#alternate alternate Homepage Accessibility links * Skip to content * Accessibility Help BBC Account Notifications * Home * News * Sport * Weather * iPlayer * Sounds * CBBC * CBeebies * Food * Bitesize * Earth * Arts * Make It Digital * Taster * Local * Tomorrow's World * TV * Radio * Menu Search Search the BBC ____________________ (BUTTON) Search the BBC News BBC News Navigation Sections * Home * Video * World * UK selected * Business * Tech * Science * Stories * Entertainment & Arts * Health * World News TV * In Pictures * Reality Check * Newsbeat * Special Reports * Explainers * The Reporters * Have Your Say England selected * Local News * Regions * Surrey selected Surrey Surrey Guildford couple's child adoption complaint rejected * 14 December 2018 * Share this with Facebook * Share this with Messenger * Share this with Twitter * Share this with Email * Share this with Facebook * Share this with WhatsApp * Share this with Messenger * Share this with Twitter * Share Share this with These are external links and will open in a new window + Email Share this with Email + Facebook Share this with Facebook + Messenger Share this with Messenger + Messenger Share this with Messenger + Twitter Share this with Twitter + Pinterest Share this with Pinterest + WhatsApp Share this with WhatsApp + LinkedIn Share this with LinkedIn Copy this link https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-surrey-46568046 Read more about sharing. These are external links and will open in a new window (BUTTON) Close share panel Karrissa Cox and Richard Carter Image caption Karrissa Cox and Richard Carter challenged a family court ruling A couple forced to give their baby up for adoption, even after being cleared of abuse, did not suffer a miscarriage of justice, a judge has ruled. Karrissa Cox and Richard Carter, from Guildford, had challenged a family court ruling that criticised them and backed the baby's adoption. They claimed they had been treated as "guilty until proven innocent". However, Judge Sir James Munby said their child had been the victim of "really serious" abuse and "cruelty". Ms Cox and Mr Carter lodged a legal challenge in 2015, vowing to clear their names. But after reviewing the evidence of that hearing, Sir James said the family court "process" overseen by Judge Peter Nathan had been vindicated and neither the parents, nor their child, had suffered a miscarriage of justice. The baby, who cannot be identified, was taken away from Ms Cox and Mr Carter, a former soldier, who served in Afghanistan, in 2012 when it was just six weeks old. Image copyright Google Image caption The judge backed Surrey County Council's intervention, which resulted in the baby being adopted The couple were charged with child cruelty after hospital staff found a number of bruises and what appeared to be bone fractures. But they were acquitted on the direction of the judge at Guildford Crown Court after an expert witness said he could not be sure the X-rays showed fractures. The baby was subsequently adopted and the parents - who have since separated - dropped their demand to have the child back during the course of Sir James's review. In his ruling, Sir James, former president of the Family Division of the High Court, backed the judge who had overseen the earlier hearing. He said the couple carried a "high measure of responsibility" for "serious parental failures". Sir James said that during the first few weeks of its life, the child had suffered an "extraordinary constellation" of "inflicted injuries for which there is no innocent explanation". In his ruling, he said the "constellation of marks and bruises... were inflicted by one or other or both of the birth parents... using unreasonable force". Mr Carter did not attend and was not represented at court for the judgement. Ms Cox's barrister has not responded to BBC approaches for comment. Related Topics * Surrey County Council * Guildford Share this story About sharing * Email * Facebook * Messenger * Messenger * Twitter * Pinterest * WhatsApp * LinkedIn More on this story * Guildford couple cleared of child abuse 'victims of unfair system' 14 October 2015 * Guildford couple cleared of abuse fight to get child back 9 October 2015 * Charges dropped against couple accused of 'baby abuse' 7 October 2015 Related Internet links * HM Courts & Tribunals Service * Surrey County Council The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites Surrey live reporting Live BBC Live: South East Full article BBC Live: South East Top Stories North Korea's Kim begins visit to China Kim Jong-un is in Beijing for a three-day visit at the invitation of China's president, state media say. 8 January 2019 Ex-Nissan boss says he is wrongly accused 8 January 2019 UNHCR 'grateful' Saudi woman not deported 8 January 2019 Features A girl's murder in Peking and a literary feud Is Africa seeing fewer military takeover attempts? Can a Leona Lewis story really help you sleep at night? Video How Vancouver is helping opioid addicts Video Why female penguins are washing up dead The upside to schadenfreude BBC Culture: Odd details hidden in eight masterpieces Golden Globes red carpet in pictures Video The 'superwoman' midwife of the mountains Elsewhere on the BBC Lyrics quiz Have you been getting these songs wrong? Full article Lyrics quiz Feeling hot What happens to your body in extreme heat? Full article Feeling hot Why you can trust BBC News BBC News Navigation England Sections * England * Local News * Regions * Surrey selected * Home * Video * World + World Home + Africa + Asia + Australia + Europe + Latin America + Middle East + US & Canada * UK selected + UK Home + England selected + N. Ireland + Scotland + Wales + Politics * Business + Business Home + Market Data + Global Trade + Companies + Entrepreneurship + Technology of Business + Connected World + Global Education + Economy * Tech * Science * Stories * Entertainment & Arts * Health * World News TV * In Pictures * Reality Check * Newsbeat * Special Reports * Explainers * The Reporters * Have Your Say BBC News Services * On your mobile * On your connected tv * Get news alerts * Contact BBC News Explore the BBC * Home * News * Sport * Weather * iPlayer * Sounds * CBBC * CBeebies * Food * Bitesize * Earth * Arts * Make It Digital * Taster * Local * Tomorrow's World * TV * Radio * Terms of Use * About the BBC * Privacy Policy * Cookies * Accessibility Help * Parental Guidance * Contact the BBC * Get Personalised Newsletters Copyright © 2019 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.