12 to	the
      8 Share	on
      7 to	be
      7 switch	to
      7 high	speed
      6 of	the
      6 edition	switch
      5 the	north
      5 the	city
      5 The	Guardian
      4 the	UK
      4 speed	line
      3 to	Liverpool
      3 that	the
      3 of	HS2
      3 northern	powerhouse
      3 jobs	Dating
      3 in	the
      3 going	to
      3 cost	of
      3 and	the
      3 a	high
      3 Search	jobs
      3 International	edition
      3 Discount	Codes
      3 Anderson	said
      2 years	old
      2 would	see
      2 would	free
      2 we	are
      2 via	Email
      2 up	the
      2 two	thirds
      2 through	the
      2 thirds	of
      2 the	proposals
      2 the	northern
      2 the	line
      2 the	government
      2 the	cost
      2 the	US
      2 the	Treasury
      2 the	HS2
      2 the	Australia
      2 that	it
      2 than	3
      2 saw	no
      2 said	he
      2 readers	Contribute
      2 proposals	were
      2 problems	in
      2 politics	Education
      2 planned	high
      2 plan	would
      2 phase	of
      2 on	Twitter
      2 on	Facebook
      2 of	Liverpool
      2 of	England
      2 no	logistical
      2 more	than
      2 mayor	of
      2 logistical	problems
      2 line	to
      2 is	more
      2 is	essential
      2 in	building
      2 he	saw
      2 he	said
      2 funded	by
      2 from	the
      2 free	up
      2 for	the
      2 for	freight
      2 for	everyone
      2 for	Liverpool
      2 everyone	funded
      2 essential	for
      2 cities	of
      2 by	the
      2 by	readers
      2 building	a
      2 be	a
      2 article	is
      2 are	going
      2 and	London
      2 Wales	Northern
      2 US	edition
      2 UK	politics
      2 UK	edition
      2 UK	UK
      2 Twitter	Share
      2 This	article
      2 The	mayor
      2 Support	The
      2 Sport	Culture
      2 Society	Law
      2 Share	via
      2 Scotland	Wales
      2 Read	more
      2 Opinion	Sport
      2 Northern	Ireland
      2 News	Opinion
      2 Media	Society
      2 Manchester	and
      2 Liverpool	to
      2 Liverpool	s
      2 Liverpool	Joe
      2 Law	Scotland
      2 Joe	Anderson
      2 Holidays	Digital
      2 HS2	s
      2 Guardian	Available
      2 George	Osborne
      2 Facebook	Twitter
      2 Facebook	Share
      2 Education	Media
      2 Digital	Archive
      2 Dating	Holidays
      2 Culture	Lifestyle
      2 Contribute	Subscribe
      2 Back	to
      2 Available	for
      2 Australia	edition
      2 Archive	Discount
      2 3	years
      2 25	BUTTON
      1 you	want
      1 year	A
      1 writers	Digital
      1 would	stimulate
      1 would	rather
      1 would	pay
      1 would	make
      1 would	form
      1 would	bring
      1 would	be
      1 would	allow
      1 with	us
      1 with	two
      1 with	millions
      1 with	google
      1 with	existing
      1 with	2bn
      1 will	probably
      1 will	be
      1 wider	economy
      1 which	has
      1 when	Manchester
      1 western	point
      1 west	links
      1 were	well
      1 were	credible
      1 well	thought
      1 we	re
      1 we	get
      1 we	as
      1 was	funded
      1 want	to
      1 vision	and
      1 view	Columnists
      1 videos	Letters
      1 ve	got
      1 us	showing
      1 us	Search
      1 us	Privacy
      1 us	Complaints
      1 up	extra
      1 up	capacity
      1 unthreaded	Loading
      1 unlike	in
      1 union	Tennis
      1 uk	Contact
      1 two	high
      1 tunnels	could
      1 transport	select
      1 transport	Transport
      1 transport	2CTransport
      1 trains	per
      1 tracks	after
      1 track	was
      1 track	that
      1 towards	the
      1 topics	All
      1 top	2020
      1 today	uk
      1 to	top
      1 to	sell
      1 to	search
      1 to	prosperity
      1 to	play
      1 to	pay
      1 to	move
      1 to	main
      1 to	home
      1 to	have
      1 to	extend
      1 to	expose
      1 to	directly
      1 to	continue
      1 to	connect
      1 to	both
      1 to	add
      1 to	Manchester
      1 to	Birmingham
      1 through	increased
      1 thought	out
      1 this	year
      1 this	mechanism
      1 this	content
      1 thinktank	ResPublica
      1 these	Crossrails
      1 there	has
      1 them	to
      1 the	wider
      1 the	western
      1 the	transport
      1 the	thinktank
      1 the	the
      1 the	success
      1 the	south
      1 the	second
      1 the	route
      1 the	report
      1 the	price
      1 the	planned
      1 the	other
      1 the	investment
      1 the	human
      1 the	first
      1 the	failings
      1 the	economy
      1 the	economic
      1 the	current
      1 the	cornerstone
      1 the	cities
      1 the	chancellor
      1 the	chair
      1 the	capital
      1 the	bulk
      1 the	accompanying
      1 the	Mersey
      1 the	Liverpool2
      1 the	International
      1 the	Guardian
      1 the	Chilterns
      1 the	55bn
      1 that	would
      1 that	sum
      1 that	money
      1 that	he
      1 that	argued
      1 than	sending
      1 term	repayment
      1 term	do
      1 taxes	rather
      1 sum	through
      1 suggests	although
      1 success	of
      1 stretch	of
      1 stimulate	over
      1 sports	BUTTON
      1 spokesperson	for
      1 spend	that
      1 spend	all
      1 speed	trains
      1 speed	rail
      1 speed	link
      1 south	which
      1 showing	how
      1 sex	Health
      1 severely	the
      1 several	decades
      1 seriously	considered
      1 serious	about
      1 sending	them
      1 sell	Liverpool
      1 select	committee
      1 seen	residents
      1 see	a
      1 see	Liverpool
      1 second	phase
      1 search	BUTTON
      1 says	the
      1 says	link
      1 said	the
      1 said	that
      1 said	The
      1 said	That
      1 said	If
      1 said	Anderson
      1 s	track
      1 s	route
      1 s	paper
      1 s	offer
      1 s	northern
      1 s	network
      1 s	most
      1 s	leaders
      1 s	argument
      1 s	an
      1 s	actually
      1 route	of
      1 route	north
      1 route	for
      1 route	connecting
      1 route	The
      1 rights	reserved
      1 revenue	in
      1 resources	normally
      1 residents	from
      1 reserved	BUTTON
      1 report	suggests
      1 report	puts
      1 report	by
      1 replies	Public
      1 repayment	commitment
      1 recommendations	BUTTON
      1 rebalancing	the
      1 re	serious
      1 rather	than
      1 rather	spend
      1 rates	and
      1 raised	taxes
      1 railway	proposed
      1 rail	project
      1 rail	network
      1 rail	lines
      1 radio	Art
      1 puts	the
      1 publisher	alternate
      1 published	later
      1 prosperity	Anderson
      1 proposes	city
      1 proposed	to
      1 proposals	would
      1 project	Patrick
      1 profile	Account
      1 probably	happen
      1 price	with
      1 powerhouse	vision
      1 powerhouse	envisioned
      1 powerhouse	Our
      1 potentially	be
      1 port	opening
      1 popular	UK
      1 politicians	insisted
      1 policy	Terms
      1 policy	Read
      1 policy	Cookie
      1 point	of
      1 play	our
      1 per	hour
      1 paying	however
      1 pay	dividends
      1 pay	2bn
      1 particular	campaign
      1 part	in
      1 paper	Inside
      1 paid	direct
      1 p	c1
      1 over	several
      1 out	and
      1 out	Search
      1 ourselves	and
      1 our	part
      1 other	cities
      1 or	its
      1 or	10
      1 opening	next
      1 on	the
      1 on	infrastructure
      1 on	existing
      1 on	WhatsApp
      1 on	Thu
      1 on	Pinterest
      1 on	Messenger
      1 on	LinkedIn
      1 oldest	BUTTON
      1 old	Mayor
      1 old	Liverpool
      1 offers	2bn
      1 offered	to
      1 offer	would
      1 of	us
      1 of	track
      1 of	that
      1 of	resources
      1 of	locally
      1 of	infrastructure
      1 of	how
      1 of	fast
      1 of	extending
      1 of	cost
      1 of	a
      1 of	Tory
      1 of	Crewe
      1 of	Britain
      1 now	because
      1 not	to
      1 north	said
      1 north	of
      1 north	due
      1 north	and
      1 north	The
      1 north	Liverpool
      1 normally	paid
      1 next	month
      1 newspaper	archive
      1 news	UK
      1 news	Share
      1 news	Environment
      1 news	2CR
      1 newest	BUTTON
      1 network	to
      1 network	With
      1 network	This
      1 need	for
      1 national	insurance
      1 must	be
      1 move	closer
      1 most	expensive
      1 more	containers
      1 more	comments
      1 more	The
      1 more	Anderson
      1 month	he
      1 money	now
      1 money	jobs
      1 modified	on
      1 millions	more
      1 mile	stretch
      1 might	be
      1 mechanism	would
      1 marketing	______________________________________________________________
      1 making	journeys
      1 make	up
      1 main	content
      1 long	term
      1 locally	raised
      1 local	employers
      1 local	MPs
      1 loading	BUTTON
      1 links	across
      1 linking	Liverpool
      1 link	would
      1 link	to
      1 link	the
      1 link	is
      1 link	Manchester
      1 lines	for
      1 line	would
      1 line	linking
      1 line	here
      1 line	Gwyn
      1 left	behind
      1 leaders	fear
      1 later	this
      1 largely	on
      1 keeping	hold
      1 journeys	from
      1 jobs	and
      1 jobs	Sign
      1 its	counterparts
      1 its	airport
      1 its	affiliated
      1 it	would
      1 it	might
      1 it	going
      1 it	It
      1 issue	of
      1 is	huge
      1 is	failing
      1 is	expected
      1 is	completed
      1 is	clear
      1 investment	would
      1 invested	in
      1 into	the
      1 insurance	contributions
      1 insisted	that
      1 infrastructure	the
      1 infrastructure	spend
      1 increased	revenue
      1 including	local
      1 including	Angela
      1 included	in
      1 in	particular
      1 in	generating
      1 in	business
      1 in	My
      1 in	London
      1 in	HS2
      1 in	2016
      1 if	we
      1 if	the
      1 human	cost
      1 huge	if
      1 however	circumspectly
      1 how	the
      1 how	severely
      1 how	determined
      1 hour	faster
      1 hour	compatible
      1 home	Support
      1 hold	of
      1 here	the
      1 he	would
      1 have	it
      1 has	to
      1 has	seen
      1 has	offered
      1 has	been
      1 hard	against
      1 happen	before
      1 half	an
      1 growth	through
      1 government	s
      1 government	cuts
      1 government	agrees
      1 got	to
      1 google	Make
      1 get	HS3
      1 generating	money
      1 garden	Women
      1 funding	plan
      1 funded	centrally
      1 from	keeping
      1 from	Camden
      1 freight	with
      1 freight	Photograph
      1 form	the
      1 form	footer
      1 for	us
      1 for	chancellor
      1 for	a
      1 for	HS2
      1 footer	today
      1 fitness	Home
      1 first	phase
      1 financially	detrimental
      1 fear	the
      1 faster	Topics
      1 fast	east
      1 fairer	distribution
      1 failings	of
      1 failing	on
      1 extra	capacity
      1 extension	would
      1 extending	HS2
      1 extend	planned
      1 expose	the
      1 expensive	ever
      1 expected	to
      1 expected	through
      1 expanded	BUTTON
      1 existing	tracks
      1 existing	rail
      1 excluded	Yes
      1 ever	rail
      1 envisioned	by
      1 endorsed	a
      1 employment	that
      1 employers	national
      1 emphasised	how
      1 email	form
      1 edition	current
      1 edition	Search
      1 edition	News
      1 edition	International
      1 economy	to
      1 economy	there
      1 economy	The
      1 economic	case
      1 east	west
      1 due	to
      1 do	you
      1 dividends	for
      1 distribution	of
      1 disadvantaged	Ellman
      1 directly	link
      1 direct	to
      1 difficult	to
      1 devolution	of
      1 development	Football
      1 detrimental	by
      1 determined	we
      1 details	Emails
      1 detailed	route
      1 design	Film
      1 depend	largely
      1 dedicated	high
      1 decades	Anderson
      1 cv	2
      1 cuts	Why
      1 current	proposals
      1 current	edition
      1 credible	and
      1 covers	two
      1 cover	two
      1 counterparts	in
      1 could	potentially
      1 could	cover
      1 cost	to
      1 correspondent	GwynTopham
      1 corrections	SecureDrop
      1 cornerstone	of
      1 contributions	However
      1 contribution	Subscribe
      1 continued	growth
      1 continue	the
      1 content	View
      1 content	The
      1 containers	expected
      1 considered	A
      1 connection	when
      1 connecting	to
      1 connecting	London
      1 connected	to
      1 connect	up
      1 conditions	Help
      1 conceded	that
      1 comscorekw	HS2
      1 completed	in
      1 compatible	with
      1 companies	All
      1 committee	endorsed
      1 commitment	and
      1 comments	Trouble
      1 comments	Most
      1 comments	BUTTON
      1 coming	from
      1 collapsed	BUTTON
      1 closer	to
      1 clear	Is
      1 cj	1
      1 city	will
      1 city	into
      1 city	has
      1 city	covers
      1 city	could
      1 city	are
      1 city	and
      1 circumspectly	for
      1 chancellor	s
      1 chancellor	George
      1 chair	of
      1 centrally	But
      1 central	government
      1 case	is
      1 capital	half
      1 capacity	on
      1 capacity	for
      1 campaign	hard
      1 c2	6035250
      1 c1	2
      1 by	central
      1 by	being
      1 by	BUTTON
      1 business	rates
      1 bulk	of
      1 built	between
      1 bring	the
      1 both	the
      1 both	ourselves
      1 between	2026
      1 benefit	with
      1 being	excluded
      1 behind	its
      1 before	we
      1 been	affected
      1 because	of
      1 be	seriously
      1 be	published
      1 be	left
      1 be	invested
      1 be	included
      1 be	financially
      1 be	disadvantaged
      1 be	difficult
      1 be	connected
      1 be	built
      1 at	3bn
      1 as	a
      1 argument	not
      1 argued	a
      1 are	to
      1 archive	Facebook
      1 app	Video
      1 and	that
      1 and	says
      1 and	proposes
      1 and	must
      1 and	local
      1 and	its
      1 and	employment
      1 and	emphasised
      1 and	depend
      1 and	continued
      1 and	Louise
      1 and	Leeds
      1 and	Birmingham
      1 and	2033
      1 an	issue
      1 an	hour
      1 although	Anderson
      1 alternate	Skip
      1 allow	both
      1 all	these
      1 all	comments
      1 airport	The
      1 ail	transport
      1 agrees	to
      1 against	the
      1 after	the
      1 affiliated	companies
      1 affected	by
      1 added	that
      1 add	a
      1 actually	to
      1 across	the
      1 account	Comments
      1 accompanying	devolution
      1 about	rebalancing
      1 a	report
      1 a	long
      1 a	fairer
      1 a	dedicated
      1 a	contribution
      1 a	connection
      1 a	city
      1 a	HS3
      1 a	20
      1 ______________________________________________________________	Sign
      1 ______________________________________________________________	Membership
      1 ____________________	What
      1 Yes	we
      1 World	news
      1 Work	for
      1 Women	Men
      1 With	the
      1 Why	the
      1 WhatsApp	Share
      1 What	term
      1 Weekly	Crosswords
      1 View	more
      1 View	all
      1 Video	Podcasts
      1 Using	this
      1 US	sports
      1 UK	news
      1 UK	jobs
      1 UK	is
      1 UK	economy
      1 Twitter	Search
      1 Twitter	Advertise
      1 Tue	23
      1 Trouble	loading
      1 Treasury	including
      1 Treasury	Using
      1 Travel	Money
      1 Transport	correspondent
      1 Transport	North
      1 Train	The
      1 Tory	policy
      1 Topics	HS2
      1 Topham	Transport
      1 Today	s
      1 Thu	7
      1 Threads	BUTTON
      1 They	ve
      1 The	report
      1 The	plan
      1 The	need
      1 The	link
      1 The	extension
      1 The	Observer
      1 That	s
      1 Terms	conditions
      1 Tennis	Cycling
      1 Tech	Business
      1 TV	radio
      1 Subscriptions	______________________________________________________________
      1 Subscribe	Contribute
      1 Subscribe	Back
      1 Subscribe	BUTTON
      1 Stage	BUTTON
      1 Sport	Football
      1 Skip	to
      1 Sign	out
      1 Sign	in
      1 Show	More
      1 Show	25
      1 SecureDrop	Work
      1 Search	with
      1 Search	switch
      1 Search	UK
      1 Science	Cities
      1 Rugby	union
      1 Reuse	this
      1 ResPublica	that
      1 Recipes	Love
      1 Rail	transport
      1 Public	profile
      1 Profits	from
      1 Privacy	policy
      1 Podcasts	Pictures
      1 Pinterest	Share
      1 Pictures	Newsletters
      1 Photograph	HS2
      1 Patrick	Barkham
      1 PA	Liverpool
      1 Our	funding
      1 Osborne	news
      1 Osborne	HS2
      1 Osborne	
      1 Order	by
      1 Opinion	videos
      1 Opinion	The
      1 Observer	Guardian
      1 Obituaries	BUTTON
      1 North	of
      1 Newsletters	Today
      1 News	World
      1 News	Media
      1 My	account
      1 Music	TV
      1 Most	popular
      1 More	HS2
      1 More	BUTTON
      1 Money	____________________
      1 Messenger	Reuse
      1 Mersey	tunnels
      1 Men	Family
      1 Membership	Contributions
      1 Media	Limited
      1 Mayor	says
      1 Mar	2019
      1 Manchester	s
      1 Make	a
      1 MPs	including
      1 Ltd	said
      1 Love	sex
      1 Louise	Ellman
      1 London	will
      1 London	is
      1 London	and
      1 London	Liverpool
      1 Loading	comments
      1 Liverpool2	port
      1 Liverpool	unlike
      1 Liverpool	paying
      1 Liverpool	offers
      1 Liverpool	is
      1 Liverpool	has
      1 Liverpool	benefit
      1 Liverpool	at
      1 Liverpool	and
      1 Liverpool	Rail
      1 LinkedIn	Share
      1 Limited	or
      1 Lifestyle	Show
      1 Lifestyle	IFRAME
      1 Lifestyle	Fashion
      1 Letters	BUTTON
      1 Leeds	to
      1 Last	modified
      1 It	s
      1 Is	it
      1 Ireland	News
      1 Ireland	BUTTON
      1 Inside	the
      1 If	we
      1 IFRAME	email
      1 However	politicians
      1 Home	garden
      1 Help	All
      1 Health	fitness
      1 HS3	route
      1 HS3	They
      1 HS2	to
      1 HS2	the
      1 HS2	route
      1 HS2	network
      1 HS2	link
      1 HS2	if
      1 HS2	This
      1 HS2	PA
      1 HS2	Ltd
      1 HS2	Liverpool
      1 HS2	2CLiverpool
      1 GwynTopham	Tue
      1 Gwyn	Topham
      1 Guardian	view
      1 Guardian	app
      1 Guardian	Weekly
      1 Guardian	The
      1 Guardian	News
      1 Guardian	Back
      1 Golf	US
      1 Global	development
      1 Games	Classical
      1 GMT	Share
      1 GMT	Last
      1 Football	Tech
      1 Football	Cricket
      1 Food	Recipes
      1 Film	Games
      1 Feb	2016
      1 Fashion	Food
      1 Family	Travel
      1 F1	Golf
      1 Environment	Science
      1 England	George
      1 England	2CGeorge
      1 Emails	marketing
      1 Email	Train
      1 Email	Share
      1 Ellman	the
      1 Ellman	said
      1 Eagle	and
      1 Digital	newspaper
      1 Dating	Discount
      1 Cycling	F1
      1 Culture	Books
      1 Crosswords	Facebook
      1 Crossrails	2
      1 Cricket	Rugby
      1 Crewe	connecting
      1 Cookie	policy
      1 Contributions	Subscriptions
      1 Contribute	Search
      1 Contact	us
      1 Complaints	corrections
      1 Comments	replies
      1 Columnists	Cartoons
      1 Codes	UK
      1 Codes	The
      1 Codes	Support
      1 Close	p
      1 Classical	Stage
      1 Cities	Global
      1 Chilterns	in
      1 Cartoons	Opinion
      1 Camden	and
      1 But	he
      1 Business	Obituaries
      1 Britain	s
      1 Books	Music
      1 Birmingham	is
      1 Birmingham	and
      1 Barkham	Read
      1 BUTTON	unthreaded
      1 BUTTON	recommendations
      1 BUTTON	oldest
      1 BUTTON	newest
      1 BUTTON	expanded
      1 BUTTON	collapsed
      1 BUTTON	View
      1 BUTTON	Threads
      1 BUTTON	Sport
      1 BUTTON	Show
      1 BUTTON	Search
      1 BUTTON	Order
      1 BUTTON	Opinion
      1 BUTTON	News
      1 BUTTON	More
      1 BUTTON	Lifestyle
      1 BUTTON	International
      1 BUTTON	Culture
      1 BUTTON	Close
      1 BUTTON	All
      1 BUTTON	50
      1 BUTTON	25
      1 BUTTON	100
      1 Art	design
      1 Angela	Eagle
      1 Anderson	conceded
      1 Anderson	and
      1 Anderson	added
      1 Anderson	Profits
      1 All	writers
      1 All	topics
      1 All	rights
      1 All	BUTTON
      1 Advertise	with
      1 Account	details
      1 A	spokesperson
      1 A	detailed
      1 7	Mar
      1 6035250	cv
      1 55bn	railway
      1 50	BUTTON
      1 45	GMT
      1 3bn	and
      1 3	or
      1 2bn	towards
      1 2bn	to
      1 2bn	coming
      1 2CUK	news
      1 2CTransport	2CNorth
      1 2CR	ail
      1 2CNorth	of
      1 2CLiverpool	2CUK
      1 2CGeorge	Osborne
      1 23	Feb
      1 2033	is
      1 2026	and
      1 2020	Guardian
      1 2019	19
      1 2016	making
      1 2016	00
      1 20	mile
      1 2	c2
      1 2	3
      1 2	0
      1 19	45
      1 100	BUTTON
      1 10	in
      1 1	comscorekw
      1 01	GMT
      1 00	01
      1 0	cj