24 sender isSelf 18 ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ 12 sender name 12 posVotes BUTTON 12 name dateTime 12 isSelf Delete 12 isSelf BUTTON 12 dateTime commentText 12 Independent Premium 12 Delete sender 12 BUTTON posVotes 12 BUTTON negVotes 8 replies sender 8 negVotes replies 8 comments comments 8 commentText Reply 8 Reply sender 8 BUTTON Submit 8 BUTTON Cancel 7 of the 7 must be 7 ____________________ BUTTON 6 try again 6 to join 6 the name 6 the debate 6 name to 6 name must 6 join the 6 debate ____________________ 6 commenting name 6 be unique 6 again the 6 a commenting 6 ____________________________________________________________ BUTTON 6 Submit Please 6 Please try 6 Create a 6 Cancel BUTTON 6 BUTTON Post 5 your thoughts 5 the first 5 email address 5 Please enter 5 Log in 5 I m 4 you want 4 you sure 4 yet be 4 want to 4 unique ____________________________________________________________ 4 to add 4 thoughts comments 4 this comment 4 sure you 4 replies replies 4 replies comments 4 our Community 4 other users 4 of HS2 4 negVotes Create 4 has been 4 first to 4 comments yet 4 comments sender 4 comments There 4 commentText sender 4 comment has 4 be the 4 are no 4 add your 4 a budget 4 This comment 4 There are 4 Street Porter 4 Post BUTTON 4 Politics Brexit 4 Matthew Norman 4 Mary Dejevsky 4 Loading comments 4 Jenny Éclair 4 Janet Street 4 Community Guidelines 4 BUTTON Subscribe 4 Are you 3 vote BUTTON 3 to delete 3 to be 3 to Independent 3 the big 3 the HS2 3 land and 3 got a 3 enter a 3 debate the 3 big issues 3 beauty Food 3 and the 3 a valid 3 You can 3 US Politics 3 UK Edition 3 Subscribe Now 3 Read more 3 Premium comments 3 Please wait 3 Food drink 3 Fashion beauty 3 Comment Are 2 Éclair Matthew 2 Éclair 20 2 your social 2 your email 2 worried about 2 without notification 2 with our 2 will be 2 when making 2 we ve 2 we can 2 views or 2 ve got 2 value_p Independent 2 value open 2 valid email 2 users without 2 users or 2 users but 2 union Cricket 2 to them 2 to the 2 to our 2 to mark 2 to debate 2 third parties 2 them respectfully 2 the right 2 the line 2 the discussion 2 stand by 2 stage of 2 sports Culture 2 singleComment_p value_p 2 singleComment_open value 2 showMore_p BUTTON 2 sexism homophobia 2 said he 2 s got 2 s chief 2 right to 2 reveal private 2 respond to 2 respectfully Swearing 2 respectful when 2 reserve the 2 registered Log 2 real world 2 radio Books 2 racism sexism 2 private information 2 posts and 2 please respond 2 personal abuse 2 parties We 2 overspending I 2 our views 2 other discriminatory 2 or reveal 2 or other 2 or inciteful 2 offending users 2 o Tech 2 notification You 2 not worried 2 not impersonate 2 not agree 2 not acceptable 2 no comments 2 no Independent 2 newsletter preferences 2 may not 2 mark this 2 making a 2 m not 2 m confident 2 logged in 2 language is 2 it s 2 is not 2 is invalid 2 information about 2 inciteful language 2 inappropriate posts 2 inappropriate BUTTON 2 in to 2 in the 2 in full 2 in BUTTON 2 in 2015 2 impersonate other 2 homophobia and 2 full here 2 for the 2 flagged BUTTON 2 first stage 2 first Oldest 2 first Most 2 find our 2 enter an 2 discussion BUTTON 2 discuss real 2 discriminatory or 2 delete inappropriate 2 dance Streaming 2 cost to 2 cost of 2 continue to 2 confident we 2 comments on 2 comments Loading 2 comment as 2 comment and 2 comment This 2 comment BUTTON 2 chief executive 2 chairman of 2 can stand 2 can find 2 by the 2 but please 2 budget we 2 boohoo Premium 2 between London 2 been flagged 2 been deleted 2 be respectful 2 ban offending 2 as inappropriate 2 and property 2 and other 2 and ban 2 and adhere 2 an email 2 along the 2 agree with 2 adhere to 2 address is 2 address Please 2 acceptable Do 2 abuse racism 2 about third 2 about overspending 2 a comment 2 ____________________ Please 2 You may 2 World US 2 We reserve 2 Voices Editorials 2 US sports 2 US Edition 2 UK World 2 Trust boohoo 2 Travelodge National 2 Tom Peck 2 Theatre dance 2 The first 2 The Independent 2 Terry Morgan 2 Tennis Cycling 2 Tech Science 2 Tech Money 2 TV radio 2 TUI Groupon 2 Swearing personal 2 Subscribe to 2 Subscribe Already 2 Streaming Hub 2 Steel Janet 2 Sport Football 2 Sir Terry 2 Shappi Khorsandi 2 Sean O 2 Science Education 2 SNP Green 2 Rugby union 2 Robert Fisk 2 Report Comment 2 Rentoul Jenny 2 Premium app 2 Post replies 2 Porter Mary 2 Porter Chuka 2 Politics Voices 2 Podcast US 2 Please be 2 Photography Theatre 2 Peck Sport 2 Party DUP 2 Open Comments 2 Oldest first 2 O Grady 2 Norman Sean 2 Norman Jenny 2 Nike Travelodge 2 News UK 2 Newest first 2 National Trust 2 Music TV 2 Most liked 2 Miguel Delaney 2 McRae Janet 2 Mark Steel 2 Macnab Clarisse 2 Loughrey Ed 2 Lib Dems 2 Labour Lib 2 Kids Books 2 Khorsandi Mary 2 Just Eat 2 Join the 2 Johnson Jeremy 2 John Rentoul 2 Jeremy Corbyn 2 IndyBest Christmas 2 Hyperoptic Just 2 Hub Geoffrey 2 Health fitness 2 Health Business 2 Hamish McRae 2 HS2 s 2 HS2 and 2 Guidelines in 2 Guidelines You 2 Groupon Argos 2 Green Party 2 Grady Tom 2 Golf Miguel 2 Geoffrey Macnab 2 Football Rugby 2 Flag comment 2 Fisk Mark 2 Film Music 2 F1 Boxing 2 Environment Health 2 Enter your 2 Email address 2 Education Environment 2 Editorials Shappi 2 Edition US 2 Ed Cumming 2 Eat Currys 2 Do not 2 Dems SNP 2 Delaney Podcast 2 Dejevsky Robert 2 Dejevsky Matthew 2 DUP Boris 2 Cycling Golf 2 Currys Nike 2 Cumming Crosswords 2 Culture Film 2 Crosswords puzzles 2 Cricket F1 2 Corbyn US 2 Conservatives Labour 2 Comments Join 2 Clarisse Loughrey 2 Chris Grayling 2 Chris Blackhurst 2 Business InFact 2 Brexit Tech 2 Brexit Conservatives 2 Boxing Tennis 2 Boris Johnson 2 Books Art 2 Blackhurst Hamish 2 BUTTON replies 2 BUTTON Report 2 BUTTON Read 2 BUTTON Please 2 BUTTON Flag 2 BUTTON Delete 2 BUTTON Continue 2 BUTTON BUTTON 2 Art Photography 2 Argos Hyperoptic 2 Already registered 2 20 Pledges 1 your password 1 your newsletter 1 your comment 1 your Independent 1 www googletagmanager 1 wrong Doug 1 would like 1 would have 1 would be 1 world solutions 1 world problems 1 within its 1 with your 1 with the 1 with that 1 with The 1 will try 1 will continue 1 whole 56bn 1 who was 1 who do 1 whistleblower says 1 which it 1 which is 1 where to 1 when they 1 when someone 1 what to 1 western branch 1 were used 1 were enormously 1 week calculated 1 we have 1 we are 1 was later 1 was chairman 1 was appalled 1 was 1 1 warned of 1 walked out 1 wait UK 1 wait News 1 wait Log 1 very clear 1 vastly underestimated 1 value_total moreThan3_total 1 value of 1 valid password 1 using your 1 used He 1 us Jobs 1 update your 1 up for 1 unique nickname 1 unique Only 1 unip en 1 underestimated whistleblower 1 underestimated the 1 under fresh 1 two is 1 try to 1 true meeting 1 troubled Crossrail 1 transport secretary 1 transfers Health 1 touch Contact 1 total comments 1 total bill 1 topics Voucher 1 told the 1 told Panorama 1 today BUTTON 1 to your 1 to vote 1 to update 1 to submit 1 to stay 1 to respond 1 to respect 1 to receive 1 to pay 1 to open 1 to log 1 to live 1 to know 1 to increase 1 to go 1 to give 1 to follow 1 to exist 1 to discuss 1 to create 1 to cost 1 to compensate 1 to acquire 1 to a 1 to Travel 1 to Manchester 1 to Birmingham 1 to 3 1 title Get 1 time and 1 threads will 1 threads when 1 thousands more 1 thoughts and 1 those who 1 this vote 1 this month 1 this field 1 this article 1 this area 1 they can 1 there will 1 their own 1 the whole 1 the western 1 the value 1 the troubled 1 the transport 1 the total 1 the threads 1 the sheer 1 the same 1 the route 1 the railway 1 the project 1 the programme 1 the potential 1 the north 1 the new 1 the net 1 the most 1 the loose 1 the journalists 1 the interests 1 the headlines 1 the full 1 the figures 1 the eastern 1 the cost 1 the construction 1 the company 1 the challenge 1 the biggest 1 the amount 1 the Midlands 1 the High 1 the East 1 that thousands 1 that the 1 that numbers 1 that needed 1 that early 1 that budget 1 tenants affected 1 talking of 1 swallowed up 1 subscription today 1 subscribing errorMessage 1 subscribe to 1 submit this 1 subjects will 1 story not 1 still not 1 stay on 1 square miles 1 speed rail 1 someone replies 1 solutions and 1 social network 1 social account 1 slapdash fashion 1 singleComment_p singleComment_p 1 singleComment_p BUTTON 1 singleComment_open singleComment_open 1 singleComment_open Open 1 sigh of 1 showMore Minds 1 showMore BUTTON 1 sheer scale 1 share their 1 shaped layout 1 seen anything 1 secretary Chris 1 scrutiny In 1 scheme The 1 scheme Independent 1 scale of 1 says I 1 same level 1 said the 1 said I 1 said HS2 1 s presenter 1 s current 1 route that 1 route is 1 route for 1 risen to 1 response the 1 respond by 1 respect all 1 resigns as 1 resigned He 1 requires 27 1 report the 1 report concluded 1 replies to 1 relief in 1 relationships Health 1 recent National 1 receiveIndyTravelNew I 1 receive news 1 reasonable basis 1 reads Politics 1 readers to 1 railways Chris 1 railway HS2 1 rail scheme 1 rail project 1 puzzles Video 1 puzzles Indy 1 puzzle the 1 purchased According 1 published daily 1 publications Evening 1 provides a 1 property to 1 property owners 1 property for 1 property director 1 properties had 1 properties along 1 project to 1 project resigned 1 project intended 1 project in 1 programme s 1 programme a 1 products Subscriptions 1 problems be 1 prices but 1 prices The 1 preserved this 1 presenter Justin 1 preferences Register 1 preferences Comments 1 potential cost 1 posted by 1 post the 1 possible cost 1 policy Privacy 1 policies unip 1 planned to 1 phase of 1 pay and 1 password Want 1 password Keep 1 page_view 1 owners and 1 own experiences 1 outdoors Fashion 1 out this 1 out of 1 our most 1 our membership 1 our apps 1 or click 1 open in 1 open debate 1 open comments 1 open comment 1 one Wednesday 1 on where 1 on time 1 on this 1 on budget 1 on all 1 on HS2 1 offers Independent 1 offers Hi 1 of this 1 of relief 1 of property 1 of properties 1 of possible 1 of our 1 of open 1 of independent 1 of conduct 1 of buying 1 of both 1 of attention 1 of England 1 of 27bn 1 o iPhone 1 o Gaming 1 o Cryptocurrency 1 numbers were 1 numbers accepted 1 ns html 1 now Login 1 now He 1 notice User 1 not subscribe 1 not known 1 not just 1 not been 1 not able 1 north of 1 north from 1 nickname ____________________________________________________________ 1 nickname Create 1 newsletter Time 1 news on 1 news o 1 new comments 1 new Indpendent 1 never seen 1 network account 1 net cost 1 needed to 1 most insightful 1 most engaging 1 most engaged 1 moreThanTen total 1 moreThanTen The 1 moreThanOne_p Newest 1 moreThanOne_p Loading 1 moreThanOne Newest 1 moreThanOne Loading 1 moreThan3_total value_total 1 moreThan3_total comments 1 more showMore_p 1 more showMore 1 more properties 1 more Sir 1 more Our 1 more BUTTON 1 month Sir 1 monitor the 1 miles of 1 message ____________________ 1 membership scheme 1 members of 1 meeting of 1 me logged 1 making the 1 m very 1 loose and 1 log in 1 live with 1 line from 1 line between 1 liked moreThanOne_p 1 liked moreThanOne 1 like to 1 like it 1 life Travel 1 level of 1 letters and 1 layout with 1 later dismissed 1 last week 1 known HS2 1 know every 1 just the 1 journalists will 1 journalists Start 1 joining the 1 its agreed 1 it had 1 it can 1 it Mr 1 issues share 1 issues ahead 1 issues Want 1 issues Learn 1 is within 1 is under 1 is the 1 is still 1 is planned 1 is due 1 involved in 1 invalid Fill 1 invalid Email 1 interests of 1 intended to 1 insurance Money 1 insightful comments 1 inside the 1 indy100 Vouchers 1 indy100 Voucher 1 industry expert 1 independent Premium 1 increase capacity 1 in using 1 in touch 1 in receiveIndyTravelNew 1 in directly 1 in dedicated 1 in Sponsored 1 in Europe 1 in 2026 1 in 2011 1 id GTM 1 iPhone o 1 https www 1 html id 1 home Motoring 1 high speed 1 here to 1 here nickname 1 here Create 1 hear from 1 headlines BUTTON 1 he was 1 he walked 1 have to 1 have preserved 1 have never 1 has claimed 1 has a 1 had risen 1 had not 1 guide Syndication 1 got to 1 googletagmanager com 1 going to 1 go and 1 give each 1 garden Kids 1 funding envelope 1 fullName My 1 full story 1 from which 1 from the 1 from London 1 from HM 1 from Birmingham 1 fresh scrutiny 1 free experience 1 former land 1 former HS2 1 for those 1 for subscribing 1 for at 1 for Stage 1 for HS2 1 follow new 1 fitness Tech 1 fitness Long 1 fitness Dating 1 first phase 1 figures underestimated 1 field Email 1 features title 1 fashion that 1 expert Michael 1 experiences discuss 1 experience Subscribe 1 exists Log 1 existing Open 1 exist for 1 executive has 1 executive Simon 1 executive Mark 1 every Saturday 1 evening and 1 estimates of 1 estimate of 1 estimate is 1 errorMessage BUTTON 1 envelope from 1 enormously wrong 1 engineering project 1 engaging discussions 1 engaged readers 1 en page_view 1 emailed when 1 email to 1 email Update 1 eastern branch 1 early estimates 1 each post 1 due to 1 drink Tech 1 drink Health 1 drink Dating 1 do not 1 dismissed by 1 discussions and 1 director said 1 directly with 1 details Help 1 deleted This 1 deleted BUTTON 1 delete this 1 dedicated articles 1 debates BUTTON 1 debate Please 1 daily in 1 current estimate 1 culture o 1 create constructive 1 create a 1 cost issues 1 cost 29bn 1 constructive debates 1 construction of 1 conduct and 1 concluded HS2 1 complaints Contributors 1 compensate property 1 company Read 1 community we 1 comments singleComment_p 1 comments singleComment_open 1 comments showMore_p 1 comments showMore 1 comments moreThanTen 1 comments INDY 1 comments Enter 1 commenting Independent 1 commenters and 1 comment singleComment_p 1 comment singleComment_open 1 comment community 1 comment The 1 comment Deleting 1 com ns 1 codes Advertising 1 click here 1 clear on 1 claimed that 1 civil engineering 1 choose to 1 challenge inside 1 centre Logout 1 capacity between 1 can to 1 can monitor 1 can be 1 can also 1 calculated that 1 by said 1 by members 1 by joining 1 by email 1 by Earlier 1 by 2017 1 buying land 1 but we 1 but by 1 buildings along 1 budgeted for 1 budget of 1 budget it 1 budget Proposed 1 budget More 1 breathed a 1 branch to 1 branch going 1 bought were 1 both HS2 1 bill 56bn 1 biggest civil 1 been budgeted 1 be swallowed 1 be purchased 1 be published 1 be posted 1 be logged 1 be involved 1 be emailed 1 be bought 1 be a 1 basis from 1 attention but 1 at the 1 at all 1 as chairman 1 articles You 1 article ____________________ 1 area in 1 are not 1 apps Archive 1 appalled at 1 app Sharing 1 app Daily 1 app Chris 1 anything like 1 and what 1 and that 1 and tenants 1 and slapdash 1 and provides 1 and on 1 and numbers 1 and more 1 and hear 1 and debate 1 and create 1 and complaints 1 and buildings 1 and breathed 1 and York 1 and Crossrail 1 and Birmingham 1 an industry 1 an ad 1 amount HS2 1 also choose 1 already exists 1 allows our 1 all subjects 1 all commenters 1 all Download 1 ahead for 1 agreed funding 1 affected by 1 address ____________________ 1 address Email 1 address BUTTON 1 ad free 1 acquire land 1 account or 1 account OR 1 accepted ____________________________________________________________ 1 about HS2 1 able to 1 a true 1 a sigh 1 a recent 1 a reasonable 1 a former 1 a Y 1 a BBC 1 ____________________ Enter 1 You must 1 York and 1 Y shaped 1 Women Video 1 Women Fashion 1 Wednesday evening 1 Want to 1 Want an 1 Vouchers TUI 1 Voucher codes 1 Voucher Codes 1 Vote Are 1 View offers 1 Video IndyBest 1 Video Indy 1 User policies 1 Update newsletter 1 Umunna John 1 Ummuna John 1 US UK 1 UK Politics 1 Treasury and 1 Travel outdoors 1 Travel ____________________ 1 Travel Women 1 Travel Outdoors 1 Travel Fashion 1 Travel Correspondent 1 Time to 1 Thurston told 1 Thornton said 1 Thornton former 1 The report 1 The most 1 The existing 1 The cost 1 Thanks for 1 Tech o 1 Tech news 1 Tech culture 1 Tech Sports 1 Syndication Legal 1 Subscriptions Install 1 Subscription offers 1 Subscribe now 1 Subscribe Thanks 1 Submit vote 1 Submit Forgotten 1 Street is 1 Start your 1 Standard Novaya 1 Stage two 1 Stage One 1 Sports fitness 1 Sports Fitness 1 Sponsored features 1 Speed 2 1 Simon Calder 1 Show moreThan3_total 1 Sharing the 1 Share your 1 Savings Pensions 1 Saturday by 1 Rowlatt I 1 Relationships Tech 1 Register with 1 Reads indy100 1 Proposed route 1 Property puzzle 1 Privacy notice 1 Premium to 1 Premium subscription 1 Premium comment 1 Premium View 1 Premium The 1 Premium Subscription 1 Premium It 1 Premium Due 1 Premium Comments 1 Premium Chris 1 Premium Account 1 Pledges UK 1 Pledges Please 1 Please continue 1 Pensions Money 1 Panorama programme 1 Panorama I 1 PA Costs 1 Outdoors Tech 1 Our products 1 Our journalists 1 Other publications 1 Only letters 1 One was 1 Office report 1 OR Log 1 Now Subscribe 1 Now News 1 Now Login 1 Novaya Gazeta 1 National Audit 1 N9RMBBF Subscribe 1 My Independent 1 Mr Thornton 1 Motoring Women 1 Motoring IndyBest 1 Mortgages Loans 1 Morgan who 1 Morgan resigns 1 More about 1 Money transfers 1 Money Mortgages 1 Money Design 1 Money Deals 1 Monday 17 1 Minds Comments 1 Midlands and 1 Midlands Leeds 1 Michael Byng 1 Mark Thurston 1 Manchester Stage 1 Ltd s 1 Long reads 1 Long Reads 1 London the 1 London and 1 London Euston 1 Logout BUTTON 1 Login Subscribe 1 Login Please 1 Loans Savings 1 Life Travel 1 Legal Code 1 Leeds and 1 Learn more 1 Keep me 1 Justin Rowlatt 1 Jobs Our 1 It has 1 It allows 1 Install our 1 Indy life 1 Indy Life 1 Indpendent Premium 1 Independent message 1 Independent commenting 1 InFact Politics 1 InFact Long 1 In response 1 In a 1 INDY GO 1 IFRAME https 1 I would 1 I have 1 Home garden 1 Home Garden 1 High Speed 1 Hi fullName 1 Help centre 1 Health insurance 1 He was 1 He warned 1 He told 1 He said 1 HS2 would 1 HS2 which 1 HS2 vastly 1 HS2 talking 1 HS2 route 1 HS2 railways 1 HS2 rail 1 HS2 one 1 HS2 it 1 HS2 high 1 HS2 executive 1 HS2 estimate 1 HS2 PA 1 HS2 Ltd 1 HM Treasury 1 Grayling said 1 Grayling Show 1 Going north 1 Get in 1 Gazeta Extras 1 Garden Kids 1 Gaming o 1 GTM N9RMBBF 1 GO newsletter 1 Forgotten your 1 Food Drink 1 Follow comments 1 Fitness Home 1 Fill out 1 Fashion Beauty 1 Extras All 1 Evening Standard 1 Euston to 1 Europe requires 1 England is 1 Email already 1 Edition app 1 Edition UK 1 Edition Subscribe 1 Edition Please 1 East Midlands 1 Earlier this 1 Due to 1 Drink Travel 1 Download the 1 Download now 1 Doug Thornton 1 Design home 1 Deleting comment 1 Delete comment 1 Delete Comment 1 December 2018 1 Deals indy100 1 Dating relationships 1 Dating Relationships 1 Daily Edition 1 Curzon Street 1 Cryptocurrency Motoring 1 Crossrail project 1 Crossrail The 1 Costs of 1 Correspondent Monday 1 Cookie policy 1 Contributors Cookie 1 Continue Please 1 Continue BUTTON 1 Contact us 1 Comments threads 1 Comments can 1 Comments Share 1 Codes TUI 1 Code of 1 Chuka Umunna 1 Chuka Ummuna 1 Christmas Sports 1 Christmas Home 1 Cancel You 1 Cancel This 1 Calder Travel 1 Byng last 1 But an 1 Books Travel 1 Books Fashion 1 Birmingham there 1 Birmingham In 1 Birmingham Curzon 1 Beauty Food 1 BUTTON singleComment_p 1 BUTTON singleComment_open 1 BUTTON moreThanOne_p 1 BUTTON moreThanOne 1 BUTTON Vote 1 BUTTON Property 1 BUTTON Follow 1 BUTTON Download 1 BUTTON About 1 BBC Panorama 1 Audit Office 1 Archive Other 1 All topics 1 Advertising guide 1 Account details 1 According to 1 About The 1 56bn would 1 56bn But 1 3bn in 1 39 moreThanTen 1 3 3bn 1 29bn making 1 27bn Going 1 27 square 1 2026 It 1 2018 19 1 2017 it 1 2015 prices 1 2015 He 1 2011 prices 1 2 HS2 1 19 39 1 17 December 1 12bn in 1 1 12bn