Are You a Nerd or a Geek?

Photo
Related ArticleCredit Henning Wagenbreth
Student Opinion - The Learning NetworkStudent Opinion - The Learning Network

Questions about issues in the news for students 13 and older.

Gadget wristwatches are all the rage. “The Big Bang Theory” often tops TV ratings. Gaming is definitely mainstream. Has society embraced geek culture?

Are you a nerd or a geek?


In the article “We’re All Nerds Now,” Noam Cohen writes:

In 2005, Randall Munroe, a young NASA robotics expert, posted to the web a comic about the mystical number pi. Among the infinite string of digits were letters that spelled out, “Help I’m trapped in a universe factory.”

His pi comic spread quickly, and nearly a decade later Mr. Munroe sits atop a small empire built around xkcd, an online comic revered by science students, computer programmers and Silicon Valley workers.

On Wednesday, Mr. Munroe’s first book, “What If?,” debuted at No. 1 on The New York Times nonfiction hardcover best-seller list. “What If?” is a series of questions and answers on technically bizarre topics, like what would happen if the entire world directed laser pointers at the moon. (Not much, it turns out, unless you used really, really big lasers.)

And, as you may have heard, Apple last week introduced a new version of an old geek totem — the gadget wristwatch. With millions watching via computer, Tim Cook, the Apple chief executive, who has an industrial engineering degree, unveiled three versions of the watch, hoping to broaden the appeal of a fashion accessory traditionally worn by the calculus crowd.

Never before has the boundary between geek culture and mainstream culture been so porous. Beyond Mr. Munroe’s popularity and the national obsession with Apple products, other examples abound. Whether it is TV series like “The Big Bang Theory” and “Silicon Valley,” or comic-book movies such as this year’s top-grossing title, “Guardians of the Galaxy,” or the runner-up, “Captain America: The Winter Soldier,” or fantasy-based fiction like the “Game of Thrones” books (and HBO show), once-fringe, nerd-friendly obsessions like gadgets, comic books and fire-breathing dragons are increasingly everyone’s obsessions.

Students: Read the entire article, then tell us …

— Are you a nerd or a geek?

— Has our society fully embraced geek culture? Can someone now declare, without shame or embarrassment, “I am a nerd”? Is being a nerd or a geek something to be proud of?

— Is it cool to be a nerd or a geek in your school? Or, is being good at science, or the high scorer on the math team, still not going to win a teenager any popularity awards?


Students 13 and older are invited to comment below. Please use only your first name. For privacy policy reasons, we will not publish student comments that include a last name.

Comments are no longer being accepted.

I can be a geek when it comes to computers and technology, but I don’t think I really fit the nerd/geek stereotype. Honestly, I think people are so judgmental about those people who are judgmental, someone could say that they are a nerd without being mad fun of. If someone makes fun of them, I’m sure tons of people would go to their side and defend them. You kinda want to fit into both, because sure there are popular people, but being smart is also very important.

i dont think im a nerd nor a geek but i think that is perfectly okay in today’s society to be a “nerd” or a “geek”. Although, people will still not consider them popular or cool even though they will probably grow up to make the most money.

I am a nerd, and I do not think society has completely embraced the nerd/geek culture. While being a nerd/geek is something to be proud of, I have learned that if you are a male, you can stand up and say, “I AM A NERD/GEEK,” and no one will judge you. However, if you are a female and you stand up to say, “I AM A NERD/GEEK,” you are going to get bombarded with phrases like, “you’re a fake geek girl!” “LOL I bet you haven’t seen the last season of Big Bang Theory!” “Silly girl, get back into the kitchen and make me a sandwich!” I guess it’s pretty okay in my school to be a geek/nerd, in some classes more than others.

I don’t think being a nerd or a geek is something to be ashamed of, but I feel like some peers might put other students down because of their natural abilities in academics.

I’m a geek, but honestly I don’t see the difference, other than the interests. Nerds (in my community) are those who are into comics, superheroes and things like that. Geeks are those who are into computers, are technology savvy and like anime, (for lack of other word) geeky TV shows, and such.

I don’t think the society has fully embraced it, it’s “okay” for a teenager-young adult to be geeky or nerdy, but if you’re an adult and you are still watching or reading those things, you’re seen as weird and you’re kind of pushed out of the social circle in the adult world.

It’s perfectly alright to be a nerd or a geek in our school, how I see it, the kids here don’t really mind what you like or don’t like, they just let you kinda do your own thing.

I think I would be a geek because I like to watch space movies and medieval fiction movies. I think that we have embraced being nerds or geeks just because of doing what you like. I don’t think you can say “I’m a nerd” without being a little embarrassed still. I don’t think it is something to be proud of. It’s not really cool to be a nerd or geek in my school, it isn’t the “cool” thing. Joining the Math Club doesn’t help you at all.

1. I really do not like either of the articles because people interpret it different. If I had to say one though I would choose nerd.

2. Saying “I am a nerd” is still not socially acceptable to full extent yet, because any way you say it people see nerds as usually very smart people that study all the time, where glasses, plaid shirts, braces, etc. It’s just the symbol of a nerd in today’s society.
Being a nerd/geek is still something to be proud of yourself for because then you have confidence in yourself and being a nerd/geek means your intelligent.

3. My school specifically I do not thing being a nerd/geek will make you popular, because most of the more popular kids in the school are either people with high humor or are in sports.

I don’t think that it is necessarily cool to be a geek or a nerd, but I think it is cool to try as hard as you can in everything you do. On the other hand I think that it is not cool to try not to do as good as you can do in school and in life.

I am more of a geek than a nerd, but I am a little bit of both. I don’t think that our society has fully embraced geek culture. There are people that are nerds and our proud of it. There is nothing wrong with being a nerd or a geek. It is cool to be anything at our school. You should not worry about what others think and should just be what you want to be.

I think I’m a nerd because I enjoy new gadgets and new things. I think society still hasn’t really truly accepted being a geek or a nerd but I also think in a way it is being accepted more widely. Being a nerd or a geek is accepted in our school because some of the things nerds and geeks do are like their “sport” and we have a great school and everyone pretty much appreciates what one another does.

Often I jokingly here people call me a nerd just because I am good academically and that is what I picture when someone says nerd but there is so much more to it than just academics. I believe most of society has embraced geek culture because the so called geeks are usually the more open minded people and they have the best chance to come up with the great future ideas. In the movie and TV part though, I think in shows such as “The Big Bang Theory,” lets people laugh at the geeks or nerds portrayed in the show, while in the comic book movies they are liked because they are action packed. In school, I don’t think that being a nerd or geek will win any popularity points because some students take that if someone is smarter than them or if they don’t like the same stuff as them, then they will not like that person.

I feel like that I am more of a geek. I am much more fascinated by technology rather than books. I love books but I think it is really cool when people can build things like robots that can do things on their own. I think that our society has embraced geek culture as a large majority of our population is fascinated and rapped up in technology much like geeks. I think being a nerd or geek is something you can be proud of because it shows what you like. I wouldn’t say that being smart wins you popularity awards but it can in some cases. Being smart isn’t something you would think of that makes someone popular, your personality makes you popular and if you are smart and have a good, friendly personality, then you can be popular.

I can proudly say that I am a geek. I think our society has embraced the look of nerds or geeks. Most people in my opinion when saying their a geek or a nerd aren’t fully a nerd or geek. If your’e a geek, don’t be afraid to say it. You should embrace who you are. To be a nerd in school can or can not be cool. If you don’t have the look or personality of “the cool kids”, then no its not cool. If you do, then yes, congrats you’re cool.

I guess I’m more of a geek. I’m still not sure exactly what the difference is between a nerd and a geek. I usually just think of them as the same thing. I know a bunch about comic books, Game of Thrones, and video games. I play DnD (Dungeon and Dragons) sometimes with friends. That’s pretty geeky. It’s really fun, so I don’t mind. I watch shows like Dragonball Z and Game of Thrones. I’m in love with Lord of the Rings. I think it can be cool to be one in our schools if you do it right. There are definitely fake nerd/geeks. Who want to be like one because it’s cool right now.

I am a geek. I think our society has embraced geek culture but it’s still not something that you can proclaim without being made fun of or looked down upon. In my school, if you’re a nerd or geek you fit in with that crowd but you are not popular with the entire school. You may get made fun of or laughed at because of it, but I think that if you enjoy it you should continue to be happy in what you love.

I would say that Im a geek and a nerd. I love Syfy shows like Doctor Who and I love giving facts to people.

I am definitley a geek (hipster), and with the society that we are in today it has become more popular among people to say yes I am a geek or yes I am a nerd but society has not yet fully accepted that some people are geeks or nerds. In my opinion it is something to be proud of, it is saying that you are diferent from most people and will not go with the crowd a good way to summerze this is the term ‘hipster’ or is different and not afraid to share that fact. In my school it is not neccisarily cool to be a geek or nerd or hipster, you are usually looked down upon or considered an outstider or uncool. Sometimes it is better be smarter and different.

I am a geek and that I am certain of. I feel like now with social media and new t.v. shows everyone is a geek so yes I think society has accepted the geek culture. Being a nerd or a geek is definitely is something to be proud of. You are showing your love for something and that is not something to be ashamed of. Being a nerd or a geek is not all the way accepted but it’s making its way into the society at my high school.

I feel like I am more of a geek in a way that I have very deep interests in certain things like netflix or volleyball. I am not academically geeky I would say I do enjoy reading and certain “geeky” tv shows.

I think i am a geek because i like the shows that are kind of geeky. It shouldn’t matter if your a geek or a nerd if your smart that’s okay because you try your hardest and you don’t just want to fail at everything. So trying you don’t have to be a geek or a nerd. You cant be one you just are one.

I believe I am more of a geek, because, although I may not be interested in technology, and I am most definitly not tech savy. Also, I definitly am not very much interested in science. With that being said, I also am a nerd, because I may not be full fledged academically excellent I do believe I excell. In my opinion, one is neither just a nerd or a geek, but a mix of both.

I believe that our society has fully embraced geek culture, but not necessarily the word “geek” or “nerd.” Many teens probably would probably not refer to themselves as geeks or nerds, and most likely would not declare it out loud, but of course there are a few exceptional people. Being a nerd or geek is prideful for some, and for others it could be considered torture. It is honestly up to whoever you are talking to. I consider myself to be somewhat nerdy and geeky, and I am more neutral to it. I am not really proud of it, but it isn’t something that is a flaw of mine either. In our culture now though, I believe a lot of people are a little geeky or nerdy.

Regarding the article I spent quite a lot of time deciding between if I was a geek or a nerd! Though, the two are very similar, in the end it came down to one thing, fandoms! Which falls into the category for me, a geek.

I found student questions two and three very odd. Because if I love Doctor Who, Sherlock, Supernatural, Anime etc. Who cares what anybody else thinks! I would like it if NOBODY watched it. But luckily this day in age, there are tons of geeks and fangirls like me! And I’ve met some of my best friends because of it.

Even in school, being a geek is cool! I’ll often find when I wear a fandom shirt, from either an anime or one of my favorite series. I will get lots of compliments! In my school we LITERALLY have clubs for fangirls like me. So if I had to some this response all up. Geeks are accepted, and even if they weren’t. I would be one anyways.

I’d have to say I’m both a nerd and a geek. In today’s society, I believe that being a nerd/geek is becoming more and more popular. With it becoming more and more popular, you get people who pretend to be a nerd/geek just to fit in. For us true nerds/geeks this is highly frustrating. We can now declare that we are smart or in to comic books and not feel like we’re going to be ridiculed. However that is not always true.

Some of the Geeks/Nerds have more popularity from people lately because people choose to make that their personality. They are fake nerds. They strut around telling everyone “I’m a geek,” or “I’m a nerd.” When it’s not really who they are. A so-called “geek/nerd” can walk around and dress like a geek, and say they are a nerd when in reality, they never really are either. They might not even like Dungeons and Dragons, but everyone thinks they do. In my point of view, the “geeks” are trying to get attention. To them it is a social status, and none of the Star Wars movies or the Marvel Nightcrawler comic books even matter to them. A true nerd/geek is someone who can act like a nerd, and like nerd/geek things without it being so much of a social status and more of a way of living.

Advertisement