Today's letters and web-only letters + 30-day archive + Submit your letter Op-Ed Columns + Today's columns + 30-day archive * Life & Entertainment RSS Feeds Podcasts _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Life Topics + Contests + Fashion & Style + Food + Home & Garden + Horoscopes + Pets DispatchClassifieds.com + Puzzles + Travel + Weekly Ads Entertainment + Books + Celebrities + Dining + Events + Movies + Music + Television + Theater + Video Games Life Blogs [-Browse by Topic-] + Life & Entertainment Blog Directory Commentary + Joe Blundo + Advice Columns + Reader Columns * Services Customer Service + Manage Subscription + Live chat + Call Service: 1-877-734-7728 + Call Billing: 1-866-790-7748 Subscription + Home delivery + E-Edition Submissions + Obituaries + In Memoriams + Celebration Announcements (ceremonies, engagements, etc.) + Letters to the Editor + Entertainment Events at ColumbusAlive.com Reader Rewards [dd-reader-rewards-logo.jpg] Current Rewards [-Select An Option-] Advertising + Place an Ad + Media Kit Other Services + Weekly Ads + Coupons + Columbus Savvy Shopper + Dispatch Events + Newspapers in Education * Contact Need help? Visit our FAQ page or use our Contact Form. _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Customer Service + Need help? Try our live chat or online customer service. + For service, call 1-877-734-7728. + For billing, call 1-866-790-7748. + For other inquiries, use our Contact Form or Staff Directory. Subscriptions + Subscribe to The Dispatch online or call 1-877-734-7728. Advertising + To place help wanted ads, call 614-888-8888 or visit ColumbusJobs.com + For private seller and classified advertising, call 614-888-8888 or visit DispatchClassifieds.com. + For retail advertising, call 614-461-5500 or email us. + For national advertising, call 614-461-5199. + For online advertising, call 614-461-5143 or email us. Newsroom + To send news tips, use our News Tip Form or call 614-461-5200. + Visit our Staff Directory. + Use our Contact Form, or call 614-461-5200. Dispatch Careers + Visit dispatch.com/careers or call 614-461-5033. + Fax 614-461-5565. + Interested in delivering The Dispatch? Check out dispatch.com/delivery for independent contractor info. * Subscribe Total Access Combo Package Enjoy the convenience of home delivery plus Digital D. Sign up for our BEST VALUE today! Select E-Edition Digital D Online? On the go? Enjoy unlimited premium dispatch.com content plus the E-Edition for computer and iPad. Select _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Home Delivery Award-winning journalism conveniently delivered to your home. Choose the custom package best suited for you! Select Home Delivery * Today's Paper * Weekly Ads * Video * Photos * Data * Obituaries Hot Links: no title * NHL All-Star Weekend * Kroger liquor petition case * Dublin coyotes * High St. Donatos * Commemorative papers, posters * Obamacare tax * Home * News Gay-marriage issue: How will it play for Republicans in 2016? [marriage12-art0-gvsukc72-11012gfx-marriage12-eps.jpg?__scale=w:300,h:430] View Larger The Daily Briefing * Reps talk to protect Ohio's military installations * Stivers reintroduces bill aimed at helping newborns born addicted * Senate committees named * Sen. Chris Widener re-elected head of Capitol Square Board Buckeye Forum Podcast [dmt-news-podcast.gif] The Dispatch public affairs team talks politics and tackles state and federal government issues in the Buckeye Forum podcast. Your Right to Know * Justices can restore sanity by clarifying 'overly broad' By Jack Torry The Columbus Dispatch • Sunday October 12, 2014 10:11 AM * Comments: 17 * * * [marriage12-art0-gvsukc72-1fiscal-summit-jpeg-08a75.jpg?__scale=w:660,h:440,t:1,c:ffffff,q:80,r:1] View Slideshow Request to buy this photoAP file photo Sen. Rob Portman, R-Ohio, favors gay marriage, but that position could hurt him in the early primaries if he runs for president in 2016. WASHINGTON — The reaction would have been very different 10 years ago: Had the U.S. Supreme Court struck down bans on same-sex marriage in any state in 2004, conservative Republicans would have howled in protest. But this week, when the justices upheld lower-court rulings that essentially legalized same-sex marriage in five states, a sizable number of Republicans seemed to shrug off the news as no big deal. The relatively quiet GOP response — House Speaker John Boehner of West Chester never even commented on it — is a sign that a divisive issue across the country a decade ago has become acceptable to many Americans. A Pew Research Center survey last month showed that 49 percent of Americans favor same-sex marriage, while 41 percent oppose it. A Pew poll from 2004 showed that, at the time, 60 percent of Americans opposed gay marriage, while 31 percent supported it. Ten years after voters in Ohio approved a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage, 62 percent to 38 percent, half of the states and the District of Columbia permit same-sex marriage. A Washington Post poll last year showed that 81 percent of people younger than 30 support same-sex marriage. “Nothing has changed quicker in the political environment than the politics surrounding gay marriage,” said David Leland, former chairman of the Ohio Democratic Party and a candidate this year for the Ohio House. “There has been a sea change of enormous proportions in the past 10 years. I think the silence from the Republicans is reflective of that.” Analysts say that as the issue fades, it will be less of an obstacle for potential Republican presidential candidates such as Sen. Rob Portman of Ohio who favor same-sex marriage. Portman announced last year that his son Will is gay and reversed his longtime opposition to same-sex marriage. Portman was the first sitting GOP senator to publicly support gay marriage. Barry Bennett, a Republican consultant in Washington and a Portman adviser, said Portman’s position would “ absolutely” help him if he could win the GOP nomination. “Our problems in the general are primarily driven by voters seeing us as not caring and not compassionate,” Bennett said. “They won’t see Rob that way.” Yet Portman’s stance is fraught with political danger. Politico.com reported this week that only four House Republicans and four Senate Republicans support same-sex marriage. Republicans might not want to talk about same-sex marriage, but they are not embracing it, either. The Pew poll shows that only 34 percent of Republicans back same-sex marriage and that 75 percent of white evangelicals — who make up a strong segment of GOP voters in the early presidential contests of Iowa and South Carolina — oppose gay marriage. “He’ll never get through the primary,” Mary Anne Marsh, a Democratic consultant in Boston, said of Portman. “While Portman, on paper, could be a good general-election candidate , the people who dominate the Republican primary process oppose gay marriage. Period.” Phil Burress, president of Citizens for Community Values in Ohio, said, “There’s no way that it has helped him, and it continues to hurt him. He’s damaged goods.” He predicted that Portman is “ not even going to keep his seat in 2016.” In a statement, Portman said he backs “same-sex marriage and the Supreme Court’s ruling opens up the possibility of marriage to more Americans.” But Portman said that “the best way to achieve enduring change is at the kitchen table, not in the courtroom. It is citizens persuading their fellow citizens, and it is happening all across the country.” While Portman was one of the few Republicans to praise the court’s ruling, most GOP officials said nothing, suggesting they hoped to avoid a blistering controversy before the November congressional elections. But some were not so reticent. Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, assailed the court’s decisions as “both tragic and indefensible,” and he vowed to introduce a constitutional amendment “to prevent the federal government or the courts from attacking or striking down state marriage laws.” Cruz is likely to run for president, and his opposition to same-sex marriage would resonate with social conservatives who make up a large percentage of Republicans voting in the 2016 Iowa caucuses. In 2012, former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum, an ardent opponent of abortion rights and same-sex marriage, won Iowa with 25 percent of the vote, while in 2008, former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee — another social conservative — won with 34 percent. But those close to Portman point out that neither Santorum nor Huckabee were able to win the nomination. They suggest that a number of GOP voters in Iowa might overlook a candidate’s position on same-sex marriage. “There are still a huge chunk of people who are caucus voters who will agree with Portman on this,” said one Republican who spoke on condition of anonymity. “I don’t think the gay marriage thing was a deal-breaker anyway. With the passing of time, it’s becoming less and less of an issue." As recently as 2004, opposition to same-sex marriage might have helped President George W. Bush win Ohio, whose electoral votes gave him a second term. Bush carried the state on the same day that voters approved an amendment to the Ohio constitution banning same-sex marriage. “It was the factor,” Burress said in explaining why Bush won. Others, however, are not as certain. Post-election analysis showed that in the Ohio precincts where Bush performed the strongest, he won more votes than the gay-marriage ballot issue. “Statistically, there is no evidence that the gay-marriage amendment in 2004 influenced the outcome of the Ohio presidential election,” said Mike Dawson, author of OhioElectionResults.com. * Favorite * Print Story * Comments * Advertisement * • * Place an ad [DigitalD12Weeks_300x75.JPG?__scale=w:300,h:75,t:2,p:6,q:80,r:1] News Video More Videos Most Popular 1. Buckeyes’ Miller still has an exit route Most Shared * Latest Headlines * Today's Paper * Top Story Feed * Advertisement * • * Place an ad News Blogs [icon-blog-politics.jpg] The Daily Briefing Reps talk to protect Ohio's military installations “Today is the start of a conversation to make sure we are all on the same... [icon-blog-politics.jpg] The Daily Briefing Stivers reintroduces bill aimed at helping newborns born addicted Rep. Steve Stivers last week paired up with another lawmaker to reintroduce a... [icon-blog-politics.jpg] The Daily Briefing Senate committees named Franklin County Sens. Kevin Bacon and Jim Hughes will chair new committees in... [icon-blog-politics.jpg] The Daily Briefing Sen. Chris Widener re-elected head of Capitol Square Board Running the Statehouse. More News Blogs * Advertisement * • * Place an ad * Advertisement * • * Place an ad [dispatch-nameplate-footer.gif] * Site Map * * About the Dispatch * * About Our Ads * * Privacy Policy * * Ad Choices * * Contacts * * Store * * Work with Us News Business Crime & Safety Education Environment Government & Politics Local Medicine & Health Obituaries Religion Science US & World Weather Sports Ohio State Sports at BuckeyeXtra.com Other Colleges NHL: Blue Jackets at BlueJacketsXtra.com MLS: Crew MiLB: Clippers MLB: Reds & Indians NBA: Cavaliers NFL: Bengals & Browns Golf Sports Commentary High School Sports Opinion Editorials Letters to the Editor Nate Beeler Cartoons Op-Ed Columnists Life Topics Contests Fashion & Style Food Home & Garden Travel Advice Columns Joe Blundo Columns Entertainment Topics Books Dining Events Movies Music Theater Classifieds Columbus Jobs Columbus Real Estate Columbus Cars Dispatch Classifieds Services Customer Service Reader Rewards Place an Ad Submissions Reader Options Home Delivery Archive Mobile E-Edition Newsletters RSS Feeds Podcasts Dispatch Media Group Dispatch Media Group Browse Affiliate Sites * Advertisement * • * Place an ad * Advertisement * • * Place an ad © 2015 The Dispatch Printing Company, reproduction prohibited. All Rights Reserved.