#publisher The Atlantic Best of The Atlantic TheAtlantic.com Continue () Advertisement The Atlantic Subscribe Now * Your AccountSign Out * Sign InSign Up ____________________ (Submit) Get The Atlantic on Facebook * Politics + Top Stories + Run, Warren, Run + Chris Christie's 'Renewal' + Kamala Harris and the New Democratic Hope + Mitt's Multiple Personalities + The Wrongly Accused Frat at UVA Is Owed a Few Apologies + The Democrats Call Dibs on the Middle Class + * Business + Top Stories + When Priorities Clash, Time Seems Shorter + Not Everyone's Internal Clock Is Set for the 9-to-5 + Who Owns Yoga? + What to Do With a Dying Neighborhood + Baby-Faced Celebrities Are More Popular When the Economy's Strong + The Slow Strategy That Might Rebuild Middle-Class Wealth + * Tech + Top Stories + Promoting the Dead on Facebook + The Myth of Neutral Technology + Curiosity Journalism Is Popular Journalism + Facebook Doesn't Know You're Faking It + The Dark Psychology of the Sexist Internet Commenter + 'V' Is for Very + * Entertainment + Top Stories + Boyhood Won the Globes Battle, but Selma Could Still Win the Oscar War + The Oregon Ducks Capture the Best and Worst of College Football + Frank Lampard's Tale of Two Cities + The Taken Series Is Every Father's Fear—And Fantasy + Amazon Makes a Risky Bet on Woody Allen's Tarnished Prestige + Making Peace With Music That Everyone Loves But You + * Health + Top Stories + Living Longer, Dying Differently + BDSM Versus the DSM + Fitness Trackers Only Help Rich People Get Thinner + Facebook Doesn't Know You're Faking It + 'Play Freely at Your Own Risk' + Not Everyone's Internal Clock Is Set for the 9-to-5 + * Education + Top Stories + Same Performance, Better Grades + Where Obama's Community-College Plan Falls Short + The Genius of Obama's Two-Year College Proposal + When Being a Valedictorian Isn’t Enough + Are Today's Law Students Tough Enough? + A School for Children—and Their Parents + Special Report: Left-Brain America + * Sexes + Top Stories + 'Manslamming': A Verb, a Gerund + The Profound Lack of Empathy in My Husband's Not Gay + The Case for the Cosby Joke + The Dark Psychology of the Sexist Internet Commenter + 'Play Freely at Your Own Risk' + Strong Female Lead: A Feminist Golden Globes Show * National + Top Stories + Hotter Than Lava + Chokeholds and 'Broken Rules' Policing + After the Spill: Life in West Virginia's Coal Country + The Faces of #BlackLivesMatter + Sex, Drugs, and Pluralistic Ignorance: Why Smart Groups Do Dumb Things + Desegregated, yet Unequal + * Global + Top Stories + Fake News From the Holy Land + David Cameron: Empower U.K. Spies to Read All Communications + France's First Free-Speech Challenge After Charlie Hebdo + The 'Worst' German Word of the Year + Who Were the Paris Attackers Working For? + The Hacking of Central Command * Video + Top Stories + The Faces of #BlackLivesMatter + Around the World in Four Minutes + Desegregated, Yet Unequal + Ruth Bader Ginsburg's Life Lessons + Social Media: The Video Game + A Warning From 1941: Don't Wash Laundry With Gasoline * Magazine + In This Month's Issue + The Tragedy of the American Military + Is the Most Powerful Conservative in America Losing His Edge? + 5,200 Days in Space + [medium.png?ngoyt7] o Subscribe o Renew o Give a Gift o Digital Editions * Subscribe * Events * Newsletters * Books * Apps * Features * Photo * Just In Facebook Doesn't Know You're Faking It * [skybox-thumb.jpg?ni4cvl] Promoting the Dead on Facebook By Shirley Li * [skybox-thumb.jpg?ni4cvl] BDSM Versus the DSM By Merissa Nathan Gerson * [skybox-thumb.jpg?ni4cvq] The Myth of Neutral Technology By Melissa Gregg and Jason Wilson * [skybox-thumb.jpg?ni4cvv] The Perpetually Sleepy Worker By Ilana E. Strauss Bill Maher's Dangerous Critique of Islam There's a constructive way for liberals to oppose illiberalism, and then there's the approach the comedian took. Peter Beinart Oct 9 2014, 7:00 AM ET * * Share on Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * InstaPaper * Pocket * Pinterest * Tumblr * Email * Print * Comments [lead.png?nd6fkb] Bill Maher and Sam Harris describe Islam as "the mother lode of bad ideas." (YouTube) Bill Maher, meet Arthur Schlesinger Jr. Last Friday, the cranky comedian, aided by atheist author Sam Harris, enraged actor Ben Affleck by calling Islam, in Harris’s words, “the mother lode of bad ideas.” Then on Monday, Maher condemned liberals for being so afraid of being called Islamophobes that they won’t denounce brutality committed in Islam’s name. “We’re liberals!” Maher declared about himself and Harris. “We’re liberals … we’re trying to stand up for the principles of liberalism! And so, y’know, I think we’re just saying we need to identify illiberalism wherever we find it in the world, and not forgive it because it comes from [a group that] people perceive as a minority.” Schlesinger would have been able to relate. In his 1949 manifesto, The Vital Center, the Harvard historian and future Kennedy administration aide attacked what he called “doughface” liberals. Borrowing a term for pre-Civil War northerners who had refused to denounce slavery, Schlesinger deployed it against liberals who refused to denounce Soviet communism. “The infiltration of contemporary progressivism by Communism,” he wrote, “has led to the same self-flagellation [that prevented doughfaces from denouncing slavery], the same refusal to take precautions against tyranny.” _________________________________________________________________ Related Story Arthur Schlesinger Jr., "On the Writing of Contemporary History" _________________________________________________________________ Schlesinger’s point then, and Maher’s now, is that the enemies of liberals do not reside only on the right. In the 1930s and 1940s, some liberals grew so focused on the struggles against fascism and racism—struggles in which communists proved staunch allies—that they refused to acknowledge Joseph Stalin’s crimes. Today, some liberals are so focused on the struggle against American militarism and Islamophobia that they can’t muster much outrage against ISIS. According to Schlesinger, occupying the Vital Center means opposing totalitarianism wherever you find it, regardless of whether it claims the mantle of progressivism, as the Soviet Union did during his time, or anti-imperialism, as jihadists do now. So far, so good. Where Maher goes wrong is in forgetting two other lessons of the liberal anti-totalitarian tradition. The first is to be precise about what you’re opposing. The second, to not get so carried away with your own virtue that you end up justifying terrible crimes. Let’s start with the point about precision. At their best, the liberals of the early Cold War trained their fire on Stalin, a particular ruler in a particular country at a particular moment in time. When they began making sweeping generalizations about communism per se—forgetting that communist regimes and movements varied depending on their time and place—they got in trouble. In the 1940s and 1950s, the myth of a monolithic communist movement blinded some liberals to the fact that European socialists and communists—many of whom had their own national loyalties—could prove effective allies against Soviet power. “A recalcitrant Communist Yugoslavia,” in George Kennan’s words, “proved more resistant to Soviet Communist pressures than any non-Communist regime would have been likely to do.” Even more tragically, in the 1960s, some Cold War liberals could not distinguish between the communism of Joseph Stalin and the communism of Ho Chi Minh. By seeing Ho only as a communist, they overlooked the fact that many Vietnamese saw him primarily as an anti-colonialist. And by pretending that the ideological distinctions between North and South Vietnam resembled the ideological distinctions between East and West Germany, pro-war liberals ignored the reality that in Indochina, America’s allies were no more democratic than its communist foes. “The tragedy of Vietnam,” wrote Schlesinger in 1967, “is the tragedy of the catastrophic overextension and misapplication of valid principles.” And the engine of that overextension and misapplication was ignorance. Most pro-war liberals simply didn’t know enough about Vietnam to realize that their anti-communism was leading them astray. As Graham Greene wrote of Alden Pyle, the idealistic CIA agent in his novel, The Quiet American, “He was impregnably armoured by his good intentions and his ignorance.” Maher is similarly armored today. It’s one thing to denounce the Saudi monarchy for its fanatical illiberalism. Like Stalin’s dictatorship, it’s a particular regime in a particular place. But to imply that Islamism—and by extension organizations such as Tunisia’s Ennahda Party or Turkey’s AKP, both of which have won democratic elections—are just milder versions of ISIS is dangerously sloppy. As Kennan insisted again and again, national circumstances often play a larger role in determining how cultures and political systems function than do transnational beliefs. That’s especially true when the ideology isn’t even Islamism but Islam. Maher wants Americans to denounce Islam because while “all religions are stupid, Islam just happens to be the one right now, in this century, that’s most dangerous and violent.” That’s a wild overgeneralization. “Islam” is not violent or peaceful, dangerous or benign. Like every great religion, it includes a vast array of diverse and often contradictory teachings, which different people interpret in different ways in different places and times. Yes, in some Muslim-majority countries, women and religious minorities are treated brutally. But that has far more to do with their particular national circumstances than with the fact that Muslims populate them. After all, other Muslim-majority countries have elected female heads of state. To lump together Indonesia and Yemen because both countries are mostly Muslim makes about as much sense as lumping together Ireland and the Dominican Republic because both countries are mostly Catholic. Restraining the evil that lurks within our own culture requires facing our own history of terrible crimes. The second lesson from the Cold War is that while anti-totalitarianism is important, it can become an excuse for America’s own misdeeds. In 1954, eager to prove their anti-communist bona fides in the face of McCarthyite attacks, liberal stalwarts Hubert Humphrey, Paul Douglas, and John F. Kennedy introduced legislation banning the American Communist Party—thus using America’s crusade against Soviet repression to massively repress free speech here at home. America’s war in Vietnam, justified as a struggle for freedom and human rights, took close to a million lives. When Affleck told Maher that America has “killed more Muslims than they’ve killed us by an awful lot … and somehow we’re exempt from these things because they’re not really a reflection of what we believe in. We did it by accident,” he was making a crucial point. As the great liberal Cold War theologian Reinhold Niebuhr stressed, nations, like individuals, are often unable to acknowledge the degree to which selfish interest infects their supposed pursuit of high principle. Restraining the evil that lurks within our own culture requires facing our own history of, and ongoing capacity for, terrible crimes. It requires trying to see largely Christian America the way we are seen by the Muslims whose cities we have bombed. By contrast, declaring that the essential barbarism in today’s world lies elsewhere—not even just in a foreign regime or movement but in an entire religion—lets us off easy. “The pride and self-righteousness of powerful nations,” wrote Niebuhr, “are a greater hazard to their success than the machinations of their foes.” It took the Vietnam War for Schlesinger to truly appreciate that point. Given America’s experience in the Middle East over the last decade, Maher has no excuse. Presented by Jump to Comments * * Share on Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * InstaPaper * Pocket * Pinterest * Tumblr * Reddit * Email * Print * Comments [author-headshot.jpg?n6c6f2] Peter Beinart is a contributing editor at The Atlantic and National Journal, an associate professor of journalism and political science at the City University of New York, and a senior fellow at the New America Foundation. * All Posts * Follow @peterbeinart Video More video [video-featured.png?ni34lx] The Faces of #BlackLivesMatter Scenes from a recent protest in New York City * * Share on Facebook * Twitter * InstaPaper * Pocket * Pinterest * Tumblr The Atlantic More Articles [home-article-curation-promo.jpg?ni53ta] Promoting the Dead on Facebook Join the Discussion After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. blog comments powered by Disqus Close Video [play-button.png] [curation-special-report-thumb.png?ni34tc] The Faces of #BlackLivesMatter Scenes from a recent protest in New York City Video [play-button.png] [curation-special-report-thumb.png?ni34tc] Desegregated, Yet Unequal A short documentary about the legacy of Boston busing Video [play-button.png] [curation-special-report-thumb.jpg?ni34tc] Ruth Bader Ginsburg on Life The Supreme Court justice talks gender equality and marriage. Video [play-button.png] [curation-special-report-thumb.png?ni34tc] Social Media: The Video Game What if the validation of your peers could "level up" your life? Video [play-button.png] [curation-special-report-thumb.jpg?ni34tc] The Pentagon's $1.5 Trillion Mistake The F-35 fighter jet was supposed to do everything. Instead, it can barely do anything. More in Global * [channel-curation-featured-small.jpg?ni4wz6] Fake News From the Holy Land Debra Kamin * [channel-curation-featured-small.jpg?ni4wz6] David Cameron: Empower U.K. Spies to Read All Communications Conor Friedersdorf * [channel-curation-featured-small.jpg?ni4wz6] France's First Free-Speech Challenge After Charlie Hebdo Adam Chandler Photo [river_thumb.jpg?ni4nex] 35 Photos The 2015 Dakar Rally Just In * Facebook Doesn't Know You're Faking It Cari Romm * The Taken Series Is Every Father's Fear—And Fantasy Alexander Huls * The Dark Psychology of the Sexist Internet Commenter Olga Khazan Most Popular 1 What Happens to a Woman's Brain When She Becomes a Mother 2 Joint Pain, From the Gut 3 When Being a Valedictorian Isn’t Enough 4 Run, Warren, Run 5 Nigeria's Horror in Paris's Shadow 6 Not Everyone's Internal Clock Is Set for the 9-to-5 7 Same Performance, Better Grades 8 The Tragedy of the American Military 9 The 2015 Dakar Rally 10 Living Longer, Dying Differently ATLANTIC MEDIA The Wire * The Taken Series Is Every Father's Fear—And Fantasy * The 'Worst' German Word of the Year * Chris Christie's 'Renewal' More from The Wire CityLab * Mohammed Is the Most Common New York Taxi Driver Name * Every City Needs Vancouver's Ban on Food Scraps * In California's Poorest Towns, Tap Water's Legacy Is Toxic for Latinos More from CityLab Quartz * The places in the world that have a burqa ban * A rapist wants to play soccer again and the game is failing to cope * What US millennials spend on media More from Quartz National Journal * Rand Paul’s Tough Sell * Can Immigrants Save the Housing Market? * Chris Christie Makes New Moves Toward 2016 Run More from National Journal Defense One * The D Brief: AQAP claims Paris attack; McCain just got his second most wanted dream job; The amazing technology searching for AirAsia jet; Little gets a new job; Bradley Cooper talks at Sniper screening; And a bit more. * The Technology That Just Found the Missing AirAsia Plane * New Air Force Bomber Is a Critical Piece of the Pentagon’s Pacific Weaponry More from Defense One Follow The Atlantic * App store * Facebook * Twitter * Linkedin * Tumblr * RSS E-Newsletters * Today's Top Stories * This Week * This Month * New at In Focus * CityLab Information * FAQ * Subscribe Help * Masthead * Store * Emporium * Jobs * Privacy * Site Map * Terms and Conditions * Advertise * Advertising Guidelines * Press * Contact Us * Special Reports * Atlantic Scene * Books * Events * Atlantic Media Subscribe [large.png?ngoyt7] Get 10 issues a year and save 65% off the cover price ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ ______________________________ [STATE] __________ ______________________________ (Submit) Next ► Fraud alert regarding The Atlantic _________________________________________________________________ Copyright © 2015 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All Rights Reserved. CDN powered by Edgecast Networks. Insights powered by Parsely . Powered by the Parse.ly Publisher Platform (P3). [img]