9 with a 9 The parameters 9 the model 9 simulation results 9 of sexual 9 N MP 9 N MD 9 N FD 9 N FC 9 individual variation 9 from the 9 as the 9 4 0 9 200 0 9 0 1 8 with the 8 the social 8 the same 8 the fitness 8 the baseline 8 social cohesion 8 public goods 8 period 5 8 of sexuality 8 N_ mathit 8 MP N 8 MP and 8 MD N 8 Journal of 8 fitness of 8 F C 8 and FC 7 to be 7 this simulation 7 the population 7 the evolutionary 7 the altruistic 7 simulation are 7 s 1 7 population size 7 of cooperators 7 four types 7 can be 7 baseline model 7 are the 7 a male 7 200 200 7 0 001 6 ω 0 6 μ 0 6 κ 1 6 Ι 1 6 δ 0 6 γ 0 6 β 1 6 α 0 6 this paper 6 the Punishment 6 Sexuality Game 6 same as 6 Punishment Sexuality 6 population of 6 of punishment 6 of I 6 N D 6 N C 6 N 400 6 mutation rate 6 is the 6 In the 6 in an 6 I I 6 d 0 6 constant population 6 by the 6 attractiveness The 6 al 2011 6 5 δ 6 5 γ 6 400 N 6 1 μ 6 1 β 6 1 α 6 1 s 6 001 d 5 Ye et 5 widetilde I 5 which is 5 where the 5 variation in 5 this section 5 the variable 5 the simulation 5 the role 5 The population 5 the offspring 5 the effect 5 society is 5 social dilemma 5 role of 5 robust test 5 represents the 5 probability of 5 parameters in 5 of variable 5 offspring is 5 of each 5 of a 5 MP MD 5 model the 5 mean value 5 mathit MP 5 males and 5 left 1 5 it is 5 In this 5 I into 5 Game with 5 Figure 1C 5 F D 5 FC N 5 effect of 5 each individual 5 due to 5 do not 5 and the 5 altruism in 5 6 s 54 of the 5 0 0 4 Ye s 4 whose I 4 we have 4 those in 4 the second 4 the robust 4 the punisher 4 the plots 4 theoretical biology 4 the number 4 the mean 4 the exception 4 the behaviour 4 that is 4 that altruism 4 surrey ac 4 strength of 4 soc surrey 4 Societies and 4 Social Simulation 4 s fitness 4 set to 4 results for 4 punishment is 4 proportion of 4 Proceedings of 4 population assumption 4 P_ mathit 4 parental care 4 parameters for 4 of theoretical 4 of sympathy 4 of social 4 of males 4 of cooperation 4 of Artificial 4 of an 4 number of 4 MP is 4 MD and 4 mathit FC 4 mate preference 4 k widetilde 4 jasss soc 4 is N 4 I right 4 invasion capacity 4 in a 4 I 0 4 http jasss 4 he will 4 has been 4 function of 4 for this 4 FD 100 4 FC FD 4 FC 0 4 existence of 4 exception of 4 e k 4 differences in 4 cooperators and 4 beta left 4 based on 4 attractiveness in 4 at a 4 as those 4 Artificial Societies 4 are N 4 and Social 4 and N 4 and FD 4 and F 4 and D 4 and attractiveness 4 an artificial 4 altruistic level 4 altruistic behaviour 4 altruism is 4 a female 4 ac uk 4 a cost 4 6 Ι 4 5000 0 4 4 ω 42 in the 4 200 5000 4 2000 200 4 1 e 4 1C with 4 0 period 4 0 N 3 without sexual 3 with no 3 with Different 3 will suffer 3 will be 3 where N 3 we employ 3 we assume 3 virtue of 3 Variable Size 3 types of 3 types in 3 type of 3 to test 3 to males 3 to as 3 to a 3 The timing 3 the strength 3 the simulations 3 the results 3 the punishment 3 the proportion 3 the previous 3 the invasion 3 the individual 3 the field 3 the existence 3 The evolution 3 the average 3 test the 3 Table 2 3 suggest that 3 strategies and 3 society with 3 Size Population 3 serves as 3 sense of 3 selection is 3 second order 3 regardless of 3 referred to 3 rate μ 3 puzzle of 3 Punishment and 3 prosocial behaviours 3 proportional to 3 population treatment 3 population models 3 plots of 3 order social 3 only males 3 of s 3 of London 3 of human 3 of fitness 3 of F 3 of both 3 of altruistic 3 of 0 3 no sexual 3 normal distribution 3 MP The 3 MP s 3 Moran process 3 model The 3 Miller 2007 3 MD is 3 MD FC 3 mating preference 3 males whose 3 male punishers 3 London B 3 is not 3 is an 3 in x 3 investing I 3 introduction of 3 into the 3 into altruism 3 in Table 3 in previous 3 individuals in 3 individual s 3 increase the 3 in biology 3 I is 3 if the 3 human society 3 Houchmandzadeh 2015 3 goods game 3 from MP 3 from males 3 form of 3 Finally we 3 Figure 7 3 Figure 5 3 Figure 1 3 field of 3 f I 3 FD is 3 FD 200 3 FC and 3 except for 3 evolutionary models 3 each type 3 distribution of 3 denotes the 3 D are 3 D 200 3 costly punishment 3 concept of 3 computer simulations 3 composed of 3 but it 3 benefit from 3 because the 3 be achieved 3 be a 3 Based on 3 attractiveness s 3 at period 3 as well 3 assumption of 3 assume that 3 assumed to 3 are not 3 and no 3 and females 3 analysis of 3 altruistic investment 3 altruistic evolution 3 altruism can 3 a costly 3 according to 3 2 2 3 200 κ 3 19 2 3 18564 jasss 3 10 18564 3 10 1016 3 100 κ 3 0 ω 3 0 s 2 μ which 2 γ δ 2 Zhejiang University 2 x right 2 with I 2 with 100 2 will punish 2 will favour 2 which will 2 where s 2 where f 2 we report 2 well as 2 We adopt 2 W D 2 various forms 2 variation and 2 University China 2 Treatments and 2 treatment of 2 Traulsen A 2 to MP 2 to model 2 to have 2 to cooperation 2 timing appears 2 Thus in 2 the virtue 2 the type 2 the turning 2 the sympathy 2 The strategies 2 the sense 2 the sake 2 the royal 2 The results 2 the puzzle 2 the period 2 The origins 2 the normal 2 the moral 2 the mate 2 the male 2 the majority 2 their genders 2 the investment 2 the introduction 2 the initial 2 the individuals 2 the hypothesis 2 the gender 2 the game 2 the four 2 the format 2 the extended 2 the emergence 2 the egoists 2 the driving 2 the distribution 2 the differences 2 the definition 2 the contribution 2 the benefit 2 the Baseline 2 the assumption 2 the analysis 2 that MP 2 that altruistic 2 than the 2 test on 2 Table 1 2 sympathy in 2 sum f 2 suffer from 2 such as 2 solve the 2 society will 2 society The 2 society of 2 society as 2 social norms 2 social equilibrium 2 s model 2 Smith E 2 simulations are 2 Simulation Results 2 simulation in 2 simplicity we 2 shows that 2 should be 2 shapes the 2 Sexual selection 2 sexual reproduction 2 sexually attractive 2 sexuality in 2 sexuality as 2 sexuality and 2 Sexual Attractiveness 2 settings in 2 selection in 2 selection can 2 selection and 2 Science 316 2 sake of 2 royal society 2 right mathit 2 right delta 2 review of 2 results in 2 resource limitations 2 report the 2 repeated computer 2 reciprocal altruism 2 reasonable to 2 quality and 2 Punishment without 2 punishment The 2 punishment on 2 punishment in 2 punishment from 2 punish individuals 2 punishers and 2 provide a 2 process of 2 process is 2 probability μ 2 previous sections 2 previous literatures 2 Preston 2013 2 present in 2 preference to 2 population payoff 2 population model 2 population has 2 population dynamics 2 population distribution 2 population and 2 plays the 2 periods The 2 penduline tits 2 paper we 2 paper is 2 own fitness 2 over parental 2 overlap with 2 overcome the 2 our model 2 Other articles 2 origins of 2 on this 2 one of 2 on each 2 on altruism 2 of γ 2 of virtue 2 of their 2 of punishers 2 of prosocial 2 of N 2 of MP 2 of morality 2 of mating 2 of male 2 of justice 2 of individuals 2 of individual 2 of high 2 of females 2 of FC 2 of economics 2 of death 2 of costly 2 of cooperative 2 of birth 2 of biology 2 of being 2 numerical simulation 2 Nowak M 2 not significant 2 Note that 2 note that 2 noted that 2 No punishment 2 no punishment 2 N is 2 nearly no 2 nearly every 2 MP N_ 2 more than 2 more cooperative 2 moral virtues 2 morality in 2 model where 2 models with 2 models in 2 models based 2 model of 2 model can 2 model and 2 might be 2 mechanism of 2 mean altruistic 2 McAndrew 2002 2 Mating Preference 2 mathit MD 2 mathit FD 2 mathit alpha 2 male with 2 male sum 2 males females 2 M A 2 limited resources 2 left N_ 2 lead to 2 leads to 2 Koella 2000 2 journal of 2 J C 2 J 2011 2 It should 2 is that 2 is set 2 is referred 2 is reasonable 2 is proportional 2 is identical 2 is designed 2 is composed 2 is assumed 2 is altruistic 2 is advantageous 2 In Ye 2 invest 1 2 in various 2 in turn 2 in simulation 2 In other 2 in MP 2 in models 2 initial population 2 Individual variation 2 individual in 2 increase in 2 in altruistic 2 in altruism 2 imply that 2 I male 2 I in 2 identical to 2 I ast 2 hypothesis is 2 human altruism 2 html doi 2 However the 2 Houchmandzadeh s 2 his probability 2 high altruistic 2 have been 2 Hauert et 2 has a 2 Hang Ye 2 Hamilton 1981 2 Hamilton 1964 2 GINTIS H 2 gender based 2 game of 2 from FC 2 For the 2 form for 2 format of 2 For each 2 For authors 2 F J 2 Figure 9 2 Figure 6 2 Figure 2 2 Figure 1A 2 female will 2 females The 2 females investing 2 females invest 2 females in 2 female cooperators 2 f e 2 FD are 2 FC is 2 FC in 2 FC are 2 favour males 2 e ωP 2 Extension to 2 extended models 2 explain the 2 Evolution of 2 evolutionary model 2 evolutionary equilibrium 2 e the 2 equilibrium where 2 employ the 2 e MP 2 emergence of 2 e g 2 effects of 2 each period 2 E A 2 dynamic evolutionary 2 driving force 2 dominance over 2 does not 2 distribution in 2 different treatments 2 difference between 2 designed to 2 delta N_ 2 definition of 2 defined in 2 c which 2 C Traulsen 2 C Punishment 2 cooperators who 2 cooperative society 2 cooperative punishment 2 cooperation Science 2 contribution of 2 conflict over 2 conducted by 2 computer simulation 2 cohesion can 2 care when 2 CAPTION Table 2 capacity of 2 can increase 2 can explain 2 by Hauert 2 B Punishment 2 BOYD R 2 both punishment 2 biology and 2 biological sciences 2 be noted 2 benefit the 2 benefits from 2 being an 2 being altruistic 2 behaviours of 2 behaviour based 2 B biological 2 Baseline Model 2 based sexual 2 B2 and 2 AXELROD R 2 Axelrod Hamilton 2 average population 2 attractiveness via 2 attractiveness variable 2 attractiveness N 2 attractiveness from 2 attractiveness and 2 a superlative 2 a strong 2 ast male 2 as punishers 2 as in 2 a sexually 2 artificial society 2 artificial life 2 a particular 2 A No 2 an MP 2 an isolated 2 an individual 2 an increasing 2 an FC 2 a net 2 and thus 2 and social 2 and population 2 and only 2 and numerical 2 and individual 2 and human 2 and genetics 2 and defectors 2 and costly 2 and cooperation 2 and behaviours 2 and B3 2 and admiration 2 a mean 2 altruistic is 2 altruistic cost 2 altruism the 2 altruism as 2 altruism and 2 alpha I 2 a higher 2 a generalised 2 a function 2 a dynamic 2 advantage of 2 adopt the 2 admiration from 2 a constant 2 achieved in 2 achieved by 2 A3 0 2 8 D 2 8 B 27 sexual attractiveness 2 7 Figure 2 50 periods 2 4 and 2 4 20 23 evolution of 2 3 4 2 3 2 2 316 5833 22 to the 22 of altruism 2 2 http 2 2 html 2 2012 In 2 2011 The 2 1 with 2 1 The 2 1 period 2 1 and 2 18 3 2 14 4 2 13 3 2 1 2000 2 1016 j 2 10 1098 2 100 Defectors 2 1000 200 2 1 000 2 0 Ι 20 for the 2 0 8 2 0 7 2 0 2000 2 0 200 2 0 1000 2 000 C 2 000 B 2 000 and 1 ωP where 1 ωP Removed 1 ω denotes 1 ω 1 1 μ The 1 μ nvest 1 μ Initially 1 μ has 1 κ are 1 δ to 1 δ For 1 δ c 1 δ Attractivenesss 1 γ and 1 β and 1 αI However 1 Zhun Deng 1 Zeng and 1 Zaballa L 1 Zaballa 2010 1 Z 2016 1 your browser 1 Yize Chen 1 Yet we 1 yet in 1 YE H 1 Ye b 1 Y Chen 1 Y 2011 1 xN_C 6 1 x is 1 x increases 1 x in 1 x Houchmandzadeh 1 x from 1 x frac 1 x following 1 x at 1 x are 1 W Weissing 1 W Smith 1 would be 1 world if 1 work was 1 works have 1 words F 1 women s 1 with viscous 1 with three 1 with this 1 with these 1 With the 1 withstands the 1 with probability 1 Without the 1 without the 1 without exploring 1 without attractiveness 1 with others 1 with more 1 with Mating 1 with Javascript 1 within the 1 with individual 1 with Houchmandzadeh 1 withhold long 1 with hard 1 with four 1 with females 1 with F 1 with cellular 1 with altruistic 1 Wilson D 1 Wilson 1999 1 will persistently 1 will obtain 1 will not 1 will never 1 will modify 1 will look 1 will lead 1 will invest 1 will incur 1 will increase 1 will express 1 wild type 1 widen the 1 whom the 1 whole society 1 whole a 1 who do 1 who admire 1 while the 1 while sexuality 1 while only 1 while mate 1 while FC 1 while decreasing 1 which means 1 which may 1 which greatly 1 which fits 1 whether the 1 where prosocial 1 where population 1 where players 1 where P 1 where mating 1 where I 1 where everyone 1 whereas MD 1 where altruists 1 When the 1 when the 1 when punishment 1 when N 1 when individuals 1 when females 1 when composed 1 when care 1 when both 1 we will 1 we utilize 1 We then 1 we speculate 1 We select 1 we provide 1 we propose 1 we plot 1 We perform 1 We now 1 We model 1 well Now 1 well fitted 1 Weissing F 1 we illustrate 1 We found 1 we do 1 we discuss 1 we compare 1 we classify 1 We believe 1 We are 1 we apply 1 we adopt 1 we acknowledge 1 way to 1 ways of 1 ways 1 1 way for 1 way Barta 1 was supported 1 was set 1 was partially 1 was contingent 1 viscous populations 1 virtue To 1 virtues The 1 virtues can 1 virtues biological 1 virtue Penguin 1 virtue mutualism 1 violation Potgieter 1 violation of 1 viewed Most 1 viewed as 1 via various 1 via the 1 via sexual 1 via methods 1 via inhibition 1 Via freedom 1 via a 1 versus the 1 Varying population 1 varying population 1 various timings 1 various selections 1 various parameters 1 various disciplines 1 various adjusted 1 Variation Variations 1 variation to 1 Variations in 1 variation behind 1 variation assumption 1 variation appears 1 variables such 1 VAN DIJK 1 Van Dijk 1 Value of 1 value larger 1 value from 1 value altruism 1 utilize their 1 usually associated 1 useful suggestions 1 up the 1 upon the 1 Unto others 1 unselfish behavior 1 University Press 1 unit of 1 unique perspective 1 uninvolved bystanders 1 under variable 1 under the 1 understood differently 1 understanding of 1 unchanged the 1 UK SHUTTERS 1 uk 19 1 uk 18 1 uk 14 1 uk 13 1 typical public 1 typically ignore 1 type within 1 type that 1 types To 1 types i 1 types cooperator 1 type i 1 type Calculate 1 type are 1 two ways 1 two steps 1 T W 1 Tu Yize 1 turn provide 1 turning points 1 turning point 1 turn he 1 turn enhance 1 trying to 1 TRIVERS R 1 Trivers 1971 1 tribute to 1 tribes Keywords 1 treatments Figure 1 treatments as 1 treatment offers 1 treatment is 1 treatment in 1 treated as 1 Traulsen et 1 TRAULSEN A 1 Traulsen 2005 1 Trans R 1 Transaction Publishers 1 traits may 1 trait but 1 tragedy and 1 tradition from 1 traditional culture 1 traditional altruistic 1 to Zhun 1 to whom 1 to Variable 1 to value 1 to type 1 to themselves 1 total population 1 to suppose 1 To summary 1 to submit 1 to study 1 To solve 1 to solve 1 To simplify 1 to sexual 1 to sex 1 to see 1 to satisfy 1 to resolve 1 to report 1 to replace 1 to rename 1 to redistribute 1 to question 1 to punish 1 to public 1 to provide 1 to produce 1 to pay 1 to overcome 1 to offer 1 Tooby J 1 to note 1 To keep 1 to invest 1 To introduce 1 to Individual 1 to individual 1 to Hamilton 1 to generate 1 to fertilization 1 To extract 1 to explain 1 To expand 1 to ensure 1 to each 1 to develop 1 to deny 1 to coordinate 1 to cooperators 1 to coercion 1 To clarify 1 to clarify 1 to benefit 1 to B3 1 to B2 1 to another 1 to altruism 1 to advertise 1 to abundant 1 to 1 1 to 0 1 T Komdeur 1 tits Proceedings 1 tits has 1 timings of 1 timing of 1 timing does 1 thus there 1 thus increase 1 through two 1 through the 1 three types 1 three simulations 1 three repeated 1 three different 1 This work 1 This violation 1 this sense 1 this proposal 1 This process 1 this particular 1 This page 1 this model 1 this constant 1 this assumption 1 this approach 1 third party 1 They share 1 they sacrifice 1 they do 1 the wild 1 the whole 1 the way 1 the various 1 The variable 1 The value 1 The treatment 1 the treatment 1 the traditional 1 the total 1 The study 1 The strength 1 the strategy 1 the status 1 the stability 1 The spatial 1 the sole 1 the societies 1 the so 1 The simulation 1 the simulated 1 the Shiwiar 1 the sexual 1 the settings 1 these simulations 1 these simulation 1 the selection 1 these keywords 1 these authors 1 the scope 1 the scale 1 the s 1 the Royal 1 The result 1 the resource 1 the resolution 1 Therefore an 1 there are 1 the real 1 the rational 1 the randomness 1 The quarterly 1 the punishers 1 the public 1 the proposed 1 The process 1 the process 1 The probability 1 the preference 1 the predecessors 1 the preceding 1 the power 1 The possible 1 The possibility 1 The plots 1 the plot 1 the player 1 the perspective 1 the persistent 1 the payoffs 1 the payoff 1 the particular 1 The outcome 1 the outcome 1 theory social 1 theory Gintis 1 theory from 1 theory and 1 the original 1 theories Current 1 theoretical outcomes 1 theoretical modelling 1 theoretical biologists 1 the opposite 1 the only 1 the numbers 1 the novel 1 the nonparticipant 1 then his 1 then her 1 then extend 1 the next 1 the nemesis 1 the National 1 the national 1 the narrow 1 the names 1 The mutation 1 the mutation 1 themselves and 1 them saints 1 the Moran 1 the models 1 the midpoint 1 the method 1 The mechanism 1 the mechanism 1 The mate 1 them as 1 the maintenance 1 the linear 1 the line 1 the limit 1 the level 1 the later 1 their system 1 their sexual 1 their robust 1 their own 1 their generation 1 The investment 1 The introduction 1 the interplay 1 the interaction 1 The initial 1 The increase 1 the incentives 1 the implicit 1 The ignorance 1 the I 1 The hypothesis 1 the human 1 the historical 1 the highest 1 The hierarchy 1 the group 1 the given 1 The genetical 1 the gap 1 The fundamental 1 the function 1 the formula 1 the formation 1 The form 1 the force 1 the final 1 the fact 1 the extinction 1 the exponential 1 the expected 1 the existing 1 The existence 1 the exact 1 The Evolution 1 the establishment 1 the entire 1 the effects 1 The dynamics 1 The dynamic 1 the dynamic 1 the dominant 1 the division 1 The difference 1 The dependency 1 the defectors 1 the dead 1 the Darwinian 1 the cost 1 the corresponding 1 the cooperator 1 the cooperative 1 the constant 1 the conflict 1 the concurrent 1 The conclusion 1 the concepts 1 The concept 1 the concept 1 The computer 1 the compensation 1 the community 1 the column 1 the collective 1 the cohesion 1 the coexistence 1 the co 1 the change 1 The case 1 the case 1 the carrying 1 the Cambridge 1 the calculations 1 the breadth 1 The Blessing 1 The biology 1 the benefits 1 The benefit 1 The basic 1 the balance 1 the assumptions 1 The apparent 1 the altruists 1 the altruist 1 The altruism 1 the agent 1 The advantage 1 the advantage 1 the admiration 1 the adjusted 1 the actor 1 the accuracy 1 The above 1 that will 1 that when 1 that was 1 that varying 1 that social 1 that report 1 that our 1 that only 1 that mutation 1 that moral 1 that models 1 that it 1 that inter 1 that increases 1 that in 1 that I 1 that FD 1 that cooperation 1 that can 1 that benefits 1 that any 1 that an 1 that a 1 than in 1 than him 1 than her 1 than four 1 than 200 1 than 10 1 than 0 1 T Hales 1 test with 1 tests the 1 tests on 1 test results 1 test for 1 term love 1 templates for 1 T E 1 Tanzhe Tang 1 Tang a 1 Tan F 1 talked about 1 takes value 1 takes dominance 1 take power 1 take part 1 taken into 1 taken alone 1 take dominance 1 T 2002 1 Székely T 1 systems Transaction 1 system of 1 synchronously with 1 sympathy The 1 sympathy that 1 sympathy proposed 1 sympathy individuals 1 sympathy can 1 sympathy as 1 sympathy and 1 sympathize with 1 switch to 1 survive under 1 Surprisingly the 1 suppose that 1 supported by 1 superlative example 1 superlative cohesion 1 super heroines 1 superheroes and 1 summary a 1 sum I_i 1 SUGIYAMA L 1 Sugiyama et 1 suggestions we 1 suggest inequality 1 suffers punishments 1 suffers nearly 1 suffer punishment 1 success Alonzo 1 substructure of 1 substitute for 1 submit Copyright 1 study the 1 study of 1 Studying artificial 1 studies In 1 studied the 1 studied in 1 structures and 1 structure may 1 structure i 1 Structured Societies 1 structured societies 1 strong stabilizer 1 strong sense 1 Strong reciprocity 1 strict stereotypes 1 strict constraint 1 Strengths of 1 strength 0 1 strategy Ye 1 strategy that 1 strategy requires 1 strategy in 1 strategy i 1 strategies Journal 1 S Tooby 1 still exists 1 s theoretical 1 stereotypes as 1 steps of 1 steps 1 1 step of 1 status where 1 stats About 1 Statistics Statistics 1 Statistics Most 1 state variables 1 standard deviation 1 stable strategies 1 stabilizer to 1 stabilizer for 1 stability of 1 S T 1 s sympathy 1 s social 1 s simulation 1 s sexual 1 Springer Science 1 spread of 1 speculate that 1 spatial spread 1 spatial distribution 1 s own 1 South African 1 sources to 1 some initial 1 somehow similar 1 solved by 1 sole dominance 1 solace or 1 society whereas 1 society where 1 society when 1 society structure 1 society Overall 1 society Otherwise 1 Society of 1 society N 1 society may 1 society into 1 society i 1 society he 1 society given 1 society from 1 society Finally 1 society Figure 1 society compete 1 society Besides 1 society are 1 society and 1 society although 1 society 54 1 societies with 1 societies typically 1 Societies Journal 1 societies In 1 societies in 1 social structures 1 social selection 1 social scrutiny 1 Social Science 1 social justice 1 sociality Journal 1 social exchange 1 social evolution 1 social environment 1 Social dilemmas 1 Social Dilemma 1 social cooperation 1 social behavior 1 social altruistic 1 Soc B 1 so called 1 Sober Wilson 1 SOBER E 1 s Note 1 sN_ mathit 1 Smith 2001 1 small probability 1 smaller mutation 1 size which 1 size serves 1 size on 1 size N 1 size is 1 size in 1 size due 1 size benefits 1 size and 1 s It 1 s is 1 s investments 1 single period 1 since a 1 s In 1 simulation where 1 simulation We 1 simulations where 1 simulations we 1 simulations that 1 simulations of 1 simulations in 1 simulations However 1 Simulations have 1 simulations have 1 simulations Hang 1 simulations Figure 1 simulations due 1 simulation requires 1 simulation practices 1 simulation models 1 simulation model 1 simulation is 1 simulation indicates 1 Simulation 19 1 Simulation 18 1 Simulation 14 1 Simulation 13 1 simulated model 1 simplify the 1 simplifies the 1 simplicity but 1 simple assumptions 1 similar to 1 similar Our 1 significant as 1 significant and 1 significant amplifier 1 Signature in 1 signal to 1 signalling theory 1 signaling theories 1 signaling in 1 Signaling and 1 Sigmund K 1 s i 1 SHUTTERS S 1 Shutters Hales 1 show the 1 show that 1 shows the 1 shown in 1 show favour 1 showed that 1 Shoresh N 1 Shiwiar of 1 She will 1 she will 1 She also 1 share the 1 shares the 1 share nearly 1 shape the 1 S H 1 s genes 1 s Figure 1 s favour 1 sexual partners 1 sexuality to 1 sexuality shapes 1 sexuality possibly 1 sexuality is 1 Sexuality has 1 Sexuality Evolution 1 sexuality Baseline 1 sexuality __________________________________________________________________ 1 sexual capital 1 Sexual attractiveness 1 sexual approach 1 sex provides 1 several important 1 setup We 1 setups in 1 setting The 1 settings to 1 settings are 1 Set the 1 serve as 1 separate and 1 sense the 1 sense that 1 self reinforcing 1 selfless help 1 self consciousness 1 select several 1 selection where 1 selection theory 1 Selection the 1 selection strength 1 selections at 1 selection of 1 selection models 1 selection may 1 Selection in 1 selection for 1 selection Figure 1 selection favours 1 selection as 1 selection an 1 selection among 1 selecting them 1 see the 1 see Figure 1 section we 1 section the 1 sections The 1 sections is 1 sections In 1 sections except 1 section if 1 section FC 1 section except 1 section Discussion 1 section at 1 section are 1 second step 1 S D 1 scrutiny and 1 scope of 1 s cooperative 1 s contribution 1 sciences rspb20112297 1 sciences 99 1 Sciences 279 1 sciences 267 1 Science Fund 1 Science Business 1 Science 327 1 Science 211 1 science 1183068 1 science 11 1 Scelza B 1 scale of 1 scale N 1 scaled the 1 S Bshary 1 say 1 1 Save citation 1 satisfy 1 1 s asexual 1 same population 1 same gender 1 salient However 1 saints of 1 sacrifice their 1 s 2015 1 S 2007 1 S 2002 1 S 2001 1 s 2000 1 S 1999 1 S0305004100033193 NEFF 1 S0022 5193 1 runs synchronously 1 rstb 2015 1 rss JASSS 1 rspb20112297 YE 1 rspb 2000 1 R Soc 1 R Richerson 1 Royal Society 1 routines Figure 1 robust tests 1 robustness checks 1 Robustness Check 1 road to 1 R Mathew 1 R M 1 R L 1 right sN_ 1 right N_D 1 right left 1 right I 1 RIDLEY M 1 Ridley 1997 1 Richerson P 1 Richerson 1990 1 R Hamilton 1 rewards A 1 revolution trying 1 review E 1 results withhold 1 results we 1 Results The 1 results The 1 results suggest 1 results No 1 results In 1 results imply 1 Results for 1 results describing 1 results between 1 results are 1 result coincides 1 response of 1 respectively x 1 respectively The 1 respectively Plots 1 respectively Figure 1 respectively 2 1 resources Extension 1 resources egoism 1 resolve the 1 resolution of 1 Researches in 1 researches in 1 researchers proposed 1 requires more 1 requires crucial 1 reproductive strategies 1 reproduction which 1 reproduction to 1 reproduction The 1 report their 1 reported in 1 report different 1 replace the 1 rename the 1 Removed at 1 remarkable differences 1 remains constant 1 remains 0 1 religions social 1 Religions and 1 Religions also 1 religion in 1 relation to 1 related to 1 reinforcing process 1 reinforce the 1 reinforced because 1 References ALEXANDER 1 referees We 1 redistribute the 1 reciprocity and 1 recent researches 1 receives the 1 receives admiration 1 receive nearly 1 receive female 1 Received 17 1 real world 1 reality better 1 realise that 1 Read in 1 reach the 1 reaches its 1 R E 1 R D 1 R B 1 rational consumption 1 rate The 1 rate Simulation 1 rate can 1 rate by 1 rarely been 1 Random processes 1 randomness of 1 random mutation 1 randomly switch 1 randomly decides 1 raises the 1 RAIHANI N 1 Raihani et 1 R 2010 1 R 1984 1 quite similar 1 quite optimistic 1 question the 1 Quarterly review 1 quarterly review 1 qualified as 1 pure altruism 1 punish the 1 punish or 1 punish only 1 Punishment γ 1 punishment without 1 punishment that 1 punishment strategy 1 punishment social 1 punishments from 1 punishment Science 1 punishment model 1 punishment mechanism 1 Punishment Mating 1 punishment game 1 punishment found 1 Punishment for 1 punishment favours 1 punishment evolution 1 punishment cements 1 punishment can 1 punishment called 1 punishment but 1 punishment Boyd 1 Punishment Attractiveness 1 punishment are 1 punish MD 1 punishes defectors 1 punisher to 1 punisher They 1 punishers Ye 1 punishers will 1 punishers Sexual 1 punishers In 1 punishers in 1 Punishers impose 1 punishers from 1 punishers cooperators 1 Punishers benefit 1 punishers Actually 1 punisher s 1 Punisher MD 1 punisher In 1 punisher directly 1 punisher and 1 punish defectors 1 Publishers ALONZO 1 Published 31 1 public interest 1 pub2 DAWES 1 psychology of 1 psychology 35 1 psychologists cannot 1 psychological science 1 Psychological bulletin 1 pseudo code 1 provides a 1 provide infrastructures 1 provided templates 1 provide critical 1 prosocial strategy 1 proposed that 1 proposed model 1 proposed by 1 proposed and 1 proposed a 1 propose a 1 proposal biologists 1 promote the 1 produce a 1 process The 1 process Physical 1 process permits 1 process Moran 1 process follows 1 processes in 1 Process adjusted 1 proceedings of 1 problem in 1 prob I 1 probability d 1 primitive tribes 1 previous simulations 1 previous contribution 1 PRESTON S 1 Press SUGIYAMA 1 press Current 1 preference we 1 Preference Sexual 1 preference Religions 1 preference or 1 preference on 1 preference is 1 Preference Download 1 preference altruistic 1 preference acts 1 predecessors of 1 preceding sections 1 praise solace 1 practices in 1 pp 60 1 power to 1 power of 1 power in 1 POTGIETER F 1 Potgieter 2011 1 possibly plays 1 possibly invade 1 possible growth 1 possibility of 1 population will 1 population unchanged 1 Population The 1 population the 1 population structure 1 populations Koella 1 Population size 1 populations Exact 1 population reaches 1 Population N 1 population is 1 population induced 1 population in 1 population frequency 1 population denoted 1 population could 1 population constraint 1 population condition 1 Population Assumptions 1 Population Assumption 1 population as 1 population All 1 population A1 1 Population A 1 population A 1 Pop is 1 Pop Dynamics 1 politics also 1 point where 1 point South 1 points from 1 Pogány Á 1 pnas 122352999 1 P MP 1 P MD 1 Plots in 1 plots in 1 plots for 1 plot of 1 plot a 1 playing the 1 player that 1 players With 1 players could 1 P J 1 Pitcher T 1 Pitcher 2005 1 pioneers we 1 pioneering works 1 Physical review 1 Physica D 1 Phil Trans 1 philosophical society 1 Philosophical Analysis 1 philosophers and 1 phenomena 22 1 P FD 1 perspective to 1 perspectives on 1 perspectives Finally 1 perspective serves 1 perspective of 1 perspective altruistic 1 persistent puzzle 1 persistently dominate 1 permit the 1 permits the 1 period To 1 period The 1 periods We 1 Periods The 1 periods However 1 periods Figure 1 periods CAPTION 1 periods C 1 periods B 1 period say 1 Period Punishment 1 period less 1 period i 1 period For 1 period as 1 period are 1 period Additionally 1 Period 5 1 period 100 1 period 0 1 perform robustness 1 performed in 1 people including 1 Penguin UK 1 PDF Tanzhe 1 P denotes 1 P Calculate 1 pay tribute 1 pay to 1 payoffs of 1 payoffs for 1 payoff P 1 payoff functions 1 payoff function 1 payoff and 1 paves the 1 paths and 1 path of 1 party punishment 1 partners which 1 part in 1 particular setting 1 particular population 1 Particularly pioneering 1 particular instance 1 particular form 1 participation of 1 partial substitute 1 partially with 1 partially solved 1 parameters We 1 parameters to 1 Parameters for 1 parameters For 1 parameters are 1 parameters and 1 paper suggest 1 paper By 1 page will 1 P A 1 P 1958 1 own interest 1 over the 1 over MP 1 over MD 1 Overall these 1 out of 1 outcome that 1 outcomes in 1 outcome of 1 our society 1 Our simple 1 Our conclusion 1 other words 1 Otherwise the 1 others The 1 Other stats 1 others Gintis 1 others and 1 other prosocial 1 other players 1 other parameters 1 other moral 1 other fields 1 other cooperators 1 or MP 1 or more 1 origin of 1 original constant 1 or even 1 or equivalently 1 or direct 1 or defectors 1 or cooperator 1 or artificial 1 or admire 1 opt out 1 optimistic in 1 opposite perspective 1 operative punishment 1 operates as 1 opens up 1 on various 1 on social 1 on other 1 on MD 1 only the 1 only origin 1 only in 1 only females 1 only defectors 1 only care 1 on high 1 on defectors 1 on cooperators 1 once again 1 on altruistic 1 of μ 1 of δ 1 of x 1 of virtues 1 of unselfish 1 of society 1 of simulation 1 of simplicity 1 of Sexuality 1 of Sexual 1 of sciences 1 of revolution 1 of reciprocal 1 of pure 1 of Punishment 1 of public 1 of psychology 1 of Population 1 of population 1 of playing 1 of periods 1 of people 1 of penduline 1 of our 1 of other 1 of nonparticipation 1 of newborns 1 of newborn 1 of near 1 of names 1 of mutation 1 of motivation 1 of moral 1 of Medicine 1 of MD 1 of mathematical 1 of mate 1 of limited 1 of life 1 of kin 1 of invasion 1 of inclusive 1 of how 1 of his 1 of having 1 of genetic 1 of generations 1 of genders 1 of game 1 offsprings is 1 offspring care 1 of four 1 of fixed 1 of Figure 1 offers a 1 offer public 1 of female 1 of FD 1 of evolutionary 1 of evolution 1 of egoists 1 of education 1 of edition 1 of Ecuadorian 1 of Economics 1 of ecological 1 of determining 1 of defector 1 of Cooperation 1 of constant 1 of conflict 1 of computer 1 of cognitive 1 of causality 1 of c 1 of attractiveness 1 of asexual 1 of any 1 of another 1 of Altruism 1 of agents 1 of A1 1 of 50 1 Oct 2015 1 obtain a 1 observed in 1 observations and 1 N β 1 N x 1 N we 1 nvest punish 1 numbers of 1 number 13AZD061 1 Now we 1 now The 1 now conduct 1 now an 1 novel sources 1 not the 1 not talked 1 not suggest 1 not selecting 1 not punish 1 not necessarily 1 not model 1 nothing to 1 not elucidate 1 noted by 1 not contribute 1 not complete 1 not clear 1 not appear 1 not an 1 not admire 1 notable Figure 1 no strict 1 no self 1 norm violation 1 norms and 1 norms also 1 No remarkable 1 non punishment 1 nonparticipation Jaffe 1 nonparticipant strategy 1 nonlinear phenomena 1 Non Gaussian 1 no MP 1 no more 1 no genetic 1 no fluctuations 1 no attractiveness 1 no altruistic 1 no admiration 1 N Nowak 1 N male 1 N left 1 N J 1 N frac 1 N female 1 next sections 1 next period 1 new form 1 New evolutionary 1 newborns equals 1 newborn offsprings 1 newborn according 1 never realise 1 net loss 1 net increase 1 nemesis of 1 neglected and 1 Neff Pitcher 1 NEFF B 1 necessary to 1 necessarily imply 1 nearly the 1 Nearly no 1 near extinction 1 N_D xN_C 1 nature randomly 1 Nature 415 1 National Social 1 national academy 1 narrow way 1 narrow road 1 names of 1 names in 1 N 7 1 N 5 1 mutualism altruism 1 mutation plays 1 mutation changing 1 Mutant with 1 mutant i 1 Multilevel selection 1 MP with 1 MP will 1 MP while 1 MP receives 1 MP P 1 MP Male 1 MP beta 1 MP also 1 MP 4 1 MP 2 1 motivation to 1 motivation for 1 Most viewed 1 most males 1 most grateful 1 most females 1 Most cited 1 Moreover a 1 more individuals 1 more he 1 more appropriate 1 more altruistic 1 Moran Process 1 MORAN P 1 Moran 1958 1 moral traits 1 moral systems 1 moral sense 1 moral psychologists 1 moral philosophers 1 Morality as 1 moral concept 1 molecular Langton 1 Molecular Ecology 1 modify this 1 modern civilisations 1 model Ye 1 model with 1 model We 1 model we 1 model Varying 1 models where 1 models when 1 models we 1 models the 1 models showed 1 models settings 1 models involving 1 model since 1 model setups 1 Model setup 1 Model settings 1 Model section 1 models are 1 models and 1 models A2 1 model operates 1 model opens 1 model MP 1 model Model 1 model loses 1 modelling and 1 model is 1 model Initialize 1 Model In 1 model in 1 model human 1 model has 1 model Figure 1 model dynamics 1 model Additionally 1 model 2015 1 M Messick 1 M Jia 1 MILLER G 1 midpoint I 1 methods of 1 method of 1 Messick D 1 Messick 2000 1 mentioned before 1 member of 1 Medicine Zhejiang 1 Media BIRD 1 mechanism runs 1 mechanism for 1 measure of 1 Meanwhile the 1 Mean Value 1 means that 1 mean of 1 MD Thus 1 MD takes 1 MD suffers 1 MD N_ 1 MD Male 1 MD except 1 MD by 1 MD beta 1 MCANDREW F 1 may serve 1 may possibly 1 may lead 1 may in 1 may disfavour 1 may be 1 may argue 1 MATLAB codes 1 Mathew S 1 Mathew 2007 1 Mathematical proceedings 1 mathematical biology 1 Mate preference 1 mate choice 1 Martu women 1 Mar 2016 1 many sexual 1 many aspects 1 male will 1 male then 1 males with 1 males that 1 males such 1 males receive 1 males punish 1 male society 1 males invest 1 males in 1 males I 1 males completely 1 males are 1 male represents 1 Male Punisher 1 male punisher 1 male parental 1 male only 1 male N 1 male investing 1 male his 1 male female 1 male favoured 1 Male Defector 1 male cooperators 1 male 8 1 making them 1 majority of 1 majority invest 1 maintenance and 1 made by 1 M 2012 1 M 2000 1 M 1997 1 L S 1 lower level 1 love and 1 loss to 1 loses its 1 look and 1 long term 1 long periods 1 long hidden 1 logo Issues 1 ll HAUERT 1 literatures on 1 literatures in 1 listed in 1 line graphs 1 linear form 1 limit of 1 limitations To 1 limitations Claussen 1 likely to 1 life with 1 life or 1 life long 1 life given 1 level where 1 levels Alexander 1 level of 1 level males 1 level in 1 level females 1 level altruism 1 level A 1 less than 1 less population 1 left x 1 led to 1 law enforcement 1 lattice models 1 later section 1 later period 1 larger than 1 larger difference 1 LANGTON C 1 Langton 1986 1 labeled on 1 L A 1 L 2010 1 L 2002 1 L 1971 1 K Zaballa 1 Komdeur J 1 Koella s 1 KOELLA J 1 kin altruism 1 Ke Zeng 1 keywords Introduction 1 Keywords Altruistic 1 key factor 1 keep the 1 K 2007 1 just MD 1 justice still 1 justice religion 1 justice and 1 jtbi 2000 1 J Pogány 1 Jia Y 1 J Grutter 1 j evolhumbehav 1 J Cosmides 1 j biosystems 1 Javascript The 1 Javascript is 1 JASSS logo 1 JASSS Home 1 JASSS Contact 1 jasss 3058 1 jasss 2780 1 JASSS 2016 1 jasss 1805 1 JAFFE K 1 Jaffe and 1 J 1990 1 It would 1 its power 1 its capacity 1 I To 1 It is 1 I takes 1 is δ 1 is usually 1 is understood 1 is treated 1 is taken 1 Issues Issues 1 Issues In 1 issues For 1 issue Back 1 is somehow 1 is quite 1 is prob 1 isolated society 1 isolated population 1 is now 1 is notable 1 is no 1 is neglected 1 is necessary 1 is male 1 is likely 1 is introduced 1 is inconsistent 1 is in 1 is how 1 is highly 1 I She 1 is he 1 is hard 1 is given 1 is generally 1 is F 1 is expressed 1 is enhanced 1 is employed 1 is egoistic 1 is disabled 1 is defined 1 is considered 1 is conducted 1 is completed 1 is clear 1 is calculated 1 is biologically 1 is beyond 1 is also 1 is 0 1 I regardless 1 I of 1 in your 1 in Ye 1 in ways 1 involving no 1 involving alternations 1 involved in 1 invests I 1 invests 1 1 investment widetilde 1 investments in 1 investments are 1 investment remains 1 investment is 1 investment incurs 1 investment i 1 Investment Distribution 1 investment distribution 1 investment can 1 investment are 1 invest in 1 investigated in 1 invest I 1 invest between 1 invest about 1 invasion of 1 in variable 1 invade the 1 in two 1 In turn 1 Introduction Sexuality 1 introduce the 1 introduced to 1 introduced the 1 into three 1 into four 1 into account 1 in these 1 inter sexual 1 interplay between 1 International journal 1 interest to 1 interest Bird 1 interaction between 1 intensity Bulletin 1 integrated framework 1 in Structured 1 in structured 1 in steps 1 instead of 1 instance e 1 inspire long 1 In simulations 1 in results 1 in repeated 1 in relation 1 in public 1 in psychological 1 in primitive 1 In press 1 in population 1 in point 1 in penduline 1 in parameters 1 In our 1 I Note 1 in offspring 1 in next 1 in nearly 1 in Moran 1 In modern 1 in MATLAB 1 in Martu 1 in males 1 initial settings 1 initial proportion 1 initial periods 1 initially individual 1 Initially altruistic 1 initially A 1 Initialize Read 1 in investment 1 in humans 1 in human 1 In Houchmandzadeh 1 in his 1 inhibition against 1 in genetics 1 infrastructures for 1 influence the 1 in fish 1 In Figure 1 in every 1 in equation 1 inequality between 1 in education 1 in economic 1 In each 1 in each 1 in dynamic 1 induced by 1 individual while 1 Individual Variation 1 individual to 1 individuals with 1 individuals whose 1 individuals We 1 individuals can 1 individuals as 1 individuals are 1 individual provide 1 individual P 1 individual of 1 individual Mutant 1 individual equally 1 individual are 1 individual and 1 indicators of 1 indicate that 1 indicates the 1 indicates that 1 incurs a 1 incurred by 1 incur a 1 in creating 1 increasing the 1 increasing population 1 increasing function 1 increase their 1 increases the 1 increases from 1 in constant 1 inconsistent in 1 in computer 1 in competition 1 Inclusive fitness 1 inclusive fitness 1 including MP 1 in civilisations 1 incentives for 1 in C1 1 In C 1 in C 1 in both 1 In biology 1 in B3 1 In B1 1 in B1 1 In B 1 in B 1 in asexual 1 in artificial 1 In all 1 in all 1 in A 1 in 5 1 I N 1 impose an 1 important problem 1 important parameters 1 implicit assumption 1 illustrates the 1 illustrate in 1 I_i N 1 ignore the 1 ignorance of 1 I gamma 1 if sexual 1 I frac 1 I For 1 I follows 1 I Figure 1 if his 1 if altruistic 1 identical normal 1 identical mutation 1 identical in 1 I 3 1 I 2 1 I 1 1 hypothesis that 1 hypothesis into 1 hunting Evolution 1 human sympathy 1 human societies 1 human sociality 1 humans Nature 1 human motivation 1 human beings 1 human behavior 1 html KOELLA 1 html DOI 1 H Tan 1 H Smith 1 How to 1 how to 1 how sexuality 1 However to 1 However taken 1 However MP 1 However in 1 However as 1 Houchmandzdeh s 1 HOUCHMANDZADEH B 1 honour of 1 honest signal 1 Home 19 1 H Nowak 1 historical observations 1 his own 1 his investment 1 his her 1 him and 1 high mean 1 highly related 1 high level 1 highest honour 1 higher mean 1 higher invasion 1 hierarchy of 1 hidden blessing 1 her probability 1 heroines with 1 her i 1 her gender 1 hence bears 1 help Preston 1 he benefits 1 health condition 1 having I 1 have to 1 have rarely 1 have not 1 have less 1 have led 1 have investigated 1 have done 1 have demonstrated 1 have broadly 1 have attempted 1 have amplifying 1 HAUERT C 1 has an 1 Harvard University 1 Harmonic Signature 1 hard to 1 hard resource 1 happens when 1 HAMILTON W 1 Hamilton W 1 Hamilton Genetics 1 Hales D 1 Hales 2015 1 H 2012 1 H 2000 1 Grutter A 1 growth in 1 Group selection 1 group selection 1 group Raihani 1 greatly simplifies 1 grateful to 1 graphs of 1 Grant number 1 g period 1 goods The 1 goods In 1 goods equally 1 goods due 1 goods altruism 1 good genes 1 g lattice 1 Given the 1 given The 1 given the 1 given public 1 given probability 1 given other 1 Gintis Smith 1 Gintis et 1 Gintis 2000 1 G F 1 genetics sexuality 1 genetics Mathematical 1 genetics argued 1 Genetics 176 1 Genetic quality 1 genetic quality 1 genetic or 1 genetical evolution 1 genes Preston 1 genes Molecular 1 genes and 1 generation the 1 generations is 1 generation In 1 generate a 1 generally conducted 1 generalised to 1 generalised perspective 1 generalised Moran 1 gender with 1 genders To 1 genders The 1 genders For 1 genders because 1 genders Additionally 1 gender In 1 gender differences 1 Gaussian fluctuations 1 gap between 1 gamma left 1 game theory 1 games as 1 game Journal 1 game is 1 game In 1 game defined 1 Game A 1 gains the 1 Gächter S 1 Gächter 2002 1 G 2012 1 G 1986 1 Fund China 1 fundamental difference 1 functions as 1 function in 1 function better 1 fulfilled only 1 F T 1 from Traulsen 1 from three 1 from third 1 from public 1 from nearly 1 from Koella 1 from finite 1 from females 1 from different 1 from Darwin 1 from B1 1 from a 1 from 0 1 frequency about 1 freedom to 1 framework for 1 frac sum 1 frac N_ 1 frac left 1 found to 1 found that 1 found in 1 for Variable 1 For useful 1 for theoretical 1 for their 1 for social 1 For simplicity 1 for simplicity 1 for sexuality 1 for sexual 1 for selfless 1 for s 1 for periods 1 for N 1 formula in 1 forms of 1 forms even 1 for moral 1 formation of 1 For male 1 for limited 1 for individual 1 for human 1 for good 1 For females 1 for females 1 for F 1 For example 1 for each 1 for different 1 force to 1 forces for 1 force of 1 force for 1 for attractiveness 1 for assistance 1 for A 1 follows the 1 follows MP 1 follows a 1 following Houchmandzdeh 1 follow an 1 fluctuations arising 1 fluctuations are 1 Fluctuation driven 1 fixed population 1 fixation of 1 fitted simulation 1 fits reality 1 fitness theory 1 fitness The 1 fitness Mate 1 fitness is 1 fitness i 1 fitness Hamilton 1 fitness for 1 fitness End 1 fitness does 1 fitness comes 1 fitness by 1 fitness Bell 1 fish Science 1 finite populations 1 final section 1 Final population 1 Figure Punishment 1 Figure Population 1 figure Figure 1 Figure 4 1 Figure 3indicates 1 Figure 3 1 Figure 2C 1 Figure 1B 1 fields of 1 fertilization success 1 Feminists may 1 female with 1 female then 1 females show 1 females respectively 1 female society 1 females is 1 females I 1 females especially 1 females can 1 females both 1 females and 1 female s 1 female punishers 1 female Period 1 Female Defector 1 Female Cooperator 1 female cooperator 1 Fehr Gächter 1 FEHR E 1 Feb 2016 1 FD will 1 FD This 1 FD right 1 FD respectively 1 FD N 1 F Ding 1 FD in 1 FD for 1 FD Female 1 FD Every 1 f denotes 1 FD coexist 1 FD beta 1 FC which 1 FC to 1 FC take 1 FC s 1 FC right 1 FC It 1 FC Female 1 FC beta 1 FC at 1 FC also 1 FC 1 1 Fawcett T 1 favour to 1 favours the 1 favours male 1 favoured by 1 favour and 1 fact that 1 factor in 1 factor for 1 F 2007 1 extract the 1 extinction of 1 extinction after 1 extend the 1 extending the 1 expressed by 1 expressed as 1 express a 1 exponential form 1 exploring the 1 explain many 1 experiments Fehr 1 expected payoffs 1 expand the 1 exist We 1 exists Yet 1 exist see 1 existing evolutionary 1 exchange among 1 except the 1 example of 1 example in 1 examines the 1 exact timing 1 Exact results 1 E Wilson 1 evolves as 1 evolution via 1 evolution Springer 1 evolutions Based 1 evolution is 1 evolution Finally 1 evolutionary way 1 evolutionary simulations 1 evolutionary response 1 evolutionary perspectives 1 evolutionary paths 1 evolutionary path 1 evolutionary Moran 1 evolutionary games 1 evolutionary dynamics 1 evolutionarily stable 1 Evolution and 1 evolution and 1 evolhumbehav 2011 1 evidence of 1 evidence for 1 every traditional 1 everyone invests 1 every MP 1 every males 1 Every individual 1 even uninvolved 1 even more 1 evenly distributed 1 even if 1 Even at 1 even adoration 1 E Székely 1 establishment of 1 established where 1 especially to 1 especially in 1 escape the 1 equivalently sexual 1 equilibrium of 1 equilibrium from 1 equilibrium Discussion 1 equation 6 1 equal to 1 equals the 1 equally while 1 equally shares 1 e period 1 environment and 1 entire society 1 ensure the 1 enhance the 1 enhanced in 1 enforcement and 1 End Set 1 End References 1 employed Surprisingly 1 employed B2 1 employ both 1 empirical studies 1 elucidate an 1 eLS doi 1 egoists Proceedings 1 egoists is 1 egoists become 1 egoistic contributes 1 egoistic because 1 egoist However 1 egoism leads 1 E Gächter 1 effect to 1 effects on 1 effect on 1 e F 1 e f 1 education as 1 education and 1 edition 31 1 e defectors 1 Ecuadorian Amazonia 1 economists have 1 Economics Zhejiang 1 economics It 1 economics Houchmandzadeh 1 economic experiments 1 Ecology 14 1 ecological selection 1 e c 1 e being 1 early period 1 e altruism 1 each of 1 each newborn 1 each generation 1 each figure 1 e a 1 E 71 1 E 2005 1 Dynamics x 1 dynamics Variable 1 dynamics raises 1 dynamics process 1 dynamics is 1 dynamics Figure 1 dynamic process 1 dynamic model 1 dynamic evolution 1 D we 1 D W 1 during each 1 DUGATKIN L 1 Dugatkin 2007 1 D Thus 1 D the 1 D that 1 D share 1 D separate 1 D S 1 driving forces 1 driven fixation 1 d represents 1 D reach 1 D Pop 1 D Pitcher 1 Download PDF 1 done in 1 done based 1 D once 1 dominate the 1 dominates F 1 dominated society 1 dominant types 1 dominant over 1 dominance of 1 DOI 10 1 D nonlinear 1 D N 1 D M 1 division between 1 distribution with 1 distribution was 1 distribution is 1 distribution initially 1 Distribution at 1 distribution and 1 distributed between 1 Displays a 1 disfavours the 1 disfavour parental 1 discuss the 1 Discussion of 1 Discussion In 1 discussed by 1 disciplines Clavien 1 disabled in 1 d is 1 direct rewards 1 directly via 1 directly sympathize 1 directly by 1 directions in 1 Ding M 1 D In 1 D in 1 diminishing effect 1 dilemma The 1 dilemmas International 1 Dilemma Other 1 dilemma of 1 dilemma in 1 dilemma Dawes 1 dilemma 2007 1 DIJK R 1 Dijk et 1 Different Strengths 1 different perspectives 1 Different Periods 1 Different mutation 1 differently in 1 different levels 1 different evolutionary 1 different and 1 difference in 1 deviation of 1 develop a 1 determining the 1 Determine the 1 detected when 1 describing the 1 described before 1 described as 1 dependency of 1 deny the 1 denoted as 1 Deng for 1 d End 1 demonstrated in 1 Demon of 1 deleterious mutant 1 defined by 1 defined as 1 Defector The 1 defectors to 1 defectors respectively 1 defectors regardless 1 Defectors initially 1 defectors In 1 defectors Figure 1 defectors do 1 defectors directly 1 defectors Based 1 defectors at 1 Defectors A 1 defector or 1 Defector FC 1 defector dominated 1 defector and 1 default in 1 decreasing the 1 decides whether 1 decentralised from 1 death Determine 1 death d 1 dead in 1 d c 1 DAWES R 1 Dawes Messick 1 Darwin to 1 Darwinian Demon 1 D 2015 1 D 2013 1 D 1987 1 D 1981 1 D 1964 1 c αI 1 Current simulation 1 Current issue 1 Current directions 1 culture yet 1 cultural evidence 1 C The 1 crucial assumptions 1 Cross cultural 1 critical evidence 1 c represents 1 creating of 1 C overlap 1 could randomly 1 could opt 1 cost to 1 costs the 1 cost of 1 costly signalling 1 Costly Signaling 1 costly signaling 1 costly commitment 1 costly but 1 costly altruistic 1 cost incurred 1 cost However 1 cost Houchmandzadeh 1 cost due 1 cost c 1 cost analysis 1 Cosmides L 1 corresponding effects 1 Copyright Statistics 1 Copyright JASSS 1 coordinate on 1 cooperators which 1 cooperators under 1 cooperators punishers 1 cooperators or 1 cooperators non 1 cooperators in 1 cooperators happens 1 cooperator shapes 1 cooperators contribution 1 cooperators clarified 1 cooperators can 1 cooperators as 1 cooperator s 1 cooperator is 1 Cooperator FD 1 cooperator do 1 cooperator defector 1 cooperative than 1 cooperative hunting 1 cooperative female 1 cooperative behavior 1 Co operative 1 cooperation researchers 1 cooperation proposed 1 cooperation Phil 1 cooperation might 1 Cooperation Journal 1 cooperation in 1 cooperation have 1 cooperation exist 1 Cooperation Basic 1 cooperation and 1 contributive and 1 contribution to 1 contribution just 1 contribution from 1 contribution by 1 contributes nothing 1 contribute Punishers 1 contingent upon 1 Contact JASSS 1 consumption of 1 constraint to 1 constraint in 1 constant scale 1 constant parameters 1 constant during 1 constant and 1 considered as 1 considered altruistic 1 Consider an 1 consciousness i 1 conduct the 1 conducted without 1 conducted to 1 condition instead 1 condition in 1 concurrent participation 1 conclusion withstands 1 conclusion is 1 concerning human 1 concepts of 1 completely overlap 1 complete for 1 completed through 1 competition with 1 compete for 1 compensation to 1 compensation for 1 compensate the 1 compatible genes 1 comparison of 1 compare the 1 compared to 1 community than 1 common tragedy 1 common default 1 commitment to 1 comes from 1 comes at 1 column of 1 colour size 1 collective action 1 coincides partially 1 cohesion where 1 cohesion of 1 cohesion might 1 cohesion made 1 cohesion Journal 1 cohesion directly 1 cohesion because 1 cohesion achieved 1 cognitive adaptations 1 cogent mechanism 1 coexist The 1 coexistence of 1 co evolution 1 coercion the 1 codes __________________________________________________________________ 1 code for 1 C N 1 clear that 1 clear but 1 Clavien Chapuisat 1 CLAVIEN C 1 Claussen Traulsen 1 CLAUSSEN J 1 classify the 1 classified into 1 clarify that 1 clarify note 1 clarified that 1 civilisations Feminists 1 civilisations altruistic 1 cited Other 1 citation Received 1 C is 1 C in 1 Chuankai Cheng 1 choose Proceedings 1 choice Neff 1 China Other 1 China Grant 1 China bCollege 1 Chen Y 1 Cheng Ke 1 Chenfeng Tu 1 Chen Chuankai 1 Check We 1 checks on 1 Chapuisat M 1 Chapuisat 2012 1 changing the 1 change of 1 changed the 1 C gains 1 C G 1 certain distribution 1 cements social 1 cellular automata 1 C dominates 1 c d 1 C Chapuisat 1 causality which 1 case of 1 case in 1 case for 1 carrying capacities 1 care Van 1 care Psychological 1 care praise 1 care in 1 care even 1 care comes 1 capital while 1 capacity The 1 capacity the 1 capacity than 1 capacity for 1 capacities of 1 can widen 1 can survive 1 can punish 1 can pay 1 can overcome 1 cannot compensate 1 can inspire 1 can influence 1 can escape 1 can choose 1 can benefit 1 Cambridge philosophical 1 called cooperative 1 called common 1 calculations for 1 Calculate payoff 1 Calculate fitness 1 calculated by 1 C3 Simulation 1 C3 are 1 C3 0 1 C2 Simulation 1 C2 and 1 C 2000 1 C 200 1 C2 0 1 C 2 1 C1 Simulation 1 C1 C2 1 C1 0 1 C 1 1 by virtue 1 by these 1 By the 1 bystanders can 1 by social 1 by pioneers 1 by not 1 by moral 1 by many 1 by Koella 1 by increasing 1 by f 1 by cooperators 1 by care 1 by both 1 By assuming 1 by altruistic 1 by a 1 but without 1 but the 1 but honest 1 but at 1 Business Media 1 Bulletin of 1 bulletin 139 1 B The 1 B show 1 Bshary R 1 B Scelza 1 browser This 1 broadly studied 1 b represents 1 breadth of 1 Brandt H 1 Boyd Mathew 1 Boyd and 1 Bowles S 1 both sexual 1 both MP 1 both male 1 both genders 1 both follow 1 both C 1 Book AXELROD 1 B most 1 Blessing of 1 blessing of 1 birth rate 1 birth In 1 BIRD R 1 Bird et 1 Bird D 1 biosystems 2014 1 BioSystems 127 1 biology suggest 1 biology of 1 biology altruism 1 biology 82 1 biology 70 1 biology 7 1 biology 35 1 biology 213 1 biology 206 1 biology 145 1 biologists have 1 biologists and 1 Biological Sciences 1 biologically egoistic 1 biological evolutionary 1 B In 1 beyond the 1 between Ye 1 between the 1 between reproductive 1 between N 1 between individual 1 between genders 1 between four 1 between cooperators 1 between asexual 1 between 50 1 between 0 1 better with 1 better Extension 1 Besides theoretical 1 be scaled 1 be reinforced 1 be qualified 1 be proportional 1 be performed 1 be one 1 benefits the 1 benefits others 1 benefit cost 1 be N 1 be more 1 BELL G 1 Bell 2012 1 believe that 1 beings to 1 behind the 1 behaviour we 1 behaviour The 1 behaviour the 1 behaviour that 1 behaviours Miller 1 behaviours from 1 behaviours As 1 behaviours are 1 behaviour of 1 behaviour and 1 behavior Journal 1 behavior Harvard 1 behavior BioSystems 1 Behavior A 1 behavior 33 1 be generalised 1 be fulfilled 1 before Population 1 before and 1 before 50 1 be expressed 1 be evenly 1 be established 1 be equal 1 been viewed 1 been studied 1 been reported 1 been mentioned 1 been labeled 1 been done 1 been conducted 1 be detected 1 become dominant 1 because religions 1 because only 1 because at 1 bears no 1 bear a 1 B D 1 bCollege of 1 B C 1 B Bird 1 B Biological 1 basic hypothesis 1 Basic Book 1 baseline simulation 1 Baseline model 1 based evolutionary 1 based behaviours 1 b aSchool 1 BARTA Z 1 Barta 2016 1 balance of 1 Back issues 1 B a 1 b a 1 B3 to 1 B3 the 1 B3 In 1 B3 compared 1 B 371 1 B2 due 1 B 2015 1 B 200 1 B2 0 1 B1 to 1 B1 the 1 B1 B2 1 B1 0 1 Axelrod 1984 1 a whole 1 a well 1 average value 1 automata Physica 1 authors Journal 1 authors How 1 authors For 1 authorities while 1 a unit 1 a unique 1 a typical 1 attractive virtue 1 attractive trait 1 attractiveness to 1 Attractiveness The 1 attractiveness the 1 Attractiveness Social 1 Attractivenesss A 1 Attractiveness Pop 1 attractiveness permit 1 attractiveness or 1 attractiveness on 1 attractiveness of 1 attractiveness For 1 attractiveness exist 1 attractiveness changed 1 attractiveness can 1 attractiveness at 1 attractiveness as 1 attractiveness are 1 Attractiveness and 1 at the 1 attempted to 1 a tradition 1 at Period 1 at later 1 A The 1 at early 1 at different 1 at capacity 1 at 50 1 as x 1 as we 1 A strict 1 a stabilizer 1 as superheroes 1 assumption will 1 assumption we 1 assumption to 1 assumptions on 1 assumption Simulation 1 assumptions concerning 1 assumptions above 1 Assumptions A1 1 assumption is 1 assumption In 1 assumption in 1 Assumption Consider 1 assuming constant 1 as substructure 1 associated with 1 assistance in 1 as sexual 1 As recent 1 aspects of 1 a spatial 1 as P_ 1 as other 1 as one 1 a society 1 a social 1 as MD 1 A smaller 1 a small 1 a single 1 as indicators 1 a significant 1 A Sigmund 1 A Shoresh 1 As has 1 as follows 1 asexual society 1 asexual reproduction 1 asexual model 1 asexual evolutions 1 asexual and 1 a self 1 as described 1 as defined 1 as compensation 1 as colour 1 aSchool of 1 as an 1 as altruist 1 A S 1 artificial societies 1 artificial molecular 1 artificial human 1 articles with 1 articles by 1 arising from 1 argue that 1 argued sexual 1 are shown 1 are set 1 are quite 1 a represents 1 are present 1 are observed 1 are no 1 are most 1 are listed 1 are involved 1 are identical 1 are found 1 are even 1 are employed 1 are described 1 are defined 1 are decentralised 1 are contributive 1 are constant 1 are considered 1 are conducted 1 are classified 1 are based 1 are at 1 are assumed 1 are also 1 are adopted 1 a random 1 a punishment 1 a probability 1 approximately at 1 appropriate to 1 approach to 1 approach it 1 apply the 1 Appendix Algorithm 1 __________________________________________________________________ Appendix 1 appears to 1 appears between 1 appears approximately 1 appear before 1 apparent absence 1 A Philosophical 1 a partial 1 A P 1 any MP 1 any intensity 1 any individual 1 an understanding 1 another type 1 another individual 1 anonymous referees 1 an integrated 1 an important 1 an identical 1 a new 1 an evolutionary 1 and ω 1 and κ 1 and Zaballa 1 and various 1 and this 1 and sympathy 1 and super 1 and state 1 and standard 1 and simulations 1 and signaling 1 and serves 1 and salient 1 and s 1 and routines 1 and Richerson 1 and remains 1 and reciprocal 1 and receives 1 and receive 1 and punishment 1 and punisher 1 and psychology 1 and provided 1 and promote 1 and politics 1 and P 1 and other 1 and noted 1 and most 1 and more 1 and moral 1 and male 1 and law 1 and initial 1 and in 1 and if 1 and identical 1 and hence 1 and health 1 and Hang 1 and group 1 and function 1 and for 1 and Figure 1 and female 1 and evolution 1 and empirical 1 and egoist 1 and economists 1 and disfavours 1 and discussed 1 and d 1 and costs 1 and cooperators 1 and Cooperation 1 and compatible 1 and C3 1 and bear 1 and b 1 and authorities 1 and anonymous 1 and altruistic 1 and altruism 1 and age 1 and A3 1 and a 1 and 5 1 and 2 1 and 1C 1 and 1B 1 and 100 1 and 1 1 an asexual 1 A narrow 1 an analogous 1 an amplifying 1 an amplification 1 Analytical results 1 Analysis eLS 1 an altruistic 1 analogous to 1 an advantageous 1 an abbreviation 1 amplifying effects 1 amplifying effect 1 amplifier for 1 amplification factor 1 a more 1 among the 1 among alternative 1 a member 1 a measure 1 Amazonia Proceedings 1 al various 1 altruists take 1 altruists especially 1 altruist in 1 altruistic that 1 altruistic than 1 altruistic She 1 Altruistic Punishment 1 Altruistic punishment 1 altruistic investments 1 altruistic contribution 1 altruistic because 1 altruist and 1 altruism Without 1 Altruism with 1 altruism with 1 altruism we 1 altruism versus 1 altruism Trivers 1 altruism To 1 altruism through 1 altruism The 1 altruism than 1 altruism she 1 altruism Quarterly 1 altruism Punishment 1 altruism on 1 altruism Multilevel 1 altruism Moreover 1 altruism may 1 altruism leads 1 altruism involving 1 altruism I 1 altruism he 1 altruism Hamilton 1 altruism from 1 altruism extending 1 altruism evolves 1 altruism equilibrium 1 Altruism Displays 1 altruism by 1 altruism but 1 altruism Axelrod 1 altruism are 1 altruism according 1 Altruism A 1 although MP 1 alternative evolutionarily 1 alternations of 1 also take 1 also shape 1 also reinforce 1 also referred 1 also punishes 1 also present 1 also invests 1 also admires 1 a lower 1 ALONZO S 1 Alonzo 2012 1 alone they 1 all three 1 All the 1 all the 1 a life 1 Algorithm pseudo 1 ALEXANDER R 1 Alexander 1987 1 a larger 1 al 2012 1 al 2010 1 al 2008 1 al 2007 1 al 2002 1 al 2001 1 a key 1 A In 1 a high 1 a Harmonic 1 a given 1 agents Shutters 1 agent in 1 a gender 1 age can 1 against norm 1 again show 1 after some 1 African journal 1 A Figure 1 Á Fawcett 1 advertise the 1 advantageous which 1 advantageous strategy 1 advantageous in 1 a driving 1 adoration and 1 adopted from 1 adopt a 1 admires MP 1 admire female 1 admire any 1 admire according 1 admiration Ye 1 admiration Miller 1 admiration if 1 adjusted models 1 adjusted model 1 adjusted for 1 a diminishing 1 a different 1 a deleterious 1 a defector 1 Additionally we 1 Additionally robust 1 Additionally altruistic 1 adaptations for 1 Actually females 1 acts as 1 actor s 1 action The 1 A costly 1 a cooperator 1 A cooperative 1 a comparison 1 a common 1 a cogent 1 Acknowledgements This 1 __________________________________________________________________ Acknowledgements 1 acknowledge Chenfeng 1 a certain 1 accuracy of 1 account Even 1 Accepted 24 1 a case 1 academy of 1 abundant public 1 Abstract Current 1 absence of 1 A Brandt 1 A Bowles 1 above The 1 above simulation 1 about the 1 About JASSS 1 about 20 1 about 0 1 abbreviation of 1 A B 1 a b 1 a and 1 A3 indicate 1 A3 C3 1 A2 C2 1 A2 and 1 A 2012 1 A 2008 1 A 2007 1 A 2005 1 A 200 1 A2 0 1 A1 C1 1 A1 A2 1 A1 0 1 a0003442 pub2 1 9 Investment 1 9 Figure 1 992 A3 1 991 A3 1 99 17 1 9909 1983 1 9904 992 1 9865 200 1 9780470015902 a0003442 1 97 125 1 8 where 1 8 suffers 1 8 Mean 1 8 Figure 1 8 examines 1 8 C 1 8 because 1 8 are 1 8 A 1 8721 00173 1 830 C3 1 82 doi 1 82 2 1 80113 4 1 7 where 17 the society 1 7 Simulation 1 7 ll 1 7 In 1 7 and 1 79 82 1 78 doi 1 71 doi 1 71 2 1 70 5 1 6 x 16 value of 1 6 The 1 6 Simulation 1 6 shows 1 6868 137 1 66 doi 1 6 5 1 64 78 1 6 1305 1 6 1 1 60 71 1 60 66 16 0 4 1 6 0 1 5 where 15 variable size 15 the evolution 1 5 The 1 5 the 1 5 tests 15 size population 1 5 Simulation 1 5 shows 1 5 respectively 15 punishment and 15 and sexual 1 5 and 15 altruistic punishment 1 5962 171 1 5833 1905 1 5833 1858 1 57 doi 1 551 B2 1 54 1 1 5193 05 1 5 1410 1 50 respectively 1 50 and 1 4 where 1 4 Simulation 1 4 Nearly 14 in Figure 1 4 http 1 4 html 14 doi 10 1 4 CLAUSSEN 1 4489 1390 1 442 C2 1 4416 200 1 4396 991 1 4392 551 1 415 6868 1 406 PRESTON 1 406755 VAN 14 0 5 1 3 Simulation 13 sexual selection 13 s 0 1 3 s 1 3 P_ 1 3indicates the 13 et al 13 as a 1 394 406 1 38 POTGIETER 1 371 1687 1 35 57 1 35 2 1 3501 830 1 342 doi 1 3 394 1 3 331 1 331 342 1 33 1 1 327 5962 1 3208 442 1 31 Mar 1 3 1375 1 31 3 1 3058 Save 12 that the 1 2 Simulation 12 results of 1 2 P_ 1 2 MP 1 2 Model 1 2 Javascript 1 2 individual 1 2 illustrates 1 2 if 12 i e 1 2 Given 1 2 For 1 2 Figure 1 2C except 1 2 97 1 279 1734 1 2 79 1 2780 SOBER 1 267 1456 1 2601 200 1 24 Feb 1 22 1 1 2 169 1 213 1 1 211 4489 1 2111 GINTIS 1 2 111 1 20 When 1 20 http 1 20 html 1 206 2 12 0 6 1 2 025101 1 2016 Therefore 1 2016 Published 1 2016 Individual 1 2016 Abstract 1 2016 1 2015 where 1 2015 Simulations 1 2015 N 1 2015 In 1 2015 Fluctuation 1 2015 assumption 1 2015 and 1 2015 Altruism 1 2015 Accepted 1 20150087 doi 1 2015 0087 1 2014 11 1 2013 while 1 2013 The 1 2013 Based 1 2012 we 1 2012 The 1 2012 Sexual 1 2012 Selection 1 2012 and 1 2012 Altruism 1 2011 to 1 2011 This 1 2011 Morality 1 2011 introduced 1 2011 Individual 1 2011 In 1 2011 However 1 2011 Attractiveness 1 2011 05 1 2010 Punishers 1 2010 proposed 1 2010 Our 1 2010 Co 1 200 Treatments 1 200 males 1 200 C1 1 200 B1 1 200 A3 1 200 A2 1 2008 We 1 2008 Analytical 1 2007 was 1 2007 Via 1 2007 via 1 2007 To 1 2007 The 1 2007 Sexual 1 2007 Selection 1 2007 Researches 1 2007 Inclusive 1 2007 Behavior 1 2007 and 1 2005 Non 1 2005 Miller 1 2005 Genetic 1 2005 e 1 2002 via 1 2002 The 1 2002 Particularly 1 2002 New 1 2002 Gintis 1 2002 Cross 1 2002 Altruistic 1 2001 Religions 1 2001 McAndrew 1 2001 Costly 1 2000 with 1 2000 The 1 2000 the 1 2000 Strong 1 2000 Social 1 2000 paves 1 2000 In 1 2000 By 1 2000 2111 1 2000 1239 1 2 000 1 1 x 1 1 when 1 1 we 1 1 Treatments 1 1 the 1 1 Simulation 1 1 shows 1 1 regardless 1 1 pp 1 1 P_ 1 1 now 1 1 nature 1 1 MD 1 1 making 11 in this 1 1 For 1 1 Figure 1 1 D 1 1C indicates 1 1C being 1 1 CAPTION 11 C and 1 1B punishment 1 1B Meanwhile 1 1B and 1 1A no 1 1A 1B 1 1999 Unto 1 1999 McAndrew 1 1997 The 1 1997 Axelrod 1 1990 Sober 1 1990 Group 1 1987 The 1 1987 Boyd 1 1986 with 1 1986 Studying 1 1985 doi 1 1984 without 1 1984 The 1 1983 The 1 1981 The 1 1981 Sugiyama 1 1981 Axelrod 1 1979 1985 1 1971 The 1 1971 Ridley 1 1964 The 1 1964 Dugatkin 1 1964 and 1 1958 Random 1 1958 As 1 19 38 1 1907 HOUCHMANDZADEH 1 1905 1907 1 1859 BOYD 1 1858 1859 1 1805 Copyright 1 17 Oct 1 179 doi 1 1790 AXELROD 1 1784 1790 1 176 3 1 1734 1784 1 171 doi 1 171 171 1 17 11537 1 169 179 1 1687 20150087 1 1 64 1 15ZDB134 For 1 149 MCANDREW 1 1467 8721 1 1456 1979 1 145 3 1 1424 TRIVERS 1 1410 1424 1 14 1 1 140 GINTIS 1 13AZD061 15ZDB134 1 1396 BARTA 1 139 6 1 1390 1396 1 1380 FEHR 1 1375 1380 1 137 140 1 1305 RAIHANI 1 127 60 1 125 MORAN 1 1239 LANGTON 1 122352999 TRAULSEN 1 120 149 1 1 200 1 119 HAMILTON 1 1 19 1 1183068 RIDLEY 1 116 DUGATKIN 1 11542 doi 1 11537 11542 1 1126 science 1 1 120 1 11 2 1 111 116 1 1111 1467 1 1 103 1 11 006 1 10 but 1 1098 rstb 1 1098 rspb 1 1086 406755 1 1073 pnas 1 103 119 1 1017 S0305004100033193 1 1016 S0022 1 10 1126 1 10 1111 1 10 1086 1 10 1073 1 10 1017 1 10 1006 1 10 1002 1 100 they 1 100 periods 1 100 In 1 1006 jtbi 1 1002 9780470015902 1 0 with 1 0 to 10 the value 1 0 The 10 Simulation results 10 on the 10 is a 1 0 have 10 Figure 8 1 0 C 1 0 B 1 0 9909 1 0 9904 1 0 9865 1 05 80113 1 05 007 10 5 000 1 0 4416 1 0 4396 1 0 4392 1 0 3501 1 0 3208 1 0 3 1 0 2601 1 025101 CLAVIEN 1 0 2 1 0087 BELL 1 007 BOYD 1 006 JAFFE 1 001 in 1 00173 MILLER 1 000 Robustness 1 000 periods 1 000 Parameters 1 000 or 1 000 of 1 000 It 1 000 Final