#Opinionator » Is Our Patriotism Moral? Comments Feed Stone Links: The Rise of Café Philosophy In Rwanda, Health Care Coverage That Eludes the U.S. RSS 2.0 alternate (Submit) Sections (Submit) Home (Submit) Search Skip to content Opinionator | Is Our Patriotism Moral? (Submit) Search (Submit) Log In (Submit) (Submit) 0 (Submit) Settings (BUTTON) Close search search sponsored by Search NYTimes.com ____________________ (BUTTON) Clear this text input (Submit) Go 1. Loading... See next articles See previous articles * Home Page * Home Page * World * U.S. * Politics * New York * Business * Business * Opinion * Opinion * Technology * Science * Health * Sports * Sports * Arts * Arts * Fashion & Style * Fashion & Style * Food * Food * Home & Garden * Travel * Magazine * Real Estate * Obituaries * Video * The Upshot * More * Africa * Americas * Asia Pacific * Europe * Middle East * At War * India Ink * Sinosphere * Education * First Draft * Elections * City Room * ArtsBeat * Events * DealBook * Economy * Energy * Markets * Media * Small Business * Your Money * DealBook * Economy * Energy * Markets * Media * Small Business * Your Money * Op-Ed Columnists * Editorials * Contributing Writers * Op-Ed Contributors * Opinionator * Letters * Sunday Review * Taking Note * Room for Debate * Public Editor * Cartoons * Op-Ed Columnists * Editorials * Contributing Writers * Op-Ed Contributors * Opinionator * Letters * Sunday Review * Taking Note * Room for Debate * Public Editor * Cartoons * Bits * Personal Tech * Environment * Space & Cosmos * Well * Health Guide * Fitness & Nutrition * Money & Policy * The New Old Age * Views * Baseball * Basketball: College * Basketball: N.B.A. * Football: College * Football: N.F.L. * Golf * Hockey * Soccer * Tennis * Baseball * Basketball: College * Basketball: N.B.A. * Football: College * Football: N.F.L. * Golf * Hockey * Soccer * Tennis * Art & Design * ArtsBeat * Books * Dance * Movies * Music * N.Y.C. Events Guide * Television * Theater * Video Games * Art & Design * ArtsBeat * Books * Dance * Movies * Music * N.Y.C. Events Guide * Television * Theater * Video Games * T Magazine * Motherlode * On the Runway * Weddings * T Magazine * Motherlode * On the Runway * Weddings * Cooking * Restaurant Search * Cooking * Restaurant Search * Commercial Real Estate * Great Homes & Destinations * My Real Estate * U.S. & Politics * International * New York * Opinion * Times Documentaries * Business * Technology * Culture * Style * Health * Food * Travel * Sports * Real Estate * Science * Crossword * Times Premier * Today's Paper * Automobiles * Corrections * Multimedia * Photography * Classifieds * Tools & Services * Jobs * Times Topics * Blogs * NYT Store * Times Journeys * Subscribe * Manage Account * Charles M. Blow * David Brooks * Frank Bruni * Roger Cohen * Gail Collins * Ross Douthat * Maureen Dowd * Thomas L. Friedman * Nicholas Kristof * Paul Krugman * Joe Nocera * Charles M. Blow * David Brooks * Frank Bruni * Roger Cohen * Gail Collins * Ross Douthat * Maureen Dowd * Thomas L. Friedman * Nicholas Kristof * Paul Krugman * Joe Nocera [kicker-opinionpages.png] Opinionator - A Gathering of Opinion From Around the Web ____________________ (Submit) Search The Stone Is Our Patriotism Moral? By Gary Gutting July 3, 2012 7:05 pm July 3, 2012 7:05 pm (Submit) The Stone The Stone is a forum for contemporary philosophers and other thinkers on issues both timely and timeless. To my mind, the Fourth of July has a lot going for it compared with other holidays: great food without a lot of work, warm weather, no presents, and fireworks. And, in our house, at least, there’s the special moment when we read out loud the Declaration of Independence and follow with a toast (American sparkling wine, of course), “To the United States of America!” And I have to force back tears of pride at being an American. Patriotism need not conflict with a universal moral outlook. This is my own distinctive experience of what we call “patriotism,” and I suspect that many Americans experience something similar, and acknowledge it in their own ways. Amid the frequent confusion, frustration and anger of our political disagreements, patriotism — a deep-seated love of our country — remains something that has the potential to bring us together, particularly at times of national crisis or triumph. But within my own particular intellectual tribe of philosophers, patriotism is often regarded as a “problem,” an emotion that many find hard to defend as morally appropriate. Of course, many Americans are uneasy with, even repelled by, certain expressions of patriotism — perhaps the obligatory flag-pins of politicians, the inanity of “freedom fries,” the suggestion in the revised Pledge of Allegiance that atheists aren’t patriotic, or even readings of the Declaration of Independence. But the philosophical problem of patriotism is not about whether or not certain expressions of patriotism are appropriate; it is about the moral defensibility of the attitude as such. (For a good survey of the philosophical issues see Igor Primoriz’s Stanford Encyclopedia article.) At the beginning of Plato’s “Republic,” Socrates asks what justice (doing the morally right thing) is, and Polemarchus replies that it’s helping your friends and harming your enemies. That was the answer among the ancient Greeks as well as many other traditional societies. Moral behavior was the way you treated those in your “in-group,” as opposed to outsiders. Socrates questioned this ethical exclusivism, thus beginning a centuries-long argument that, by modern times, led most major moral philosophers (for example, Mill and Kant) to conclude that morality required an impartial, universal viewpoint that treated all human beings as equals. In other words, the “in-group” for morality is not any particular social group (family, city, nation) but humankind as a whole. This universal moral viewpoint seems to reject patriotism for “cosmopolitanism” —the view perhaps first formulated by Diogenes, who, when asked where he came from, replied that he was a citizen of the world. Certainly, patriotism can take an explicitly amoral form: “My country, right or wrong.” But even strong traditional patriots can accept moral limits on the means we use to advance the cause of our country. They may agree, for example, that it’s wrong to threaten Canada with nuclear annihilation to obtain a more favorable trade agreement. But the moral problem for patriotism arises at a deeper level. Suppose the question is not about blatantly immoral means but simply about whether our country should flourish at the expense of another? Suppose, for example, that at some point Saudi Arabia, now allied with China, threatened to curtail our access to its oil, thereby significantly reducing our productivity and tipping the balance of world economic power to China. Imagine an American president who declined to oppose this action because he had concluded that, from a disinterested moral viewpoint, it was better for mankind as a whole. Even if we admired such a response, it’s hard to think that it would express patriotic regard for the United States. Should we therefore conclude that patriotism is ultimately at odds with a moral viewpoint? There remains the option of denying that morality has the universal, all-inclusive nature modern philosophers think it has. Alasdair MacIntyre, for example, argues that morality is rooted in the life of a specific real community — a village, a city, a nation, with its idiosyncratic customs and history — and that, therefore, adherence to morality requires loyalty to such a community. Patriotism, on this view, is essential for living a morally good life. MacIntyre’s argument (in his Lindley Lecture, “Is Patriotism a Virtue?”) has provided the most powerful contemporary defense of a full-blooded patriotism. It may seem, then, that we must either accept modern universalist ethics and reject patriotism as a basic moral virtue or accept patriotism along with MacIntyre’s traditional localist morality. But perhaps, at least in the American context, there is a way of avoiding the dilemma. For what is the animating ideal of American patriotism if not the freedom of all persons, not just its own citizens? This is apparent in our Declaration, which bases its case for independence on the principle that governments exist to “secure the rights” of “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” to which all persons are equally entitled. This principle is the avowed purpose of all our actions as a nation, and we may read our history as the story of our successes and failures in carrying out this principle. America, then, is the paradox of a local historical project that aims at universal liberation. Through this project, we have a way of combining traditional patriotism with universal morality. Related More From The Stone Read previous contributions to this series. This project has had many failures, most often when we forget that the freedom of a nation must always grow from its own historical roots. We cannot simply wage a war that rips up those roots and then transplant shoots from our own stock (American-style capitalism, political parties, our popular culture). We have also often forgotten that the liberation of our own citizens is by no means complete. But none of this alters the fact that our governments have often worked and our soldiers died not just for our own freedom but for the freedom of all nations. We are a MacIntyrean community that is still trying to live out a modern morality that seeks the freedom of everyone. I love America because I still believe that this sublime project is possible. __________________________________________________________________ Gary Gutting Gary Gutting is a professor of philosophy at the University of Notre Dame, and an editor of Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews. He is the author of, most recently, “Thinking the Impossible: French Philosophy since 1960,” and writes regularly for The Stone. Correction: July 4, 2012 An earlier version of this article misidentified the speaker in Plato's Republic who declares that justice is helping your friends and harming your enemies. It was Polemarchus, the son of Cephalus, not Cephalus himself. (Submit) The Stone, Patriotism, Philosophy More on nytimes.com * Previous Post Stone Links: The Rise of Café Philosophy * Next Post In Rwanda, Health Care Coverage That Eludes the U.S. The Stone features the writing of contemporary philosophers and other thinkers on issues both timely and timeless. The series moderator is Simon Critchley. He teaches philosophy at The New School for Social Research in New York. To contact the editors of The Stone, send an e-mail to opinionator@nytimes.com. Please include “The Stone” in the subject field. * The Stone RSS Inside Opinionator * Fixes Fixes * Disunion Disunion * Private Lives Private Lives * Draft Draft * The Stone The Stone * More Contributors + Bedside Bedside + Couch Couch + Errol Morris Errol Morris + Home Fires Home Fires + Measure for Measure Measure for Measure + Menagerie Menagerie + Stanley Fish Stanley Fish + The Conversation The Conversation + The Great Divide The Great Divide + All Contributors & Series » January 22, 2015 In Egypt, Sowing the Seeds of Gender Equality A program has shown that mixing boys and girls together for discussions helps build empathy across the gender divide.Read more… January 16, 2015 For Better Crime Prevention, a Dose of Science We need science and gold-standard evidence about what works to help us identify promising interventions, and save lives. Read more… More From Fixes » January 21, 2015 Shannon’s Scouts vs. Sherman’s Armies Unable to beat the Union general on the field, the Confederacy sent a small group of shock troops to slow down his progress through the Carolinas.Read more… January 16, 2015 Forty Acres and a Mule The origins, and failure, of Gen. William T. Sherman’s plan to resettle freed slaves.Read more… More From Disunion » January 21, 2015 This Is Your Grandmother I saved her voice mails, realizing that any message could be the last.Read more… January 14, 2015 What Would You Grab in a Fire? My son — but also, my toothbrush, my computer and a knife.Read more… More From Private Lives » January 19, 2015 A Poet’s Boyhood at the Burning Crossroads In the wake of the deaths of James Byrd Jr. and Matthew Shepard, the process of writing poems felt like a reprieve. Read more… November 22, 2014 Writing to the Beat Shakespeare, Hemingway and Poe had their own rhythm.Read more… More From Draft » January 18, 2015 What, To the Black American, Is Martin Luther King Jr. Day? This holiday does not fully belong in the most profound ways to many Americans, and to some, it does not belong at all.Read more… January 12, 2015 What’s Wrong With ‘All Lives Matter’? The philosopher Judith Butler argues that we risk missing the fact that black people have not yet been included in the idea of “all lives.” Read more… More From The Stone » January 18, 2015 Good Eggs It wasn’t cuddly or strokable, but I had no choice in the matter: We were going to be sharing our apartment with a turtle.Read more… January 11, 2015 A Swarm in ‘Dead City’ At 14, I tried to run away. But millions of molting cicadas, and a mother who loved me, came between me and my freedom. Read more… More From Menagerie » January 17, 2015 After PTSD, More Trauma I was a veteran who needed therapy. What I got was another kind of battle.Read more… January 10, 2015 Getting Grief Right Don’t believe what you hear about closure and “stages” of mourning.Read more… More From Couch » January 3, 2015 When Prisoners Are Patients Should convicted felons receive free health care?Read more… September 6, 2014 When It’s the Doctor Who Can’t Let Go Too many physicians think palliative care means giving up.Read more… More From Bedside » November 5, 2014 The Republican Party In Triumph Brooks and Collins on the full extent of the Election Day devastation of Democrats, including some who weren’t on the ballot.Read more… October 28, 2014 Political Infections Brooks and Collins on conflicting responses to Ebola, the meaning of the midterms and the pleasure of voting for effective crooks.Read more… More From The Conversation » June 27, 2014 Inequality Is Not Inevitable Inexorable laws of economics aren’t tearing us apart. Our policies are.Read more… June 21, 2014 Gaming the Poor Modern slot machine parlors have sophisticated methods of milking less affluent gamblers.Read more… More From The Great Divide » March 28, 2014 The Certainty of Donald Rumsfeld (Part 4) The absence of evidence, the evidence of absence, and the Iraq War.Read more… March 27, 2014 The Certainty of Donald Rumsfeld (Part 3) Could Pearl Harbor be called a “failure of imagination,” and in that sense was it similar to the attacks of 9/11?Read more… More From Errol Morris » February 7, 2014 Time Travel and the Ballad Tradition Inspiration can come from unpredictable places: family history, 19th-century personal ads, a child’s eighth-grade project.Read more… January 31, 2014 The Sound of a Tree Falling Is Not Ka-ching Does it still count as a solo album if your cat meows on a couple of tracks?Read more… More From Measure for Measure » November 10, 2013 Lives During Wartime, Vol. 4 A collection of reader photographs and remembrances of United States military veterans and their service.Read more… October 19, 2013 Invitation to Veterans, Their Friends and Families A call to readers for photographs and recollections of United States’ military veterans and their service. A selection will be published on Veterans’ Day, Nov. 11, 2013.Read more… More From Home Fires » October 28, 2013 Academic Freedom Against Itself: Boycotting Israeli Universities In the skewed logic of the boycott, academic freedom means abandoning its precepts when your political considerations outweigh them.Read more… September 23, 2013 Deeper Than God: Ronald Dworkin’s Religious Atheism A final book grapples with a vexing question: to what extent and on what basis should constitutional protection be afforded to religious activities?Read more… More From Stanley Fish » Archive [Select Month..] Recent Posts [opinionator-pog-fixes-thumbStandard.gif] Fixes In Egypt, Sowing the Seeds of Gender Equality A program has shown that mixing boys and girls together for discussions helps build empathy across the gender divide.Read more… [opinionator-pog-disunion-thumbStandard.gif] Disunion Shannon’s Scouts vs. Sherman’s Armies Unable to beat the Union general on the field, the Confederacy sent a small group of shock troops to slow down his progress through the Carolinas.Read more… [opinionator-pog-privatelives-thumbStandard.png] Private Lives This Is Your Grandmother I saved her voice mails, realizing that any message could be the last.Read more… [opinionator-pog-draft-thumbStandard.png] Draft A Poet’s Boyhood at the Burning Crossroads In the wake of the deaths of James Byrd Jr. and Matthew Shepard, the process of writing poems felt like a reprieve. Read more… [opinionator-pog-thestone-thumbStandard.gif] The Stone What, To the Black American, Is Martin Luther King Jr. Day? This holiday does not fully belong in the most profound ways to many Americans, and to some, it does not belong at all.Read more… Follow us on @nytopinionator on twitter * Twitter Follow Site Index News * World * U.S. * Politics * New York * Business * Technology * Science * Health * Sports * Education * Obituaries * Today's Paper * Corrections Opinion * Today's Opinion * Op-Ed Columnists * Editorials * Contributing Writers * Op-Ed Contributors * Opinionator * Letters * Sunday Review * Taking Note * Room for Debate * Public Editor * Video: Opinion Arts * Today's Arts * Art & Design * ArtsBeat * Books * Dance * Movies * Music * N.Y.C. Events Guide * Television * Theater * Video Games * Video: Arts Living * Automobiles * Crossword * Food * Education * Fashion & Style * Health * Home & Garden * Jobs * Magazine * N.Y.C. Events Guide * Real Estate * T Magazine * Travel * Weddings & Celebrations Listings & More * Classifieds * Tools & Services * Times Topics * Public Editor * N.Y.C. Events Guide * TV Listings * Blogs * Cartoons * Multimedia * Photography * Video * NYT Store * Times Journeys * Subscribe * Manage My Account Subscribe * Subscribe * Times Premier * Home Delivery * Digital Subscriptions * NYT Opinion * Crossword * Email Newsletters * Alerts * Gift Subscriptions * Corporate Subscriptions * Education Rate * Mobile Applications * Replica Edition * International New York Times * © 2015 The New York Times Company * Contact Us * Work With Us * Advertise * Your Ad Choices * Privacy * Terms of Service * Terms of Sale * Site Map * Help * Site Feedback * Subscriptions