24 sender isSelf 18 ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ 15 Independent Premium 12 sender name 12 posVotes BUTTON 12 name dateTime 12 isSelf Delete 12 isSelf BUTTON 12 dateTime commentText 12 Delete sender 12 BUTTON posVotes 12 BUTTON negVotes 10 of the 8 replies sender 8 negVotes replies 8 comments comments 8 commentText Reply 8 Reply sender 8 BUTTON Submit 8 BUTTON Cancel 7 to the 7 must be 7 ____________________ BUTTON 6 try again 6 to join 6 the project 6 the name 6 the debate 6 name to 6 name must 6 join the 6 has been 6 debate ____________________ 6 commenting name 6 be unique 6 again the 6 a commenting 6 ____________________________________________________________ BUTTON 6 Submit Please 6 Please try 6 Log in 6 Create a 6 Cancel BUTTON 6 BUTTON Subscribe 6 BUTTON Post 5 your thoughts 5 to be 5 the first 5 in the 5 email address 5 Please enter 4 you want 4 you sure 4 yet be 4 want to 4 unique ____________________________________________________________ 4 to add 4 to Independent 4 thoughts comments 4 this comment 4 the railway 4 sure you 4 replies replies 4 replies comments 4 our Community 4 other users 4 negVotes Create 4 it is 4 first to 4 cost of 4 comments yet 4 comments sender 4 comments There 4 commentText sender 4 comment has 4 be the 4 are no 4 add your 4 This comment 4 There are 4 Street Porter 4 Post BUTTON 4 Politics Brexit 4 Matthew Norman 4 Mary Dejevsky 4 London to 4 Loading comments 4 Jenny Éclair 4 Janet Street 4 HS2 Ltd 4 Community Guidelines 4 Are you 3 your Independent 3 will be 3 white elephant 3 vote BUTTON 3 up to 3 to run 3 to delete 3 to Birmingham 3 the same 3 the private 3 the cost 3 the big 3 registered Log 3 project s 3 private sector 3 on HS2 3 of public 3 is understood 3 is not 3 is a 3 in 2026 3 higher than 3 enter a 3 due to 3 debate the 3 costs of 3 continue to 3 big issues 3 beauty Food 3 and the 3 a valid 3 a third 3 You can 3 US Politics 3 UK Edition 3 Subscribe to 3 Subscribe Now 3 Subscribe Already 3 Read more 3 Premium comments 3 Please wait 3 News UK 3 High Speed 3 HS2 will 3 HS2 train 3 Food drink 3 Fashion beauty 3 Comment Are 3 Already registered 3 2011 prices 2 Éclair Matthew 2 Éclair 20 2 your social 2 your email 2 would be 2 worth it 2 without notification 2 with our 2 will have 2 will continue 2 which could 2 when making 2 was forecast 2 views or 2 value_p Independent 2 value open 2 valid email 2 users without 2 users or 2 users but 2 union Cricket 2 train due 2 today BUTTON 2 to your 2 to vote 2 to them 2 to submit 2 to start 2 to our 2 to mark 2 to debate 2 to bookmark 2 this article 2 third parties 2 third higher 2 them respectfully 2 the right 2 the new 2 the discussion 2 the costs 2 the London 2 the High 2 that the 2 than previously 2 team behind 2 subscription today 2 start running 2 sports Culture 2 spokesman for 2 spent on 2 source added 2 singleComment_p value_p 2 singleComment_open value 2 showMore_p BUTTON 2 sexism homophobia 2 s impression 2 running in 2 right to 2 reveal private 2 respond to 2 respectfully Swearing 2 respectful when 2 reserve the 2 really worth 2 real world 2 railway s 2 rail link 2 radio Books 2 racism sexism 2 public money 2 proposed new 2 private information 2 previously estimated 2 posts and 2 please respond 2 personal abuse 2 parties We 2 our views 2 other discriminatory 2 or reveal 2 or other 2 or inciteful 2 offending users 2 of this 2 of an 2 o Tech 2 notification You 2 not impersonate 2 not agree 2 not acceptable 2 no comments 2 no Independent 2 newsletter preferences 2 new railway 2 near Parliament 2 more than 2 may not 2 mark this 2 making a 2 logged in 2 link was 2 line father 2 likely to 2 leg of 2 language is 2 is invalid 2 information about 2 inciteful language 2 inappropriate posts 2 inappropriate BUTTON 2 in to 2 in full 2 in BUTTON 2 in 2010 2 impression of 2 impersonate other 2 homophobia and 2 have to 2 have been 2 full here 2 forecast at 2 flagged BUTTON 2 first phase 2 first Oldest 2 first Most 2 find our 2 father near 2 enter an 2 discussion BUTTON 2 discuss real 2 discriminatory or 2 demonstrating against 2 delete inappropriate 2 dance Streaming 2 comments on 2 comments Loading 2 comment as 2 comment and 2 comment This 2 comment BUTTON 2 can find 2 but please 2 boohoo Premium 2 been flagged 2 been deleted 2 be sold 2 be respectful 2 ban offending 2 at HS2 2 at 21 2 at 2011 2 as the 2 as inappropriate 2 artist s 2 are not 2 approaching 30bn 2 and other 2 and ban 2 and adhere 2 an email 2 an HS2 2 agree with 2 against the 2 adhere to 2 address is 2 address Please 2 account of 2 acceptable Do 2 abuse racism 2 about third 2 a comment 2 ____________________ Please 2 You may 2 World US 2 We reserve 2 Want to 2 Voices Editorials 2 US sports 2 US Edition 2 UK World 2 UK Politics 2 Trust boohoo 2 Travelodge National 2 Tom Peck 2 Theatre dance 2 The source 2 The Independent 2 Tennis Cycling 2 Tech Science 2 Tech Money 2 TV radio 2 TUI Groupon 2 Swearing personal 2 Streaming Hub 2 Stop HS2 2 Steel Janet 2 Start your 2 Sport Football 2 Shappi Khorsandi 2 Sean O 2 Science Education 2 SNP Green 2 Rugby union 2 Robert Fisk 2 Report Comment 2 Rentoul Jenny 2 Protesters demonstrating 2 Premium to 2 Premium subscription 2 Premium app 2 Post replies 2 Porter Mary 2 Porter Chuka 2 Politics Voices 2 Podcast US 2 Please be 2 Photography Theatre 2 Peck Sport 2 Party DUP 2 Parliament Getty 2 Open Comments 2 Oldest first 2 O Grady 2 Norman Sean 2 Norman Jenny 2 Nike Travelodge 2 Newest first 2 National Trust 2 Music TV 2 Most liked 2 Miguel Delaney 2 McRae Janet 2 Mark Steel 2 Macnab Clarisse 2 Loughrey Ed 2 Lib Dems 2 Labour Lib 2 Kids Books 2 Khorsandi Mary 2 Just Eat 2 Join the 2 Johnson Jeremy 2 John Rentoul 2 Jeremy Corbyn 2 It is 2 IndyBest Christmas 2 Hyperoptic Just 2 Hub Geoffrey 2 Health fitness 2 Health Business 2 Hamish McRae 2 HS2 was 2 HS2 s 2 HS2 rail 2 HS2 is 2 Guidelines in 2 Guidelines You 2 Groupon Argos 2 Green Party 2 Grady Tom 2 Golf Miguel 2 Getty Images 2 Geoffrey Macnab 2 Football Rugby 2 Flag comment 2 Fisk Mark 2 Film Music 2 F1 Boxing 2 Environment Health 2 Enter your 2 Email address 2 Education Environment 2 Editorials Shappi 2 Edition US 2 Ed Cumming 2 Eat Currys 2 Do not 2 Dems SNP 2 Delaney Podcast 2 Dejevsky Robert 2 Dejevsky Matthew 2 DUP Boris 2 Cycling Golf 2 Currys Nike 2 Cumming Crosswords 2 Culture Film 2 Crosswords puzzles 2 Cricket F1 2 Corbyn US 2 Conservatives Labour 2 Comments Join 2 Clarisse Loughrey 2 Chris Blackhurst 2 Business InFact 2 Brexit Tech 2 Brexit Conservatives 2 Boxing Tennis 2 Boris Johnson 2 Books Art 2 Blackhurst Hamish 2 Birmingham leg 2 BUTTON replies 2 BUTTON Report 2 BUTTON Read 2 BUTTON Please 2 BUTTON Flag 2 BUTTON Delete 2 BUTTON Continue 2 BUTTON BUTTON 2 Art Photography 2 Argos Hyperoptic 2 An artist 2 A spokesman 2 21 4bn 2 20 Pledges 1 your password 1 your newsletter 1 your inbox 1 your favourite 1 your comment 1 your bookmarks 1 years as 1 year A 1 www googletagmanager 1 wrong increasing 1 would like 1 world solutions 1 world problems 1 working on 1 worked on 1 with your 1 with trains 1 with The 1 with Sketch 1 will ultimately 1 will try 1 will provide 1 will end 1 will carve 1 wider UK 1 whose constituencies 1 who knows 1 who has 1 who do 1 which will 1 which simply 1 which partly 1 which links 1 which is 1 whether it 1 where the 1 when they 1 when the 1 when someone 1 when it 1 what will 1 we have 1 we are 1 was really 1 was first 1 was at 1 wait UK 1 wait News 1 wait Log 1 vote against 1 videos title 1 vanity project 1 value_total moreThan3_total 1 valid password 1 using your 1 use of 1 us Jobs 1 updates on 1 updated costs 1 update your 1 up plans 1 up from 1 up costing 1 up by 1 up A 1 until 2040 1 unique nickname 1 unique Only 1 unip en 1 understood to 1 understood there 1 understood that 1 under pressure 1 under my 1 ultimately be 1 two link 1 twenties of 1 turn cost 1 try to 1 true meeting 1 transport projects 1 transfers Health 1 trains not 1 trains and 1 train rail 1 touch Contact 1 total comments 1 topics Voucher 1 to update 1 to three 1 to take 1 to spiral 1 to respond 1 to respect 1 to reflect 1 to receive 1 to read 1 to make 1 to log 1 to invent 1 to have 1 to give 1 to follow 1 to flog 1 to find 1 to exist 1 to discuss 1 to curb 1 to create 1 to build 1 to axe 1 to Leeds 1 to 80bn 1 to 250mph 1 title Sponsored 1 title Popular 1 title BUTTON 1 time as 1 through the 1 three separate 1 threads will 1 threads when 1 thoughts and 1 those who 1 this white 1 this was 1 this vote 1 this to 1 this month 1 this message 1 this is 1 this field 1 this area 1 third 1 1 they can 1 they are 1 there to 1 there have 1 there has 1 their own 1 the wider 1 the trains 1 the threads 1 the spending 1 the sheer 1 the second 1 the rising 1 the revised 1 the price 1 the phase 1 the out 1 the most 1 the journalists 1 the interests 1 the huge 1 the high 1 the headlines 1 the general 1 the full 1 the floor 1 the fact 1 the entire 1 the country 1 the content 1 the budget 1 the books 1 the amount 1 the Treasury 1 the Stop 1 the Ontario 1 the House 1 the HS2 1 the English 1 the Comprehensive 1 the Channel 1 the 2030s 1 the 2020s 1 that since 1 that plays 1 that means 1 that it 1 that every 1 that HS2 1 than the 1 than a 1 than 5bn 1 tests Experts 1 takes account 1 take account 1 tag It 1 t there 1 t show 1 surprised at 1 supporters argue 1 sums wrong 1 suggested which 1 subscribing errorMessage 1 subscribe to 1 submit updated 1 submit this 1 subjects will 1 story not 1 stories to 1 starts carrying 1 staff This 1 staff Labour 1 squeezed during 1 spokesman said 1 spiral A 1 spent at 1 spending review 1 spending cuts 1 speeds of 1 speculation around 1 sources believe 1 source who 1 source suggested 1 someone replies 1 some of 1 some informal 1 solutions and 1 sold to 1 sold in 1 social network 1 social account 1 soaring costs 1 skilled engineering 1 singleComment_p singleComment_p 1 singleComment_p BUTTON 1 singleComment_open singleComment_open 1 singleComment_open Open 1 since HS2 1 simply aren 1 shows this 1 showMore Minds 1 showMore BUTTON 1 show that 1 show me 1 shortly after 1 shortages of 1 shortHeadline Most 1 sheer scale 1 share their 1 serious questions 1 separate concessions 1 see foreign 1 sector to 1 sector staff 1 sector in 1 sector at 1 section under 1 second phase 1 scheme Independent 1 scale of 1 same time 1 same level 1 same amount 1 said that 1 said These 1 said HS2 1 s use 1 s supporters 1 s proposed 1 s massive 1 s going 1 s first 1 s costs 1 s construction 1 s budget 1 s boost 1 runs in 1 run the 1 run it 1 run for 1 run HS1 1 route to 1 roads or 1 rising cost 1 revised cost 1 review delayed 1 review More 1 responsible chancellor 1 respond by 1 respect all 1 replies to 1 relationships Health 1 reflect better 1 reference later 1 recoup some 1 receiveBrexit_______ I 1 receive updates 1 real prices 1 reads Politics 1 readers to 1 read or 1 reaches the 1 ratchet up 1 railway including 1 railway and 1 railway a 1 railway Inside 1 railway High 1 rail will 1 rail line 1 questions about 1 puzzles Video 1 puzzles Indy 1 published daily 1 publications Evening 1 public sector 1 provide 2 1 proved the 1 protected department 1 projects will 1 project the 1 project might 1 project management 1 project is 1 project develops 1 project They 1 project HS2 1 profile Don 1 products Subscriptions 1 problems be 1 prices when 1 prices it 1 prices The 1 prices An 1 price tag 1 price estimate 1 pressure from 1 preserved this 1 preferences Register 1 preferences Industry 1 posted by 1 post the 1 popular title 1 politics every 1 politics and 1 politics Show 1 policy Privacy 1 policies unip 1 plays down 1 plans to 1 planning assumption 1 phase two 1 phase to 1 phase starts 1 phase one 1 phase is 1 people working 1 pension funds 1 password Want 1 password Keep 1 passengers at 1 partly explains 1 palatable at 1 paid 2 1 page_view BUTTON 1 ownership which 1 own experiences 1 over runs 1 over fears 1 over another 1 outdoors Fashion 1 outcomes of 1 out turn 1 out this 1 our most 1 our membership 1 our apps 1 other transport 1 or reference 1 or rail 1 or outcomes 1 or click 1 open debate 1 open comments 1 open comment 1 one s 1 on this 1 on the 1 on speculation 1 on politics 1 on future 1 on all 1 on Brexit 1 offers Independent 1 offers Hi 1 off the 1 of which 1 of up 1 of proposed 1 of our 1 of open 1 of inflation 1 of independent 1 of economic 1 of construction 1 of conduct 1 of building 1 of billions 1 of benefit 1 of attention 1 of London 1 of HS2 1 of Commons 1 of Britain 1 o iPhone 1 o Gaming 1 o Cryptocurrency 1 numbers accepted 1 ns html 1 now approaching 1 now Login 1 now Known 1 notice User 1 nothing more 1 not subscribe 1 not shows 1 not mean 1 not just 1 not due 1 not able 1 not a 1 nickname ____________________________________________________________ 1 nickname Create 1 next year 1 newsletter The 1 news on 1 news o 1 new price 1 new estimate 1 new comments 1 new Indpendent 1 network account 1 near doubling 1 my profile 1 much longer 1 most insightful 1 most engaging 1 most engaged 1 morning by 1 moreThanTen total 1 moreThanTen Protesters 1 moreThanOne_p Newest 1 moreThanOne_p Loading 1 moreThanOne Newest 1 moreThanOne Loading 1 moreThan3_total value_total 1 moreThan3_total comments 1 more showMore_p 1 more showMore 1 more palatable 1 more Our 1 more HS2 1 more BUTTON 1 month Previously 1 money spent 1 money being 1 might fail 1 message again 1 message ____________________ 1 membership scheme 1 members of 1 meeting of 1 measurements of 1 means roads 1 means other 1 mean the 1 me this 1 me logged 1 materials and 1 massive cost 1 many people 1 management staff 1 make HS2 1 look more 1 longer line 1 logical planning 1 log in 1 located along 1 links London 1 link from 1 link UK 1 link The 1 lining up 1 line and 1 liked moreThanOne_p 1 liked moreThanOne 1 like to 1 life Travel 1 level of 1 letters and 1 latest news 1 later this 1 later Start 1 lasting around 1 knows where 1 just the 1 journalists will 1 journalists Start 1 joining the 1 its sums 1 it will 1 it takes 1 it shortly 1 it reaches 1 it off 1 it investors 1 it had 1 it but 1 it The 1 issues share 1 issues Want 1 issues Learn 1 is the 1 is really 1 is now 1 is nothing 1 is likely 1 is higher 1 is designed 1 is cooking 1 is completed 1 is being 1 is approaching 1 involved in 1 investors would 1 invent benefits 1 invalid Fill 1 invalid Email 1 interests of 1 insurance Money 1 instead Mr 1 insightful comments 1 informal discussions 1 inflation which 1 inflation is 1 inflated by 1 indy100 Vouchers 1 indy100 Voucher 1 independent Premium 1 increasing phase 1 increased because 1 increase in 1 including the 1 inbox ____________________ 1 in your 1 in using 1 in up 1 in touch 1 in shortHeadline 1 in receiveBrexit_______ 1 in directly 1 in dedicated 1 in concessions 1 in Article 1 in 2013 1 in 2011 1 if HS2 1 id GTM 1 iPhone o 1 huge increase 1 https www 1 html id 1 home Motoring 1 hit by 1 high twenties 1 here to 1 here nickname 1 here Create 1 help recoup 1 hear from 1 headlines BUTTON 1 have preserved 1 has worked 1 has increased 1 has also 1 has already 1 happened at 1 had got 1 guide Syndication 1 got its 1 googletagmanager com 1 going to 1 give each 1 general RPI 1 garden Kids 1 future ownership 1 furious at 1 funds Borealis 1 fullName My 1 full story 1 from the 1 from spending 1 from Conservative 1 from Birmingham 1 from 50bn 1 free experience 1 fraction of 1 foreign companies 1 for those 1 for the 1 for subscribing 1 for over 1 for Transport 1 for HS2 1 follow new 1 floor of 1 flogged to 1 flog it 1 fitness Tech 1 fitness Long 1 fitness Dating 1 first announced 1 find 25bn 1 figures show 1 figure is 1 field Email 1 features title 1 fears team 1 favourite articles 1 fail tests 1 fact they 1 fact that 1 explains the 1 experiences discuss 1 experience Subscribe 1 exists Log 1 existing Open 1 exist for 1 every morning 1 every 1 1 estimated The 1 estimated Exclusive 1 estimate that 1 estimate proved 1 estimate is 1 errorMessage BUTTON 1 entire railway 1 engineering and 1 engaging discussions 1 engaged readers 1 ends up 1 end up 1 en page_view 1 emailed when 1 email to 1 email Update 1 elephant will 1 elephant as 1 elephant Ministers 1 economy and 1 economic changes 1 each post 1 during the 1 dubbed white 1 drink Tech 1 drink Health 1 drink Dating 1 drawing up 1 down the 1 doubling of 1 does not 1 do not 1 discussions at 1 discussions and 1 directly with 1 direct to 1 develops The 1 details Help 1 designed to 1 department from 1 deleted This 1 deleted BUTTON 1 delete this 1 delayed over 1 dedicated articles 1 decade who 1 debates BUTTON 1 debate Please 1 daily in 1 cuts Somebody 1 cut The 1 curb soaring 1 culture o 1 create constructive 1 create a 1 countryside HS2 1 country But 1 could see 1 could help 1 could be 1 costs ratchet 1 costs means 1 costs and 1 costing around 1 cost over 1 cost it 1 cost does 1 cost Read 1 cost If 1 cooking the 1 content or 1 constructive debates 1 construction which 1 construction when 1 construction inflation 1 constituencies are 1 conservative estimate 1 conduct and 1 concessions lasting 1 concessions another 1 completed in 1 complaints Contributors 1 companies run 1 community we 1 comments singleComment_p 1 comments singleComment_open 1 comments showMore_p 1 comments showMore 1 comments moreThanTen 1 comments Enter 1 comments Comments 1 commenting Independent 1 commenters and 1 comment singleComment_p 1 comment singleComment_open 1 comment on 1 comment community 1 comment The 1 comment Deleting 1 com ns 1 codes Advertising 1 click here 1 claimed that 1 choose to 1 changes as 1 chancellor would 1 centre Logout 1 carve through 1 carrying passengers 1 cannot comment 1 can to 1 can be 1 can also 1 campaigners are 1 campaign said 1 by shortages 1 by more 1 by members 1 by joining 1 by email 1 by cost 1 by a 1 but we 1 but this 1 but instead 1 building materials 1 build it 1 budget has 1 budget alone 1 both the 1 boost to 1 books to 1 bookmarks in 1 bookmarked Find 1 bookmark your 1 bookmark this 1 billions Download 1 bill authorising 1 beyond direct 1 better what 1 benefits which 1 benefit to 1 believe this 1 believe HS2 1 being spent 1 being inflated 1 behind the 1 behind project 1 been spent 1 been some 1 been hit 1 been asked 1 been a 1 because it 1 be squeezed 1 be published 1 be posted 1 be logged 1 be lining 1 be involved 1 be in 1 be flogged 1 be emailed 1 be cut 1 be asking 1 be a 1 be 70bn 1 backbenchers whose 1 axe the 1 authorising HS2 1 attention but 1 at the 1 at speeds 1 at real 1 at both 1 at a 1 at HS1 1 assumption that 1 asking serious 1 asked to 1 as happened 1 as drawing 1 as costs 1 articles and 1 articles You 1 article ____________________ 1 article Want 1 around the 1 around 75bn 1 around 30 1 argue the 1 aren t 1 area in 1 are located 1 are likely 1 are furious 1 are already 1 apps Archive 1 app Sharing 1 app Daily 1 app Chris 1 anti HS2 1 another source 1 another decade 1 announced in 1 and with 1 and that 1 and stories 1 and skilled 1 and project 1 and numbers 1 and more 1 and many 1 and hear 1 and debate 1 and create 1 and could 1 and complaints 1 and beyond 1 and Manchester 1 and CPI 1 an ad 1 amount of 1 amount adjusted 1 also claimed 1 also choose 1 already under 1 already exists 1 already been 1 along the 1 alone by 1 allows our 1 all subjects 1 all commenters 1 ahead of 1 against a 1 again Get 1 after the 1 admitted it 1 adjusted to 1 address ____________________ 1 address Email 1 address BUTTON 1 added the 1 added it 1 added The 1 ad free 1 account or 1 account OR 1 accepted ____________________________________________________________ 1 about whether 1 about HS2 1 able to 1 a white 1 a vanity 1 a true 1 a protected 1 a near 1 a much 1 a logical 1 a fraction 1 a conservative 1 a bill 1 ____________________ Enter 1 You must 1 Women Video 1 Women Fashion 1 Want an 1 Vouchers TUI 1 Voucher codes 1 Voucher Codes 1 Vote Are 1 View offers 1 Video IndyBest 1 Video Indy 1 User policies 1 Update newsletter 1 Umunna John 1 Ummuna John 1 US UK 1 UK politics 1 UK economy 1 UK UK 1 Two HS2 1 Two Canadian 1 Tunnel Two 1 Treasury ahead 1 Travel outdoors 1 Travel Women 1 Travel Outdoors 1 Travel Fashion 1 Transport DfT 1 This figure 1 This construction 1 They are 1 These figures 1 The team 1 The project 1 The new 1 The most 1 The link 1 The latest 1 The fact 1 The existing 1 The cost 1 The Stop 1 The DfT 1 The Department 1 Thanks for 1 Tech o 1 Tech news 1 Tech culture 1 Tech Sports 1 Teachers Pension 1 Syndication Legal 1 Subscriptions Install 1 Subscription offers 1 Subscribe now 1 Subscribe Thanks 1 Submit vote 1 Submit Forgotten 1 Standard Novaya 1 Sports fitness 1 Sports Fitness 1 Sponsored features 1 Spending Review 1 Speed Two 1 Speed 2rail 1 Speed 2 1 Somebody s 1 Sketch HS2 1 Show moreThan3_total 1 Sharing the 1 Share your 1 Savings Pensions 1 Saturday 14 1 Review CSR 1 Relationships Tech 1 Register with 1 Reads indy100 1 RPI and 1 Privacy notice 1 Previously the 1 Premium section 1 Premium comment 1 Premium View 1 Premium The 1 Premium Subscription 1 Premium It 1 Premium Due 1 Premium Comments 1 Premium Chris 1 Premium Account 1 Popular videos 1 Politics newsletter 1 Politics HS2 1 Political Editor 1 Pledges UK 1 Pledges Please 1 Please continue 1 Plan paid 1 Pensions Money 1 Pension Plan 1 Outdoors Tech 1 Our products 1 Our journalists 1 Other publications 1 Osborne is 1 Ontario Teachers 1 Only letters 1 OR Log 1 Now Subscribe 1 Now News 1 Now Login 1 November 2015 1 Novaya Gazeta 1 N9RMBBF Subscribe 1 My Independent 1 Mr Osborne 1 Motoring Women 1 Motoring IndyBest 1 Most popular 1 Mortgages Loans 1 More about 1 Money transfers 1 Money Mortgages 1 Money Design 1 Money Deals 1 Ministers are 1 Minds Comments 1 Mark Leftly 1 Manchester is 1 MLeftly Saturday 1 Ltd on 1 Ltd has 1 Ltd cannot 1 Ltd admitted 1 Long reads 1 Long Reads 1 Logout BUTTON 1 Login Subscribe 1 Login Please 1 Loans Savings 1 Life Travel 1 Legal Code 1 Leftly Deputy 1 Leeds and 1 Learn more 1 Labour to 1 Known as 1 Keep me 1 Jobs Our 1 It allows 1 Install our 1 Inside Politics 1 Infrastructure and 1 Indy life 1 Indy Life 1 Industry sources 1 Indpendent Premium 1 Independent message 1 Independent commenting 1 InFact Politics 1 InFact Long 1 Images The 1 Images 2 1 If HS2 1 IFRAME https 1 I would 1 House of 1 Home garden 1 Home Garden 1 Hi fullName 1 Help centre 1 Health insurance 1 HS2 spokesman 1 HS2 said 1 HS2 route 1 HS2 review 1 HS2 look 1 HS2 has 1 HS2 ends 1 HS2 dubbed 1 HS2 campaigners 1 HS2 campaign 1 HS2 believe 1 HS2 added 1 HS2 Cost 1 HS1 which 1 HS1 until 1 Get in 1 Gazeta Extras 1 Garden Kids 1 Gaming o 1 GTM N9RMBBF 1 Forgotten your 1 Food Drink 1 Follow comments 1 Fitness Home 1 Find your 1 Fill out 1 Fashion Beauty 1 Extras All 1 Experts surprised 1 Exclusive The 1 Evening Standard 1 English countryside 1 Email already 1 Editor MLeftly 1 Edition app 1 Edition UK 1 Edition Subscribe 1 Edition Please 1 Due to 1 Drink Travel 1 Download the 1 Download now 1 Don t 1 DfT is 1 DfT has 1 Design home 1 Deputy Political 1 Department for 1 Deleting comment 1 Delete comment 1 Delete Comment 1 Deals indy100 1 Dating relationships 1 Dating Relationships 1 Daily Edition 1 Cryptocurrency Motoring 1 Created with 1 Cost of 1 Cookie policy 1 Contributors Cookie 1 Continue Please 1 Continue BUTTON 1 Contact us 1 Conservative backbenchers 1 Comprehensive Spending 1 Commons next 1 Comments threads 1 Comments can 1 Comments Share 1 Codes TUI 1 Code of 1 Chuka Umunna 1 Chuka Ummuna 1 Christmas Sports 1 Christmas Home 1 Channel Tunnel 1 Cancel You 1 Cancel This 1 Canadian pension 1 CSR later 1 CPI measurements 1 But anti 1 Britain s 1 Brexit politics 1 Borealis Infrastructure 1 Books Travel 1 Books Fashion 1 Birmingham to 1 Birmingham link 1 Beauty Food 1 BUTTON singleComment_p 1 BUTTON singleComment_open 1 BUTTON moreThanOne_p 1 BUTTON moreThanOne 1 BUTTON Vote 1 BUTTON News 1 BUTTON Follow 1 BUTTON Download 1 BUTTON Created 1 BUTTON About 1 Article bookmarked 1 Archive Other 1 All topics 1 Advertising guide 1 Account details 1 About The 1 A source 1 A responsible 1 80bn up 1 75bn and 1 70bn to 1 5bn A 1 50bn in 1 4bn but 1 4bn at 1 30bn a 1 30bn Mark 1 30 years 1 30 moreThanTen 1 2rail line 1 25bn if 1 250mph in 1 22 30 1 2040 HS2 1 2030s It 1 2026 This 1 2026 The 1 2026 1 2020s The 1 2015 22 1 2013 HS2 1 2010 to 1 2010 there 1 2 of 1 2 Protesters 1 2 HS2 1 2 An 1 2 2 1 2 1bn 1 1bn in 1 14 November 1 1 of 1 1 2